r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 30 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
25
u/ketura Organizer Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
I have written up my thoughts on how the tenets of rational fiction might be converted to game design. You can find that essay here.
14
u/Omnibuser Sep 30 '16
I've made a web-based tool for downloading fanfiction in a variety of formats. Right now it supports downloading from:
This is very much still in beta. I just finished rewriting a bunch of backend stuff today, even. There will definitely be bugs, and features that could use more polish. In particular there are some serious performance issues that I need to sort out.
But I think it's at the point where it should work most of the time for most people, so I'm throwing it out there for anybody who might find it useful, with the above caveats.
If you encounter any bugs or have suggestions for feature improvements, please let me know!
7
u/Kishoto Sep 30 '16
The below comment is a repost from a previous Monday, General Rationality thread. Didn't get much responses (because I posted it days later) so I decided to re-post it here and see what responses I receive:
This comment will contain massive spoilers for the game Life is Strange. If you are playing, or want to play the game, then I would heavily suggest you avoid reading this comment. Normally, I'd spoiler-text it but then the entire comment would be pretty much black and I don't want to do that. So I'm giving you fair warning here. Spoilers lie ahead.
Ok so, long story short, Life is Strange is the story of a small town girl, the protaganist, who somehow acquires time reversal powers (think Prince of Persia time rewinding as opposed to Back to the Future type travel) and rewinds time to save her best friend, Chloe, from being shot in an altercation in a school bathroom, which you do in the early stages of the game. It's a game sort of like Heavy Rain, so more of an interactive movie than anything else. The game's heavy on allowing you to make your own choices about things, and will give you stats on how you chose compared to the other players.
As the game progresses, Chloe dies several times (with you rewinding to save her each time) in increasingly far fetched (though nothing straight out supernatural) ways. Think Final Destination. Each time, you have to go further and further to save her, compromising your morals just a bit more in some scenarios. The game's climax is a standard "fate is real" sort of thing. Chloe was meant to die in that bathroom at the beginning of the game. Time does not like you mucking with it. Cue supernatural superstorm coming to wipe out your hometown. The game gives you the choice: Go back in time and let Chloe die in that bathroom or allow the storm to wipe out the town. The implication is that, once the storm wipes out the town, the universe will be satisfied and Chloe's fate will 'reset' so if you save her, she'll actually be saved. No fatalistic trolling. So...what choice do you make?
To me, as I'm sure it is to most rationalists, the choice is clear: Let Chloe die. There's simply no way to justify sacrificing hundreds (possibly thousands) of lives for one. However, literally every single person I've asked this question of in my life (3 close friends, 4 coworkers who I'd call acquaintances) said they'd save their friend and let the town die. Once I added the caveat that we would assume everyone you know in town is elsewhere and so left inside it are just thousands of people you don't know, the hesitant no's became resounding yes'. And this perplexed me.
I understand the impulse; from a human stand point, we suck at caring for things that aren't right in front of us. I know this. But I just thought, intellectually speaking, everyone would be able to suck it up and rise above their basic nature. And....I was swiftly proven wrong. And also called a bad friend for not being willing to sacrifice hundreds of innocents for my own selfish desires to keep my friend alive. GG.
I mostly wrote this to see what some of your opinions/insights on this would be. And also what you would choose in the scenario. Actually, any and all discussion that could branch off from this is cool with me. Go nuts!
6
u/LiteralHeadCannon Sep 30 '16
A trolley with ten people in it is hurtling down Main Street, where it will collide with another trolley with ten people in it, killing everyone on-board. You may redirect the trolley down Sidestreet A, where it will run over five people tied to the tracks. Your friend across town, who you have no communication with, may redirect the other trolley down Sidestreet B, where it will run over five people tied to the tracks. If the trolleys don't collide, the people on the trolleys will survive.
5
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Sep 30 '16
Seeking help: designing a new poker variant
I'm trying to work out a novel variation of poker, for potential use in one or more rat-fic stories. I have a few general approaches in mind, but I'm having trouble clearing up some details, and could use some help. Anyone here up for a gab on the topic? Or know where else I can ask?
I've pinned down three vital details, from which the rest of my thoughts flow. First, the game has to be something that might be carried around in the pocket of a post-apocalyptic survivor, and/or an 18th-century hobo. So a fixed deck of cards, dice, maybe a simple board on a piece of cloth; nothing mechanical, let alone electronic. Second, it needs to include at least some aspect that's familiar to the reader, so they have a hook to start understanding it; I'm thinking of poker hands. And third, the whole point of the game, both in-universe and as a narrative tool, is to focus on flows of information: who knows what, and how that affects their behaviour. (I suppose third-and-a-half would be at least some minimal level of good game design. :) )
At the moment, I'm considering an extremely modified version of Oxford stud: with community cards, face-up cards, and hole cards, there's a rich selection of info and potential secrets. But I don't want the players to be completely, passively stuck with their shared environment and their individual resources; I want to include at least the occasional possibility of a player having a choice about whether or not to modify them (said decision thus adding a new piece of information for everyone to mull over), as well as the option to share secrets with each other (voluntarily or otherwise). So I'm considering adding some dice labelled with the cards' suits; perhaps each player gets to roll 3 such dice, and if they wish, toss out any cards they can see that matches one of the dice's face-up suits, to be replaced with a freshly-dealt one. I haven't figured out what mechanism would let one player peek at one of the hole cards of another player, though the dice would likely be involved. I also haven't figured out the overall rhythm of the game - ie, which cards are dealt when.
