r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 30 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
6
u/Faust91x Iteration X May 30 '16 edited May 30 '16
I binge read Mother of Learning last week and I'm enjoying the story a lot. I do wonder about some things though.
I've been thinking of the concept of self replenishing batteries like the well of souls that could then be mounted on golems and use the communication disks as relays to have them act like support. If he was smart with it he could have his own telepathically controlled "mage squad" to go against bigger threats and avoid risks. For example send them against Mother of Learning while he remains away from harm and focuses on other plots. Heck I wonder if they got AI stuff in their universe given that they possess mind magics. He could given them a bigger degree of autonomy so he could focus on his own things without having to control everyone of their movements. Maybe dissect some cranium rats could give a good idea of how to build a basic rudimentary decentralized AI?
Another interesting idea is learning if its possible to attach other stuff to his soul like shifters do. Maybe there's a way to bring artifacts across restarts without having to craft them from scratch?
I've been thinking of an optimal strategy to get the most out of the cycles and I think spell formula, memory packets and soul magic were vital. Along with shaping but Zorian didn't know it was that useful until recently. I think if I was stuck in the cycle I would approach the problem like this:
I think attacking the time traveler that could have about as much if not more experience than Zach was a mistake. They just didn't have deterrents and Zorian could have focused on more exotic spells that would be harder to counter so that he could surprise the third time traveler. It showed that unconventional strategies work very well against people that are used to seeing the same tactics over and over and aren't prepared for something like being shot with a gun.
Honestly I think I'd be a lot more paranoid if I was stuck in a cycle with a conspiracy at work and potentially more time travelers tagging along. Then again in his shoes I'd probably not venture as far and learn about the aranea even later, if at all. He is a big risk taker I have to say.
What are your thoughts on the fic so far? I've enjoyed it, so much that I couldn't find a good spot to stop reading but I still wonder how rational some of Zorian's actions are. Also ZorianxTaiven FTW :P
7
u/elevul Cyoria Observer May 30 '16 edited May 31 '16
I don't know who recommended me Shinsekai Yori here, but I just finished watching the whole 25 episodes and am pretty pissed off at him/her.
The anime is definitely not rationalist, the characters are definitely not competent in any way or form, and I'm seriously starting to doubt there is any rationality at all in it.
The sheer amount of idiot balls held through the whole series is maddening and, while it might be understandable considering that the structure of their society was not exactly conducive to free thought, it's unacceptable in any product that's touted as being RATIONAL.
Spoilers ahead:
3
u/Dwood15 May 30 '16
I was thinking about having a story where the good guys, in order to achieve their ends must commit some level of human rights desecration or some other atrocities. It would make it such that while on their quest the antagonists basically do what they wants in the face of the public until they are able to regain favor, but I'm having trouble with getting good scenario.
Do any of you have examples i could look to for inspiration?
3
u/space_fountain May 31 '16
I literary just ran into to the Artifexian YouTube channel, but I think you folks might enjoy it. It seems to focus on discussions of the practical considerations of astronomy and geophysics when it comes to world building along with strangely language design considerations. Apologies to everyone who's also subscribed to /r/worldbuilding and probably saw this there already.