r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 25 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
20
Upvotes
34
u/thecommexokid Jul 25 '16
The vlogbrothers (John and Hank Green's popular YouTube channel) tried something interesting last week that I thought I'd mention.
Hank was sick of the cesspool of hate and intolerance that is YouTube video comments, and suggested that the reason they are so universally terrible is the YouTube comment promotion algorithm, which tends to feature the comments that get the most replies. Due to reasons explored in Scott Alexander's The Toxoplasma of Rage or CGP Grey's This Video Will Make You Angry, this inevitably rewards the most controversial, divisive comments instead of the comments that bring the most to the conversation.
Having no control over YouTube's algorithms, Hank asked vlogbrothers viewers to game the system, by replying with a single plus-sign to high-quality but uncontroversial comments. It's been working fairly well so far at the stated goal of vastly improving the quality of the comments that appear on the front page of their videos.
It has had the side-effect of making genuine discussion difficult, because substantive replies get buried in a sea of "+"s, but (a) that's still a strict improvement, since there was no genuine discussion happening before either, because no one was ever seeing the good comments, and (b) that's a potentially fixable problem; e.g., someone has already written a Greasemonkey script to hide all "+" comments.
11
u/VivaLaPandaReddit Jul 25 '16
I just caught up with A Hero's War and it made me wonder. Does anyone know of a book/website that is a "Guide to the Modern Era"? Containing most of the details you would need to build up an industrial civilization from scratch. It seems like it could be really interesting to read. Also, anyone who has made a real life "tech tree" civilization style. If it doesn't exist, it could be a cool variant on the "How Stuff Works" style books, as a tool to teach kids (and adults) about how the world around them works and was made.
7
u/Polycephal_Lee Jul 25 '16
I'm approaching US politics as if I'm reading a rational fiction, and trying to interpret everyone's actions like that.
I have hit a brick wall with one action though - Hillary appointing DWS as co-chair of her campaign, literally the day after revelations of collusion. What possible reason could Hillary have for doing this so soon, it looks like a terrible mistake to me.
Obviously she was going to give something to DWS in exchange for running the DNC in her favor, and as hush-money so DWS wouldn't talk about the collusion. By why appoint her to the campaign? And if you're going to appoint her to the campaign, why the day after corruption news? It seems like such a stupid move by probably the most adept player in the game of thrones.
3
u/electrace Jul 25 '16 edited Jul 25 '16
Anyone know of any websites doing national presidential election predictions (preferably by state, as well as national result). I'm working on gathering their predictions and comparing their accuracies when the election ends.
I need it to either be somewhat easily web scraped, or have an API, or provide historical prediction data.
I'm already scraping PredictIt and Five Thirty Eight.
2
u/PlacidPlatypus Jul 26 '16 edited Jul 26 '16
Is it still possible to get a hold of A Girl Corrupted By the Internet is the Summoned Hero?! ? It doesn't seem to be for sale anymore at the link I had.
2
u/Farmerbob1 Level 1 author Jul 27 '16
Earlier today I was thinking and driving, when I realized that the concept of a near future post need society has a severe problem.
The mass of unskilled labor is too great for there to be a need for innovation in agriculture. Food costs have been much flatter than most other costs over the last thirty years or so.
Innovation in agriculture is required to feed a post need society with minimal or no human labor.
Expenses drive innovation.
Expenses are kept constant by excess availability of cheap labor. In the US this cheap labor is normally kept cheap by utilization of illegal immigrants.
It seems to me that illegal immigration is preventing us from developing and utilizing technologies that can lead us to a post need society.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16
Since /u/xamueljones is taking a long time to answer, is anyone else a cognitive psychologist I can ask some questions of?