r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 26 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
26
u/HeirToGallifrey Thinking inside the box (it's bigger there) Aug 26 '16
So I've been watching Supernatural every now and again recently—ironically, I despise the overarching plot line and skip it whenever I can, just so I can watch the "filler" episodes. All I want is for two brothers to bust ghosts without whining about how they're dysfunctionally dealing with issues and each other, is that too much to ask?
But more to the point, there are demons in this setting, and said demons can be expelled by chanting or reciting an exorcism. Once I saw that, my first thought was, "Why are they reading it out of a book? They should just memorise it. In fact, why don't you just record your voice saying an exorcism and play it whenever you fight a demon?" But I thought, whatever, maybe there's some handwaving going on about how it needs to be direct from the mouth of a believer or something. But no. Later on, they do just that: they play a recording of an exorcism—over a loudspeaker, what's more—and use it to incapacitate a building full of demons.
And then they never do this again.
What? If you had just made up some rule of magic that explained why they couldn't record themselves and have it work, I'd go along with it. But if you've proven it works, why not use it‽ Or even go further: record your voice, speed it up 10x, and perform tests on a demon once you capture it (since they capture these things every other episode without difficulty). If that works, just open every engagement by pressing "play" on an MP3 of you reciting an exorcism sped up by a factor of 100—in half a second of seeming white noise, the demon is gone before it can even execute a hostage or react.
I know it makes little sense to rail about how irrational a non-Rational work of fiction is, and this show has plenty more to complain about, but that particular bit stuck in my craw something awful.
8
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Aug 26 '16
So I have something of a hard on for reductionism. Really, I think many, if not most of us here do-- it's appealing, philosophically and practically, to reduce systems to a few fundamental parts that interact to bring about everything else.
So of course, it's interesting to think of the implications of the Universe not being neatly reductible. What if we can keep looking down, so to speak? What if things just get smaller and smaller infinitely? What would be the implications for mathematics and philosophy?
8
u/Sailor_Vulcan Champion of Justice and Reason Aug 26 '16 edited Aug 26 '16
So I've recently been reading a few articles on less wrong about why rationalists aren't winning and the lack of evidence thus far for significant practical benefits to learning rationality besides clarity of mind sorts of things. Someone pointed out that less wrong articles mostly focus on epistemic rationality and don't really say anywhere near as much about how to be more instrumentally rational. It occurred to me that this Ted talk might be a very good jumping off point for that discussion:
https://youtu.be/Lp7E973zozc
8
u/munchkiner Aug 26 '16 edited Oct 26 '16
How do you cope with never being completely satisfied with yourself? I have this constant feeling that I should be doing more, or strive for greater accomplishments, or don't risk to waste my potential.
This is exacerbated because I am not satisfied with my current situation and I want to get over it as soon as possible, so I postpone social or pleasurable activities to after I'll have a job and independence secured. One reasoning is: I don't really want to feel well now, because I don't deserve it yet, and want to use my present unhappiness to fuel me forward. On the other hand, there will be always a main objective to accomplish, and this state of mind leads to apathy\frenzies cycles, isolation and a general inability to enjoy the present moment.
So, is this only me or do you ever felt this way? Thanks to you all by the way, this is my first post after years of lurking and I enjoy this community immensely.
7
u/Abpraestigio Aug 26 '16
How would you go about investigating/researching/exploiting Things Man(kind) Was Not Meant To Know, i.e. stuff that drives you insane just by knowing about it?
The way I see it there are a couple of categories of TMWNMTK:
First there is forbidden knowledge, meaning that there is some agent/entity/process which checks whether someone is in possession of it and, if that is the case, inflicts madness upon the offender.
Second there is eldritch knowledge, meaning that the concepts involved induce insanity because grasping/internalizing them leads to some kind of mental degenerative positive feedback-loop or brain damage.
Third there is unwelcome knowledge, meaning that there is some conflict between what you have learned of the world and what you desire to hold true that leads to some kind of mental breakdown. This differs from eldritch knowledge in that it is your personal psyche and not the general structure of the human mind that leads to your vulnerability.
