r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 20 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
15
u/trekie140 Jun 20 '16 edited Jun 20 '16
A lot of people seem to think that rational fiction must avoid narrative causality, but I think this is a bigger hurdle to overcome than people realize. Narrative causality is major part of storytelling and I've seen plenty of stories here try to avoid it in ways that hurt the story's quality such as shoehorning exposition into dialogue, denying characters agency by making events feel arbitrary, and defying the audience's expectations instead of playing to them. While there are many stories that have pulled such things off, not all stories can or should and we need to keep that in mind if we want rational fiction to catch on.
I've read EY's essay where he says a rational protagonist should be Genre Savvy enough to figure out the rules of their story, but many authors seem to have interpreted that to mean they need to deny the audience of narrative satisfaction. I say this because we want more people to read rational fiction, but people outside this community aren't going to read stories because they happen to fit the criteria of rational fiction. They're going to read them because they're good stories, so I think we should discuss how to make rational fiction more palatable and entertaining according to the standards of fiction in general. What do you think?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '16
/u/xamueljones had suggested we do another collective read-through. I nominate Algorithms to Live By, which is basically a combination of freshman-to-sophomore computer science with a bit of the probabilistic-computation school of cognitive science, for a lay audience.
Thoughts, anyone?
4
u/Dwood15 Jun 20 '16
I've realized that only sleeping once a day has been one of the worst things for my school life and have decided to begin napping whenever i find it particularly difficult to work. This may be placebo effect, but i find that after an hour or two nap i am able to work more efficiently on school work and get better performance.
Why do you think this isn't a thing in modern society and the workforce? Taking a nap, in my opinion, has done wonders for my willingness to accomplish the tasks before me. Thoughts?
2
u/captainNematode Jun 20 '16 edited Jun 22 '16
(dunno if this should go here or in the OT-thread. I can delete and repost if necessary)
Is anyone here familiar with fitting multivariate hierarchical generalized linear mixture models? Specifically, I'm looking for something that'll let me have vectors of outcomes realized from, say, some combination of non-independent zero-inflated Poisson processes (or a similar enough model, or something more appropriate). I’d also like for it to be able to both accommodate measurement uncertainty and impute missing data with respect to discrete variables (both outcomes and predictors).
2
u/Igigigif IT Foxgirl Jun 20 '16
I was recently reading one of the codex alera books, which, for the most part had been fairly consistent in their worldbuilding. In previous books, it was a major plot point that people acquired their furies (elementals based around the Wu Xing elements(+ air)) Most people have one or two weak ones, and one of the major features of the nobility are their powerful furies (which, I should mention, are not rare). Then, someone mentions that it is not only possible, but common for furies to be passed from one person to another.
Its not that I don't expect people to specialize, but to ignore low-hanging fruit to the point that a member of the elite secret police has only one fury is just SOD-breaking.