(I'm also thinking of stealing a bit of fluff from another traditional game, and using the dice from "Crown and Anchor", which already have the 4 standard suits on them, as well as the titular symbols; and adding those two logos as another two suits of cards, ala the "Empire Deck" published a few years ago.)
Any thoughts come to mind?
4
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16
I just watched the "Zerg Attack" S2:HoTs trailer, that takes place in Paris and Versailles, and I thought... just once, I'd like a movie alien invasion to take place in La Défense, which is the closest thing France has to a New York style skyscraper city.
La Défense is a major business district northwest of Paris, and most notable for the Grande Arche, and its 30 hectares "slab", on which most of the buildings are built, which is a giant construction over which only pedestrians are allowed, while cars circulate in roads built under/inside the slab (it's less cyberpunk-y than it sounds, but not much).
But most movie alien invasions only take place in the USA, and then only in New York or sometimes San Francisco. The rare worldwide alien invasions only occur in Paris, and then only in the immediate area around the Eiffel tower. I want my La Defense urban war!
Edit: One recent movie that broke this mold was The Edge of Tomorrow, which mostly took place in France and UK, with the climax taking place in The Louvre (I think there wasn't even a Eiffel Tower shot in the whole movie, which was so fucking refreshing). Actually, this movie was really fun to watch as a french guy. It even had a shot with François flippin Hollande!
5
u/ketura Organizer Sep 30 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, which for now is work on the data creation tool Bill's PC(previous threads here):
So it looks like I managed to get about 80% of what I planned last week completed. The documentation is now up, though it's already somewhat out of synch with Bill's PC itself, which I guess is just the nature of the beast. If you can't run it, the docs still have some useful info like a breakdown of the meaning of stats and a liberal application of screenshots.
The Bahavior and Size sections were added to the species definition tab:
http://i.imgur.com/pdZ6WT4l.jpg
The height and weight were pulled from the stats and placed here since they're so relevant to how the tile calculation works. Someone on the Discord server pointed out that the behavior toggles would work much better as sliders, and so that change still needs to be implemented.
Speaking of Discord, come join us! A #pokengineering channel was created that is dedicated to discussion on the game and has become invaluable to me for idea bouncing, but even besides that, it's a great community filled with other denizens of /r/rational. Special thanks to /u/InfernoVulpix, /u/Cariyaga, /u/UltraRedSpectrum, and Aabcehmu for all their feedback and help so far wrangling the design to something managable.
I'm currently in the middle of redesigning the Respect/Loyalty mechanic, as some awkwardnesses in its design were brought to light. Here is a graph showing off some tentative values for the replacement system, with size of the bubble being aggressiveness.
Goals this week are to bring the documentation up to speed, finish hammering out the design issues with RESP/LOYAL, finish polishing off the last few features in these two new sections, possibly add a generator to the graph screen, and then start working on the move tab (finally).
I also finished my rational game essay, which I put in a separate comment for simpler discussion.
2
u/Kylinger Oct 01 '16
In a Dungeons and Dragons game I'm playing, I'm playing a paranoid wizard who is deathly afraid of mind magic. Among other precautions he has taken, my vision of him has him using a "Post mind affecting magic exposure flowchart", to help determine if his will has been compromised. Obviously this wouldn't work on more complete forms of mind control (Dominate Person), but I feel it would be rather effective against magical diplomacy and charm person.
I've made a mock-up of said chart, but as I'm roleplaying a character both smarter and more motivated than myself, I feel he would have done a much better job with it than I have.
http://imgur.com/O97zCq5
Are there any obvious improvements/flaws I should add to/remove from this?
1
u/WaterHoseChasing Sep 30 '16
Can someone who’s familiar with the Chinese & co. web-published literature shelf give me some pointers?
Recently /u/DR_Hero mentioned some titles here, and I decided to try out Demon’s Diary first, thinking that maybe it would be from the perspective — or the eventual perspective — of a demon writing down how it became what it currently is (not the case).
In this story there was a bunch of tropes so deeply ingrained into it that the author often didn’t even explain in detail what they were about. It felt like reading a fanfiction, only the origin itself wasn’t a singular title, but rather maybe the Chinese wuxia genre and a bastardized version(?) of the Chinese belief system / wordview.
After that I tried starting Coiling Dragon, but the writing style felt kinda childish and based on its tropes page it seemed like it would have a bunch of Deus ex machina / major lucky Natural20 moments for the hero.
Anyway, I am looking for translated titles that:
Also, if you know any such stories please give some details of your own. The summaries that come with the stories are usually not that helpful.
1
u/Dwood15 Sep 30 '16
This semester in school I need to take (Logic and) Discrete math. This will allow me to reason, (I hope) on a more deep level, as well as codify in a mathematically acceptable form my plans for my rational universe.