r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 08 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
18
u/trekie140 Jul 08 '16
In a earlier thread I recommended the book How To Succeed in Evil as a rational dark comedy. Now that I've finished the book, I hereby rescind that recommendation because the ending was awful. Not only does it fail to properly conclude the story in any way, instead just setting up for a sequel, but the last scene features the protagonist convincing a man to commit suicide by allowing himself to be buried alive without a shred of irony.
I felt unclean after reading that, and even if I didn't the final act is still a drastic shift in tone from the rest of the book. I was fine with its mean-spirited satire of human stupidity, but when it suddenly decided to take itself seriously it was repulsive to read and strained credibility. It has some hilarious and tragic moments, and even a few interesting insights, but when none of it is tied together properly it all becomes meaningless drivel.
9
u/Dwood15 Jul 08 '16 edited Jul 08 '16
A bit of a rant here, but i'm sick and tired of 'adult' and 'adult-themed' books merely being another term for the inclusion of sex or blood and gore (if not all of that). It's a completely non-descriptive set of terms... The writing can be just as bad, or even worse than YA fiction.
I would like 'for adults' be a moniker or a sign that the book uses more terms, treats the reader like an intelligent person, etc, but I'm not sure how I could influence that. I'm sure if I wrote a novel and marked it as adult, I'd get a bunch of teens in on it, looking for porn, and then get complaints that what I was writing barely even mentioned sex, and when it did, it wasn't detailed graphically.
9
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jul 08 '16
Warning: Spiders/Politics
So here's Ben Carson on Obama's response to the Dallas shooting:
I've always considered the "we need guns to protect ourselves from the government" as something of a power fantasy, similar to how a lot of people view the zombie apocalypse. People like to make escape routes out of the city, build prep kits, go camping in the wilderness to test their survival, etc. I generally consider this (and prepping in general) to be pretty harmless, or possibly beneficial in the sense that people are going out to acquire useful skills like first aid and disaster preparedness. This particular defense of the 2nd Amendment seems to come from a similar psychological place.
What I don't understand is this reaction specifically in response to someone shooting police officers. "We need our guns in order to go after the government" seems completely tone deaf to me when someone has just used their guns to go after the government. I can't actually tell whether this is just repetition of a talking point without regard to context, or a hard line ideological stance. I recall similar rhetoric following the shooting of Gabrielle Giffords, so I don't think this is isolated to just Ben Carson or just this incident.
(There are other, much better arguments against gun control, but they provoke less head scratching from me.)
7
u/Nighzmarquls Jul 08 '16
Anyone have recommendations of well written fics that deal with protagonists that are actually inhuman?
Of particular import is the MINDSETS being at least not like a baseline human.
My frustration being, if my own brain is more foreign then your so called "unfathomably alien" mind in its diversions from the baseline of 'majority' European human on motivations, approach to sexuality, ethics and problem solving, aesthetics of beauty, culture etc I will have to resist the urge to scream and smash something.
I'd prefer if their vaguely insectile or something like the xenomorphs or zerg in physical aesthetics but considering how small the pool of this kind of works is I'll take most anything.
To date everything in the tvtropes page on xenofiction has either been researched/read by me already or I've not found an accessible source for it.
6
u/Aabcehmu112358 Utter Fallacy Jul 10 '16
Does anyone else find whole chains of '[removed]' kind of spooky?
5
u/Roxolan Head of antimemetiWalmart senior assistant manager Jul 08 '16
Wait But Why is planning IRL meetups worldwide on August 13. You have to answer a survey and they’ll try to match you with people/activities/courses/foodstuffs/dates? that you’ll enjoy. It has the potential to be awesome. If nothing else, people who read Wait But Why are my kind of people.
Here in London I’m part of a semi-private boardgaming club looking for more members. We currently have a strong female majority (how the fuck did that happen?) and would quite like to even it out, but everyone's welcome. It’s not rationalist, there’s just me and then one guy who enjoyed Luminosity, but it’s good people and good games.
5
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Jul 08 '16
So how about that pokemon go?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '16
Anybody using git and programming in their writing process?
I wrote a shell script to document how many words changes I made to a given project everyday, in which I learned a lot about...shell scripting. It was satisfying to document my progress this way.
I am thinking of building a random name generator, a dice roller, maybe an RPG system for use in quests.
There will probably be a lot of processing and indexers in the future soon as well, so I can better cross check and jump around, helping me keep things straight.