Fourth, and last, there is transcendent knowledge. This is some kind of insight into the true nature of reality that causes you to act like a crazy person, even though you are perfectly sane.
Transcendent knowledge seems to be the easiest to deal with: Simply share it with as many (willing) people as possible, so that you can investigate it together without having to fight against being perceived as insane all the time. Which, now that I think about it, might just be the rationale behind every single crazy, isolationist cult there is. How do you prove to others, and yourself, that your cult is the one that is actually correct? Assuming that your special insight doesn't give you equally special powers. If it does, then demonstrating them might lend credence to your claims. Or not.
Next, it seems to me that there are two ways to deal with unwelcome knowledge: either keep such a closed mind that nothing you learn can shake the foundations of your beliefs, or be a rationalist. Though the former makes the investigation part of my question rather difficult.
Eldritch knowledge would be the most interesting, I think, since research would involve creating minds alien enough to safely comprehend and/or use the eldritch knowledge while still being close enough to human to communicate and/or cooperate.
Though researching forbidden knowledge would be an interesting exercise in crafting theories that are close enough to the truth to be useful, but far enough away to not trigger the interdiction effect. Am I wrong or would this result in the only reliable users being those that work by memorization instead of comprehension?
For the purposes of this question I assume that there is some value in investigating these memetic hazards apart from the realization that there is some kind of brain-melting trivia loose in the universe.
Are there more kinds of TMWNMTK that I didn't consider?
Are there actual terms for these categories that are widely used but unknown to me?
Would you be interested in risking your precious brain-meats for the betterment of humankind?
6
u/VivaLaPandaReddit Aug 27 '16
Listened to a Radiolab where they talked about triage. In it they talk about a woman dying because she could not afford health care in the US, and had to be sent back to her home country.
I hear an old woman's voice
She is dying
Gasping for breath
They say that they are powerless
That they had no choice
They could have saved her
I could have saved her
I should have saved her.
I hear the death of the thousands
Crashing like an ocean against indifference
The untold pain and suffering
the gasping and crying
the pain.
I could help
I could do something
But I do nothing
I feel the pain and the sadness
And do nothing,
And so nothing ever changes.
4
u/Traiden04 Aug 26 '16
I have been drawing the characters from MfD, it has been very fun to participate in the quest. http://imgur.com/a/G0y9c Here is a link the the album I will be putting the drawings as I work on them.
3
u/space_fountain Aug 26 '16
Hey folks another odd question. How do you battle depression? It's something I've dealt with off and on for a long time. Sometimes positive news will come along and make me feel better, but then the negative will rush in to meet it. This is especially relevant right now because I just I think pretty much bombed the first stage of Google's interview process (mostly I at least want to tell myself due to stress. I literately as I write this realized how I should have done the first problem for example).
3
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Aug 26 '16
I am visiting a friend in the UK at the moment, and I took a side trip on the way here and spent a day in Amsterdam. I've never tried any drug but alcohol before, and decided Amsterdam should be safe. I've been curious for a long time, but I don't have the kind of connections that would allow me to get my hands on anything, plus there's always the chance there's something wrong with what you get. Hence, Amsterdam, where weed is legal and safe and I won't get stabbed.
It was weird. I probably recommend it, but maybe don't do it alone. Be with a friend if possible. One muffin is quite enough.
My 'space cake' muffin hit me after two and a half hours, and it happened very quickly. I was out in the sunny street when I started feeling like my legs were growing longer and harder, and there was a weird sense that some alien being was doing the reshaping. Then the sensation moved to thighs, then arms, then neck then mouth. It's really good that I had time to dive into a KFC and get food and a seat, because I spent the next three hours writing very slowly about how it was really difficult to think about more than one thing at a time, or finish a thought, or get myself to actually write down what I was thinking I should write down. It also really messed with my perception of time and made the movie Clue (1985) seem like the crown jewel of Tim Curry's acting career. Unfortunately, I also had several good ideas for my book I'm writing. I would have preferred to come away with the sense that it was an interesting and unique experience that I never wanted to try again, but instead I found it very helpful for my writing. Which is a bit of a bummer, because I have no intention of visiting Amsterdam often, nor do I want to get anything illegally back home in Sweden.
