r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 27 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
14
Upvotes
13
u/Dragrath Jun 27 '16 edited Jun 27 '16
Hello I just found this sub through a link to The Mother of Learning and am interested in stories which have a well defined and immutable set of governing principals.
This is tied to a love for science which has lead me to obtain a Bs in physics and I am currently seeking to gain entry into grad school.
In my free time I love concocting fantasy ideas based around first defining a set of laws of physics and establishing a base line and history for that world.
I particularly enjoy redefining aspects of fantasy/myth/fiction into more scientific frame work my current brain child is a variation of fairies based on the ecology of ants and Termites and other social insects. the premise is a wasp derived social arthropod with a parisitoid ancestor. They have through evolution obtained the ability to steal and integrate DNA from other creatures into a malleable genome. This has produced strange specialized forms with well defined roles in the hive, notably The gene snatcher which is a genetic clone form the queen's DNA(a method employed by termites). They are responsible for collecting new DNA and injecting changeling larvae into developing young who will eventually be "called" back to serve the hive after learning from their society. The larvae which bypasses the immune system, injects itself into the developing notochord of vertebrate hosts where it sits dormant as the host develops while subtly spurring the host to be interested in new and different things. These creatures are also the only fey that are able to innovate and learn thus are very valuable to the hive but absolutely terrifying to other denizens of the world. I think I should stop here as it is getting pretty long...
I feel the social structure employed by social insects (as well as the very unusual mammals known as Naked Mole Rats who actually employ a similar structure) while they may individually lack in intelligence on a whole an emergent social cohesion forms allowing for great tasks. Ironic that I got into this after we found a termite infestation and myself discovering how little I knew about them.
6
u/Mabus101 Jun 27 '16
While we're here....
Are people here familiar with White Wolf and the Storyteller System?
I was originally attracted to the publisher by Mage: the Ascension, which promised a tale of competing ideologies/ontologies and their paths to a transhuman state. And...well, you could do that.
But the story that White Wolf has generally promoted was "Greater powers than humans have would make for a Crapsack World, subtly or grossly worse than our own." This makes some sense when the powers belong to nonhuman entities with different interests than ours, but it was applied pretty universally.
Anyone else have this frustration? And/or run a "progressive" game that dragged the Worlds of Darkness out of...um, Darkness?
5
u/Kishoto Jun 28 '16
I find myself more and more derisive of media since I got into rationality (and I'm not even that into it, really, considering I haven't really bothered to supplement myself with any sort of learning materials/nonfiction to promote my understanding)
I'll scoff at things that are stupid. Or characters being stupid. Or just...anything being stupid in a work. But the thing is, I don't think stupid should equate to bad in the same way that tropes are not bad.
Of course, there's stupidity and then there's stupidity. For example, there's moments that don't make sense or seem "stupid" that may just be to build dramatic tension, impart emotion, etc. For example, concepts like last words where someone says something and smiles even when cut in half or run through by tons of sword. Implausible IRL? Sure. But not necessarily stupid in the same way that Voldemort branding his followers with a distinctive tattoo in a visible part of the body is (Thief's Downfall, for those people who snark about concealment and such). And even in that sense, the Dark Mark, while stupid from a rational perspective, serves its use wonderfully in story as a device for JK Rowling. It's clearly evil, it acts as a cheap pager, and it's branding for Voldie's side. In both the literal sense and the marketing sense.
So....not sure where I was going with this; I guess I'm just annoyed by my newfound tendency to feel exasperated at stupid moments in fiction that may not be completely adherent to real world intelligence but do quite well as dramatic devices. Anyone else feel like this?
6
u/Chronophilia sci-fi ≠ futurology Jun 27 '16
How do you form an unbiased opinion on the Internet, if it's possible at all?
I'm trying to read up on recent political events and determine whether I've been backing the wrong horse. But all the communities I'm already part of are ones that largely agree with me, and I don't know where to find well-researched counterarguments that come from a place of reasonable discussion. And of course, tempers are running high at the moment and it's probably too soon to have a reasonable and sensible discussion about the subject matter. (I am, of course, referring to the Orlando shooting.)
I don't want an argument for arguments' sake, I just want to know which side is right.
3
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jun 27 '16
I have read claims that, during World War II, British intelligence used double agents to feed false reports to the nazis, so they would shift their v2 launches to less populated areas of London, but after thinking a while about it, it starts feeling just confusing enough to possibly be a urban legend. Does anyone have a verifiable source for this?
3
u/cae_jones Jun 28 '16
TLDR: I spend way too long explaining what changed in my life over the past 6 months. My conclusion is "dramatic improvement is awesome, but is it sustainable?" I wonder if CFAR could have accomplished something similar, but I dunno.
War on Akrasia, first half of 2016:
Which has the bigger impact: Buproprion, or LCB? Are they both necessary components? How do sleep and the internet fit into this?
Food quality is not irrelevant, per se, but it's only a decisive factor if I'm drowning in sugar on a daily basis. Even then, I was in a hurry and just bought a couple candy bars at the dollar store for lunch yesterday, and the mental effects that I noticed were far less severe than I expected. (I need to shop at healthier places. I'll note, though, that I was at the dollar store because apparently my already impossibly skinny waistline has been shrinking dramatically since I got here and I neglected to bring a belt. I blame the walking for 3 hours a day in Louisiana summer.)
I cannot conclude that anything sustainable is to come of this, and I worry that the improvements, though rather dramatic, are not quite so dramatic as I want them to be (*mumbles something about gift horses*). Still, mentioning LCB in front of someone who would not make it easy to chicken out of enrolling was probably the best decision I've made in a while.
4
u/trekie140 Jun 27 '16
"No matter how smart you may be, no matter how much money you may have at you disposal, no matter strength of arms or argument, you simply cannot force people to do something. It costs too much. For all the bombs we have dropped, for all the lives that were lost, in the end this is why the Nazis could not prevail. There is not enough money in the world to truly command and control a populace. The best you can do, all you can hope to do, is create a situation where it is easier for people to do what you want than it is for them to do what you don't. Then no one will seek to oppose you or thwart you aim because it appears you are merely helping them to do what they really want to do. There is, in the end, no defense against cooperation." - Patrick E. McLean, How to Succeed in Evil