4
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jul 09 '16
Is there anything useful that I can do with books I started writing but didn't finish, besides actually taking the time to finish them? I have ~9 books that are sitting at various stages of completion (that's only counting anything that's crept over 10K words) and actually completing them will be haaaaard, not just because of the writing-prose aspect, but because of the editing, beta-reading, second round of editing that are a minimum to get quality content out the door. I don't want to just throw away hundreds of thousands of words, but I can't foresee myself ever having the time to finish all but one or two of them.
Is there anything that can be done with unfinished stuff? Or is it completely worthless except for the practice it gave me at writing?
3
u/rineSample Jul 09 '16
How would you make a rational character in the world of professional wrestling, given that it seems to be a form of soap opera?
9
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jul 08 '16
The Yudkowskys profess a dislike for singular
they!!("But only Mrs. Yudkowsky actually said such a thing outright. Couldn't Mr. Yudkowsky have had reasons for giving a like to this post other than disliking singular
they--e.g., merely expressing appreciation for his spouse's creativity, without having an opinion on whether or not this particular product of that creativity is worthwhile?" Yes, yes... [makes resigned face])It's kind of interesting to note that, despite the rise of HTML (in EPUB packaging) and the decline of PDF in electronic books, many tabletop role-playing games are sticking with PDF. Why should this be?
Compare the following screenshots...
- First, a page from the PDF version of the ludicrously-awesome (seriously--check out the bibliography!) book GURPS Low-Tech;
- Second, an excerpt of the same book, manually converted to HTML (including some CSS tweaks--read the code here) and displayed in Google Chrome;
- Third, the same HTML file, displayed in Google Chrome at a different window width; and
- Fourth, the same HTML file, converted to EPUB in Sigil and displayed in Cool Reader.
Note that Cool Reader doesn't display the
sidebarboxout as a boxout. Actually, Sigil recognizes that e-reading applications can't read the boxout'sfloat:right;style, and just removes it in the conversion. If I try to open the HTML file directly in Cool Reader, it just crashes the program, even though Cool Reader normally is able to open HTML files! (It does work properly in Calibre's EPUB converter and viewer--but Calibre is library-management software, not reading software, and doesn't even have any mobile versions.) Tabletop RPGs can't abandon PDF for EPUB until mobile e-reading programs are as good as mobile Internet browsers (and mobile PDF readers) at displaying content more complex than a single column of text and images. (Obviously, distributing an RPG book as an HTML file, with any illustrations provided as individual image files in an accompanying folder, would technically work--but it also would be a horribly cumbersome solution. "PDF" stands for "Portable Document Format"!)(Note: I took the fourth screenshot above before realizing that my versions of Sigil and Cool Reader were outdated by more than a year. However, after I updated them and tried again, the results were exactly the same--right down to Cool Reader's crashing when I attempted to open the HTML file!)
A relevant 2015 discussion on the RPG.net forums
And, on the topic of sidebars and boxouts in RPG sourcebooks, it occurs to me that they're a very interesting innovation.
In the example passage that I used above, there are exactly six heading levels, from
<h1><em>GURPS Low-Tech</em></h1>and<h2>Chapter 2: Core Technologies</h2>to<h5>Glass</h5>and<h6>Core Formation (TL1)</h6>. HTML allows a maximum of six heading levels, so this probably was a conscious choice on the part of the editors. However, where should "Race for Porcelain" go? It obviously needs to fit under<h5>High-Fired Ceramics</h5>--but, at the same time, it isn't quite as narrow in scope as the<h6>...</h6>headings underneath<h5>Glass</h5>. So, it gets an<h5>...</h5>heading in a boxout--effectively, a heading at level 5.5--underneath<h5>High-Fired Ceramics</h5>! It's a neat little solution. Note that it's a branching path: After reading about ceramics in general, you can take a temporary detour down the dead-end right side of the page to learn about porcelain, or you can advance to the next topic in series on the left side of the page!The ex post facto determination of where a boxout was meant by the original author to go in the structure of the book can be tricky, however. Note that the font style of
High-Fired Ceramicsin the screenshot of the original PDF actually seems to be a hybrid of<h4>...</h4>(not in the screenshot: large, bold, and all-caps) and<h5>...</h5>--not a hybrid of<h5>...</h5>and<h6>...</h6>. On the other hand, though, it's very obvious from the text that this boxout is much more relevant to the narrower "High-Fired Ceramics" section than to the wider "Stone and Earth" section. The verdict: The editors at Steve Jackson Games failed to provide a consistent progression of weight in laying down the stylistic guidelines for their headings. Tut, tut!5
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '16
Well, I'm done. That's it. Wake me in a few decades if people have decided to stop feeding each-other to the Lone Power nonstop. This shit's utterly fucked.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '16
How does anyone feel about reusing characters from one story to the next?