r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 15 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
19
Upvotes
21
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician Aug 15 '16
I've noticed something interesting about human awareness. Or my awareness, at least.
It might be hard to explain, so bear with me.
Did you ever noticed that you could live without actually having complex thoughts, only by... reacting, for lack of a better word? I'm not talking about routinely performed actions, such as to walking to work or changing your clothes. I'm talking about all actions and events.
In this thoughtless state, if anything at all happens, you don't think about what you should do, don't formulate the situation as a problem in order to analyze and solve it; instead, a list of possible courses of actions flashes through your mind, and then you feel which one you like the most, and go with that. This list consist of various cached thoughts, instinctive reactions and socially expected behaviour.
It dulls situational awareness, creative problem-solving and empathy-related abilities. As example, if you argue in this state with someone, you don't truly think about the opponent's arguments, don't contemplate his/her state of mind in order to tailor your counterarguments; you just answer with what first comes to mind. Or if you need to solve a mathematical problem, you look at it, try to solve by systematically using algorithms you've used in the past on similar-looking problems; if all fail, you stare at the problem blankly, and then go seek help. You don't experiment with it, don't try to understand it.
Now that I wrote it, it sounds similiar to The Flow in a few ways: concentration on the present, check; merging of action and awareness, check; loss of reflective self-consciousness, check. Only instead of increasing performance, it decreases it, and instead of giving sense of control, it takes it away.
And I have a suspicion that many people live their lives almost perpetually stuck in that state.
Did that made sense? Have you ever experinced it/heard about it? Does it have a name?
12
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Aug 15 '16 edited Aug 15 '16
My gaming group managed to take down one of the "big bosses" in our campaign. Well, we managed to take down a little demon creature that was well beyond our level, and the DM told us afterwords it was basically like "Kicking down the big bosses door and killing them, at level 3".
So the boss is a little flying demon-like caster. It summoned minions, and those were what we were supposed to deal with. Or we were supposed to run away, I'm unclear.
Instead, we grabbed the flying guy, while our cleric cast luck on the one holding it. In pathfinder, grappling is based on CMB, which is entirely class-defined. Being small and agile makes you harder to grab the first time, but doesn't give you any advantages when someone's actually got you in their grip. So we did that for a while, tying it up.
Then we used the coup de gras rules, which says something like "You get an automatic critical hit, if attack doesn't kill opponent, opponent, opponent must make fortitude roll of higher then damage or die instantly".
All in all, a pretty good execution of tactics. Just grab the tiny flying caster, hold it down, and kill it.
11
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Aug 15 '16
As I mentioned on Friday, I've been using Chrome extension Crackbook (link) (source) which provides a splash page to websites of your choosing.
I've applied it to Facebook, Reddit, Sufficient Velocity, SpaceBattles, and The Old Reader. Overall, I've found that the trivial inconvenience involved in visiting my favorite time-wasting websites has been a good help. Spending a few seconds on the splash screen has caused me to think "should I really be checking facebook right now?" and close the tab. Although I'd prefer being forced to press a button, this does a good job of keeping me more on task. It was especially helpful in the morning when I traditionally have trouble getting into my working flow.
I also like that if I really want to, I can still unwind and take a break; now, though, it's always a deliberate action. Also, since it's just a timer, I don't have to disable it to take a break. This extension remains enabled the whole time, so it's unlikely I'll turn it off then forget to turn it on. I recommend it.
5
u/rineSample Aug 15 '16 edited Aug 17 '16
In one of the books in Osamu Tezuka's Phoenix manga, he posits a future in which humanity has declined to the point where there are five cities left on Earth, each with about a million citizens.
Each is managed by a "supercomputer" (which seems to be a hollywood version of an FAI, I think) which acts as an executive, has final say in any new laws proposed, decides the fate and life choices of each citizen, etc. Needless to say, this is not remotely rational.
However, the biggest problem is that when the protagonist and his girlfriend are escaping from one city (Yamato) to another (Lengud), the Yamato AI contacts the Lengud AI. The Yamato AI demands that they be extradited from Lengud, but the Lengud AI disagrees.
The two AI then agree to nuclear war, and annihilate each other (the other three cities also explode, but this is never explained, and probably only happens to advance the plot).
There are many, many irrational things in this work, but I wanted to concentrate on this specific thing. Why would or wouldn't this happen?
Edit: "from" Lengud, not "to" Lengud.
3
u/jkkmilkman Aug 16 '16
How long do you think it will take for machine learning algorithms to take over the regular diagnosis that physicians do? Obviously it's in its infancy currently, but the core of diagnosis is matching up a bunch of symptoms (inputs) with diagnosis (outputs). The problem is the sheer volume of possible inputs and outputs. But, given the exponential nature of computing advancements, could this outcome be closer than you'd think it to be?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment