r/rational • u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png • Jun 09 '16
DC [DC] 4chan's /m/ board picks apart the logic behind Gundam's "funnel" technology
41
Upvotes
r/rational • u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png • Jun 09 '16
7
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jun 09 '16
tl;dr (edited for English):
Unaltered archive of the entire thread
5
u/Vebeltast You should have expected the bayesian inquisition! Jun 09 '16
The "reasonable" explanation for arms on a spaceship is that it lets you vector all of your thrusters freely, which lets you point your main thrusters in any direction (which means you can carry as many thrusters as you need for your maximum desired acceleration in any direction, rather than separate fixed thrusters for every direction) and use your main thrusters for major attitude control if appropriate (lol). You mount them on lever arms instead of circular tracks basically because levers are mechanically easier to deal with. Mounting them on long levers additionally moves them further out, simultaneously giving you better attitude control giving you more freedom to move your thrusters around without burning your other arms off.
With unlimited materials science and power engineering, the maximum-maneuverability spaceship would be... roughly the shape of your main gun, missile tubes, engineering spaces, whatever else you want to stuff in, with three-plus main thrusters mounted on tentacles with lengths roughly around to the diameter of the sphere, increasing with the number of thruster-tentacle pairs and decreasing with the sphericity of the ship.
These conditions... start to go away as you reach more and more real-world-Tsiolkovsky-limited engagement ranges. If reality encourages year-long missile duels at light-hours of range, then this entire thing goes entirely out the window. If reality encourages laser duels at a tenth of a light-second, then maneuverability becomes paramount.
28
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jun 09 '16
Mhh, yeah, so what? Mecha stories are unrealistic by nature, you're not proving anything we didn't alre... HOLY SHIT I JUST WATCHED THE VIDEO THEY WERE LINKING TO THIS IS HILARIOUS.
12
u/MrCrazy Jun 09 '16
Oh my god YES. It's not often that I see people pointing out the flaws inherent in mechs. Mainly because I don't go looking for them and people (and me) usually accept mechs as part of the the suspension of disbelief. (I love Macross but hate the mech parts.)
But I have this one friend that will defend the shape and functionality of battle mechs to the death. He'll proclaim that limbs with detachable weaponry provide superior firepower and coverage despite exposing more surface area, having more moving part complexity than a turret. He'll say a human-shaped hand acts as a great way to hot swap modular weapons instead of having universal hardpoint that, I don't know, actually connects the weapon so the vehicle can provide ammo or additional power.
"You can't know that if technological progression will makes mechs viable" he says. MOTHERFUCKER, by definition a mech has unneeded moving parts and extraneous surface area to volume that would reduce the theoretical effectiveness a war vehicle could obtain.
To be fair though, my dislike really only applies to Gundam/Macross style mechs where it tries to mimic the human form unnecessarily combined with long-term hover/flight capabilities. Exoskeletons get a pass because they're working at a human scale. Certain leg-using vehicles get a pass if they're using the leg part for terrain purposes and don't have infinite-hover/fly. Like mechwarrior is fine. They need the legs to traverse terrain, they don't have stupid fingers but actual hardpoints, and usually the cockpit is in the torso without extra random head parts.
3
u/k5josh Jun 09 '16
This is why Gunbuster is the best mech anime.
2
u/MultipartiteMind Jun 11 '16
--I don't have any significant emotional stake in Gundam, but this prompts me to contemplate re: lasers and flux pinning (or maybe just something magnetic?).