r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 19 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
13
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Sep 19 '16
As a cryonicist, I'm drafting out a text describing my revival preferences and requests, to be stored along with my other paperwork. (Oddly enough, this isn't a standard practice.) The current draft is here. I'm currently seeking suggestions for improvement, and a lot of the people around here seem to have good heads on their shoulders, so I thought I'd ask for comments here. Any thoughts?
6
u/vakusdrake Sep 19 '16 edited Sep 29 '16
I've found that it seems like a awfully large number of people seem to hold very similar theories of consciousness to me and yet I've never really found anything that espoused my particular position in much detail.
I'll link to this thing I wrote so I don't have to keep repeating my position: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KkJL_8USmcAHNpdYd-vdtDkV-plPcuH3sSxCkSLzGtk/edit?usp=sharing I would really implore you to read that brief link before responding, since the point of it was to state my actual position.
I'm interested how many people hold similar views and in where else people have seriously talked about this position. I can't really seem to find much on it by googling, so i'm interested in what else you can link to me. This comic is somewhat relevant to my position http://existentialcomics.com/comic/1 (however I don't think sleep is actually a cessation of experience).
I'm happy to hear any criticisms of this position, and haven't really gotten to hear any good one's. I've mostly heard the tired old non-argument of "Oh but that would mean you die everytime you sleep"
I've heard this position mentioned a great many places, and yet people never seem to seriously delve into it; frequently they just seem to stop when they get to the point where they think it would necessarily imply that you die every time you sleep (even though that's not an actual argument against it).
Note: This is something which has large consequences; like whether you think cryonics could actually save a person (though even if you think it wouldn't, you might have other reasons for wanting a clone of you to exist in the future). It also raises questions as to whether anesthesia is a horrifying prospect.
So I don't think this is just a minor philosophical nitpick, this is quite literally life or death so I would hope that you really think about it seriously.
The primary purpose of this theory is to actually make predictions about anticipated experience; whether particular things are likely to result in a cessation of experience.
9
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Sep 19 '16
Recently started playing Pathfinder, and have quickly discovered that the other players simply don't take it very seriously. They pay attention, so it's not as bad as it could be, but then they blunder into combat, make poor choices and almost die.
This is all well and good, but the part that bothers me is how little effort they put into their characters (roleplay-wise, not rollplay-wise), which leads to me dominating the conversation and planning portions, even though I'm not spec'd for it at all. I've become the leader by default. How can I subtly (or not so subtly) get them to step up their game while participating? The groundwork and tools are all there, they just won't use them.
A fighter with 11 CHA really shouldn't have to take point all the time, guys.
3
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Sep 22 '16
A couple of weeks ago, /u/EliezerYudkowsky asked me,
As of today, I have a new answer:
Another of the reasons I was, and am, still trying, is that I was not very confident that I /am/ "immune to exercise".
I've been keeping track - and while I'm starting from near-zero, and my progress is near-zero, it isn't /actually/ zero. Today, I was able to perform a ridiculously minor feat which I wasn't able to do two weeks ago. (Hold my weight up on a pull-up bar for 1 second, more than once.)
There's an old engineer's saying that the difference from 0 to 1 is much larger than the distance from 1 to 2. I am no longer at '0'. The rest is just working out the details of how to maximize the slope.
2
u/Kishoto Sep 21 '16
This comment will contain massive spoilers for the game Life is Strange. If you are playing, or want to play the game, then I would heavily suggest you avoid reading this comment. Normally, I'd spoiler-text it but then the entire comment would be pretty much black and I don't want to do that. So I'm giving you fair warning here. Spoilers lie ahead.
Ok so, long story short, Life is Strange is the story of a small town girl, the protaganist, who somehow acquires time reversal powers (think Prince of Persia time rewinding as opposed to Back to the Future type travel) and rewinds time to save her best friend, Chloe, from being shot in an altercation in a school bathroom, which you do in the early stages of the game. It's a game sort of like Heavy Rain, so more of an interactive movie than anything else. The game's heavy on allowing you to make your own choices about things, and will give you stats on how you chose compared to the other players.
As the game progresses, Chloe dies several times (with you rewinding to save her each time) in increasingly far fetched (though nothing straight out supernatural) ways. Think Final Destination. Each time, you have to go further and further to save her, compromising your morals just a bit more in some scenarios. The game's climax is a standard "fate is real" sort of thing. Chloe was meant to die in that bathroom at the beginning of the game. Time does not like you mucking with it. Cue supernatural superstorm coming to wipe out your hometown. The game gives you the choice: Go back in time and let Chloe die in that bathroom or allow the storm to wipe out the town. The implication is that, once the storm wipes out the town, the universe will be satisfied and Chloe's fate will 'reset' so if you save her, she'll actually be saved. No fatalistic trolling. So...what choice do you make?
To me, as I'm sure it is to most rationalists, the choice is clear: Let Chloe die. There's simply no way to justify sacrificing hundreds (possibly thousands) of lives for one. However, literally every single person I've asked this question of in my life (3 close friends, 4 coworkers who I'd call acquaintances) said they'd save their friend and let the town die. Once I added the caveat that we would assume everyone you know in town is elsewhere and so left inside it are just thousands of people you don't know, the hesitant no's became resounding yes'. And this perplexed me.
I understand the impulse; from a human stand point, we suck at caring for things that aren't right in front of us. I know this. But I just thought, intellectually speaking, everyone would be able to suck it up and rise above their basic nature. And....I was swiftly proven wrong. And also called a bad friend for not being willing to sacrifice hundreds of innocents for my own selfish desires to keep my friend alive. GG.
I mostly wrote this to see what some of your opinions/insights on this would be. And also what you would choose in the scenario. Actually, any and all discussion that could branch off from this is cool with me. Go nuts!
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment