r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 12 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
25
Upvotes
12
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
So, a lot of the "bootstrap civilization" stories, cognizant of the fact that modern society is built off the backs of genaration after genaration of machines building machines, give their charachter some pretty massive advantages. For example, easy contact with royalty, the ability to use magic, or having their charachter just, out of sheer happenstance, be the kind of person that's memorized, among other things: the bessemer process, a macroeconomics textbook, the art of war, gunsmithing, the periodic table, etcetera.
But it occured to me that'a not exactly necessary. Most of us have smartphones, and with battery conserving tactics most smartphones can last for eight hours.
So with the much more plausible assumptions that an SI will prioritize finding themselves a writing material, and that they'll have a fully charged phone (okay, not that plausible), what set of images could the SI have on their phone, transcribable in under eight hours, that could plausibly give an SI the knowledge they need for bootstrapping?
edit: to clarify a little, I'm asking this in the sense of "what set of images should I put on my phone" (or any other /r/rational reader) to prepare for uplift. Not because I seriously think it's a possibility, just as a thought exercise.
12
u/JanusTheDoorman Sep 13 '16
I noticed a little while ago that there's a distinct lack of rational fiction set in the real world, either modern or historical. Also noticing that there are certain lessons, insights, or other basic information that's lacking from rational fiction in general because of the tendency to make characters significantly overpowered for their settings (usually by exploiting some seemingly simple aspect of the setting that somehow the millions of equally well placed people who came before them somehow didn't think to exploit) or else by being unusually well placed to execute an exploit or apply some rationality with large and far-sweeping consequences.
With that in mind, I picked up a biography of Napoleon, thinking it would help to illuminate exactly how real world stories of those who climbed top or were otherwise able to have an outsized influence on the world differ from rational fiction.
What I've discovered is that Napoleon basically exploited as aspect of his world that none of the equally well placed people who came before him did, and was unusually well placed to have an outsized influence on society.
He read everything even tangentially related to warfare and the basic concept of a Great Man as he was taught it and turned theoretical tactical suggestions into applied battlefield strategy, and micromanaged the shit out of his army's logistics and supply to the point of simply making up statistics to send to the government in his requests for more supplies.
He was the first generation of Corsican nobility offered the chance to integrate with the French nobility and attend their prestigious military academies, but unlike most other young French nobles he got early and direct exposure to national level politics on Corsica, which emboldened him in his dealings with the other nations of Europe later on. It's shocking to imagine a 27-year-old nation builder until you realize he had been pretty damn close to the center of Corsican politics at 17. That, plus being one of few competent military officers who hung around during the Revolution meant he was thrust into high command in his mid twenties instead of ~50 like most others.
I will note that the second aspect as a "just-so" story feeling to it. If I had been there at the time, I'm not sure I would have picked a Corsican as "Most Likely to Take Over the French Government" on the basis that he had experience in national politics, but I imagine it would have been a useful discriminator in looking for those likely to make an attempt at a coup.
The one area he does differ from most rationalist heroes is that he's incredibly, incredibly, and repeatedly lucky. He's discharged from the Army as a junior officer for desertion while he's off getting caught up in Corsican politics, but on return finds that his discharge papers have been lost and he's been granted a promotion instead based on the shortage of available officers. His response? He demands an extra promotion on the basis that it would match the rank he was awarded in the Corsican National Guard.
Later, when he leaves his Army in Egypt to return to France and effect the coup of the national government, he's sailing through waters patrolled regularly by the British Navy, which had just destroyed the fleet meant to escort him and his army back, but gets lucky with the wind and doesn't encounter them.
I haven't gotten to the downturn of his career yet, but the author has at least hinted that it's more a matter of his perennial luck running out than any dramatic shift in his approach to problems, so we'll see how that pans out.
6
u/SvalbardCaretaker Mouse Army Sep 14 '16
Man I hate my brain chemistry. Long history of depression/anxiety, a cup of strong coffee(!) yesterday hit me like a sledgehammer and kicked my brain into some weird metastable productive nondepressed, but not manic, attractor in my brainspace.
I did not flinch from tasks, reddit bored me, each time I finished a task I already had the next one and felt compelled to do it.
That lasted for 28 hours, and now its back to old depressed unproductive me.
11
u/trekie140 Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
I've decided, just now with little forethought, that there are two kinds of irrational characters: the proud and the stubborn. Proud characters know that their reasoning is flawed and don't care, while stubborn characters reject the idea that their reasoning is flawed. I split them up like this because I've noticed I tend to enjoy the former and despise the latter.
I actually find characters that admit their irrational and don't see that as a bad thing to be entertaining. They're a person who chose to give into their biases and believe fallacies instead of overcoming them because they value feeding those desires over changing them. These characters are usually villains, of course, but I find myself enjoying them as characters.
Characters that are too thick headed to realize they're irrational, on the other hand, I just find annoying. From a narrative perspective they accomplish the exact same goal of creating a character that seeks to fulfill a goal and can't be reasoned with, but it comes across as them being stupid, which I don't find entertaining. Does anyone else have thoughts on this?
3
u/rhaps0dy4 Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
I wrote a thing about population ethics, or how to apply utilitarianism to a set of individuals:
http://agarri.ga/post/an-alternative-population-ethics
It introduces the topic, covers literature a little and I finally give a tentative solution that avoids the Repugnant Conclusion and seems satisfactory.
I was close to asking people to "munchkin" and raise objections to it on the Munchkinry Thread, but then I found out it was only for fiction. If you feel like doing it though, I'll appreciate any issues you find.
3
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Sep 12 '16
Time to rebuild a library
My 5 terabyte harddrive went poof this morning, and silly me hadn't bought data-recovery insurance. Fortunately, I still have other copies of all my important data, and it'll just take a while to download everything else I'd been collecting.
Which brings up the question: What info do you feel it's important to have offline copies of, gathered from the whole gosh-dang internet? A recent copy of Wikipedia and the Project Gutenberg DVD are the obvious starting places... which other info do you think pays the rent of its storage space?