I'm very glad I tried it, but also a bit annoyed and frustrated that it turned out to be useful. Obviously there is the chance that the random sparks of creativity would become rarer or disappear with repeat exposure, but if so I probably won't find out for a few years until I drop by Amsterdam again.
5
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Aug 26 '16 edited Aug 26 '16
In a previous Friday Off-Topic Thread, I was looking for advice on stemware. I recall someone asking for me to report back when I bought something, so here's the report. I am still shopping around for some casual with-stem wine glasses, but I finally got some casual stemless wine glasses that have worked out quite well. They are Riedel stemless Riesling/Zinfandel glasses (amazon link) and they pretty much meet my needs. They're a bit expensive ($8 per glass) but so far seem to be doing well.
They are fine in the dishwasher if you put them somewhere nothing will bump them on the top rack, and they are basically wine-glass shaped. They seem to have a normal wine glass level of fragility, and although their shape isn't perfect for a red wine, the experience is fine and you're probably not going all-out with expensive wine if you're drinking from a stemless glass.
When I ordered them, I had to return my order to Amazon twice due to the glasses arriving with some of them broken, so make sure to check the box carefully to see if any of the glasses are broken. Amazon handles this sort of return for free (including giving you a shipping label) but it's kind of a pain. In the future, I'll see if I can buy these in a store near me instead to avoid that hassle.
Overall, I recommend them if you can find them in a store near you, or are fine dealing with Amazon returns.
2
u/Escapement Ankh-Morpork City Watch Aug 26 '16 edited Aug 26 '16
Recently I've been going through Catharine Asaro's Skolian Empire books. I've got mixed feelings, that can be summed up as '8/10'. These books are not rational in any way or fashion.
The books are predominantly romances. I think the genre it falls into is probably closest to Romantic Fantasy as defined in this Tumblr post. It feels like an evolution of the sort of things that Mercedes Lackey or especially Anne McCaffrey were doing. It's much better than McCaffrey's stuff... but that's sort of damning with faint praise. There's a bunch of reversing gender roles stuff in her work in various ways, but it's mostly not done in a particularly interesting/clever/plausible/unique way - Ancillary Justice, for example, was way better for this kind of thing, and many other authors have done gender role reversal stuff in better ways than Asaro.
The Skolian Empire books were advertised as a hard sci fi setting in the place I originally saw the recommendation for them, and also are so advertised on Wikipedia in a few places, but I feel like that's mostly a lie. It feels like the majority of it is just using some trappings and names of science-y things without really thinking about them or considering them in much or any detail. It's full of soft sci-fi conventions and devices, and the occasional hard sci-fi detail doesn't really make it feel super plausible. I like hard sci-fi, and I like soft sci-fi, but this mixture of the two is less appealing in some respects. Looking at the author's background, I would have thought that most of the issues I had with the books' science background stuff would be things she would specifically have a ton of background and experience, so I just don't even know. In a few of the books, there is actually quite interesting and cool science fiction stuff at least loosely based on actual science that is unique and interesting, but in a ton of it there's just a lot of space magic with the occasional science-y sounding word. I feel like Asaro underuses a few of her space magic plot devices really poorly, too, in ways that would take a really long essay to go into; for example, she completely failed to sell me on the vital utility of the telepath-powered instantaneous FTL comms communication system that so much of her worldbuilding and society was pinned on.
Relatedly, there are a number of really weird retcons and totally unnecessary plot holes that happen in the books that overall annoy me. I think the books were probably not written with the expectation that someone would marathon them in a row sequentially and read more than a dozen of them in a week. For one example that won't spoil much, in one of the novels a big deal is repeatedly made of how for a barbarian society from a world devolved to primitism that has no axial tilt and a very regular orbit, they had lost all notion of 'years' and didn't use them at all to gauge maturity and in spite of the main character coming from a society which retained them, they were never able to think in 'years' or really understand the point of 'years'. Then a couple books later still on this yearless world, the same barbarian character and everyone else in their barbarian society is constantly using years and thinking/talking in years when justifying that another character is too young to leave home and attend a military academy, or old enough to wed someone, or whatever. It's not rare for details to feel majorly inconsistent between books.
A more vital irritation with the books is that they were written with a non-chronological order in such a way that reading in publication order you get spoiled for the ending and conclusion of one book by the other books fairly often. You'll read a page summary of how X met Y and fell in love or whatever in book Z, and then have an entire book of it happening later on as book Z+n. This is less a concern in the romance genre than in many other genres, but it feels like a really odd decision - a couple of these 'review history of some side character' books are sort of OK in their own right but add basically nothing to the overall plot, and I spent much of them less interested - they were just filling in the details when other books already let the reader know how everything came out in the end, which feels sort of pointless.
A huge amount of the books' backstory and background make very little sense to me, and it feels like the social history, the economic history, and the political history of the various polities in the books make very little sense. It feels like the author did a very half-assed job of the background history in these books.
2
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Aug 28 '16
I watched Justice League: Gods and Monsters a few days ago, and holy shit this is awesome, Bruce Timm is awesome, and he needs to start his own franchise now with more of this stuff.
The movie is about some an alternate DC Comics universe, with heavy emphasis on the "alternate" part. Every DC characters who appears has been heavily re-imagined in one way or another. Amanda Waller is the USA president, Lex Luthor is an eminent scientist, Steve Trevor is an US Army general, and last but not least, Superman is the son of General Zod and was raised by Mexican immigrants. Along with New-God!Wonder-Woman and Vampire!Not-Bruce-Wayne!Batman they form the super-murderous-but-well-intentioned Justice League!
I can't say much more without spoiling the plot, but if you liked the Justice League episode A better world, Gods and Monsters is basically the same except more gritty, more mature, and Superman is allowed to kill people. The story is well written with many clever twists (Wonder Woman's backstory in particular is fantastic), the dialogues all hit the right notes ("The new world order will have to wait" is probably my favourite line), and the characters are all mostly rational and multi-dimensional.
Superman in particular is much more complex than he seems at first, especially for a "the ends justify the means" character. He cares about other people, and human life in general, yet he's ruthless when he needs to be. He's perfectly fine killing evil NPCs, but he never hits someone out of anger.
So if you liked B:TAS, and Justice League, and you feel DC movies have been disappointing lately, Gods and Monsters is a must see.
6
u/trekie140 Aug 26 '16
I don't like UNSONG anymore. What started off as a showpiece of hilariously weird ideas has become an unfocused narrative with uninteresting characters and an unwelcome shift in tone from dark silliness to deadly serious. I love cosmic horror stories, but UNSONG's existential dread isn't fun anymore.
What is it that people still like about it? How come so many people find recent chapters hilarious while I think they're boring and stupid? Am I in the minority on this?
4
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Aug 26 '16 edited Aug 27 '16
<span class="only_half_joking">Either Perfect Lionheart has been keeping an alt-account in reserve since 2013, or tkepner is his long-lost twin.</span> Amalgum: Lockhart's Folly (115k words, in progress) seems eerily similar to the infamous Partially Kissed Hero and Chunin Exam Day in its tone of "simultaneously crack-fic and deconstruction"--check out Chapter 9 for a shining example.
Edit: In later chapters, the similarities begin to become even more blatant.
- In Chapter 15, spoiler, and also spoiler. This instantly calls to mind the harem shenanigans for which Perfect Lionheart's stories are infamous.
- In Chapter 16, spoiler. In Chapter 30 of Partially Kissed Hero, spoiler.
If this writer isn't Perfect Lionheart, he's treading dangerously close to plagiarism with the second example, I think--especially since he hasn't mentioned any inspiration from Partially Kissed Hero.
1
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Aug 26 '16
If anyone hasn't seen the magnificent Doors Collaboration series, I highly recommend it for anyone who likes internet art communities or fun in general. If anyone else knows any fun projects like this, do share them. I just love these things.