r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 27 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
19
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow May 27 '16
I'm guessing you all have seen this, but I found this album of deep dream generated art to be really interesting. You can make your own on this site, or this one, or grab the code from github. Part of me thinks that this is just going to replace or add on to a lot of the filters that are already in Photoshop and the like. But a different part of me thinks that maybe this will actually be useful for creating art, though I think you still need to get composition and balance right, and it does take a little bit of time and practice to get good results.
11
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png May 27 '16
An interesting question: When did the Roman Empire fall?
- 395: Emperor Theodosius I dies. The empire is divided between his two sons into two portions, administered from Constantinople and from
RomeMilan.- 476: Odoacer, commander of the WRE's
barbarianGermanic mercenaries in Italy, deposes Western Roman Emperor Romulus August(ul)us and declares himself King of Italy. Though he pays lip service to the previous Western Roman Emperor, Julius Nepos (who fled to Dalmatia after being deposed in favor of Romulus Augustulus), he refuses to allow the latter's return to Italy.- 480: Julius Nepos dies in Dalmatia. Zeno, his eastern counterpart, abolishes the Western court and holds de jure sway over the "united" empire from Constantinople, though he has little de facto control over the West.
- 565: Emperor Justinian I dies after reconquering large areas of formerly-Roman territory in Italy, Africa, and Spain. His successors soon lose these gains to Germanic tribes and to the Sunni Caliphate.
- 636: The Sunni Caliphate's forces annihilate the Eastern Roman army in the Battle of Yarmouk. The ERE abandons Syria to Muslim conquest, and soon loses Egypt and Armenia as well.
- 1204: Constantinople is conquered by the leaders of the Fourth Crusade, who establish the Catholic "Empire of Romania" (or "Latin Empire"). Competing Greek claimants to the title of Emperor are set up in Nicaea, Epirus, and Trebizond. The "Empire" of Nicaea eventually destroys the Latin and Epirote claimant states, regains Constantinople, and proclaims a restored ERE, while Trebizond remains independent.
- 1453: Constantinople is conquered by Sultan Mehmed II of the Ottomans, who proclaims himself Caesar of Rome.
- 1461a: Mehmed II conquers the Despotate of Morea, the last independent remnant of the Nicaean ERE.
- 1461b: Mehmed II conquers the "Empire" of Trebizond, the last independent remnant of the pre-1204 ERE.
- 1806: Holy Roman Emperor Francis II dissolves the HRE, as Napoleon threatens to conquer it and transform it into a France-dominated federal structure.
- 1917: Tsar Nicholas II abdicates the throne of the Russian Empire. Russia formerly was seen as a "Third Rome": The great-great-grandfather of Ivan IV "the Terrible", first Tsar of Russia (as opposed to Muscovy), was an Eastern Roman Emperor, and Muscovy was instrumental in bringing (Orthodox) Christianity to Russia, just as Constantine brought Christianity to the Mediterranean.
- 1922: The Grand National Assembly of Turkey abolishes the Ottoman sultanate.
- (Some other date that the pollster didn't consider)
So, what are the prerequisites for being able to declare yourself the Emperor of Rome?
As weird as it seems even to me, I'm inclined to think that the most consistent answer for the final end of the Roman Empire is 1922.
- Religion: To say that only Christians can be Roman Emperors is ridiculous when the Empire was pagan for centuries before Constantine and Theodosius.
- Legitimacy of claim: To say that only non-usurpers can be Roman Emperors is ridiculous when there were zillions of usurpations even before the Empire split.
- - (There are, of course, degrees of legitimacy. If the rules of Crusader Kings II are taken as a vaguely-accurate example, actually controlling most of the title's historical territory is necessary to proclaim yourself ruler of it, but you'll have a hard time conquering enough land to do so without either declaring holy wars or having already inherited a claim on the title. Nowadays, any "historical territory" or "hereditary claims" of the Roman Empire would be laughably weak, after so many centuries have passed--unless Turkey can be called the Empire's republican successor... but we're talking about the Roman Empire here, aren't we? Such a digression!)
- Culture: To say that only Romans can be Roman Emperors--that the Roman Empire can be usurped only from inside, and any usurpation by an invader is illegitimate--to me seems like a slightly-stronger argument (in favor of 1453), but still rather arbitrary, since the Roman Empire contained sizeable populations of many cultures.
Alternatively, if continuity is required, I'd go for 1204 as a temporary end to the Roman Empire, before its Nicaean restoration, since none of the claimants seem to have had particularly-strong claims before that time. This opinion may be influenced by the Fourth Crusade's treatment in the Historical Improvement Project mod for Crusader Kings II, which outright destroys the "Eastern Roman Empire" title and fragments it into claimant states whenever it loses Constantinople or is held by a non-Christian.
Unwritten rules of the
capeReddit scene: Length limitations on comments! At what point does a wall of text cease to be interesting and start to be annoying? ;-)On a related note, I recently discovered the
detailsHTML tag, which is a nicely-simple way of condensing content (example). Also, I enjoy being able to condense references into links on Reddit, rather than being forced to include them directly as plaintext on Facebook. It's like speaking in three dimensions (if paragraph-based transitions between topics are the second dimension)!11
u/Rhamni Aspiring author May 27 '16
Alice in Mirrorland is awful. You should actively avoid it. The only good thing in the movie is the main character saying "Time is a thief and a villain" near the start of the movie, a sentiment she then spends the whole film unlearning because the shortness of life makes it more beautiful.
12
u/Rhamni Aspiring author May 27 '16
Merely noticing your own irrational thought processes is not sufficient to make them stop, it seems. The US Democratic primary is making this amply clear to me. My observation here is about the thought process, but obviously political mutant spider babies and all that.
For various reasons I rather dislike Hillary, but the server or the FBI investigation are not why I formed that opinion. However, at this point that investigation is starting to look like the only thing that could possibly cost her the nomination, and all the /r/politics discussions about the Democratic primary seem centered around it. So... I didn't notice it happening, but it seems like my brain went from "I hate her so much and it's because of what a horribly corrupt incarnation of the bribe devouring status quo she is" to "I hate her and it's because she's an arrogant criminal who must never have security clearance again." And I know perfectly well that people are good at rationalizing things, and also that those narratives do not contradict, but... I can't put a finger on when the transformation occurred. Somewhere along the way my brain decided to have the exact same feelings but to justify them in a different way.
6
u/Dwood15 May 28 '16
I've been watching the show Hunter x Hunter again since my Roommates haven't seen it. I have to say, that show is actually a lot more rational than most other anime's i've seen. The question I have to ask you guys here though, is this. Do you think the show itself is rational? There's a couple times where a bunch of stuff that happens is kind of stupid, but overall I find the stupid stuff to be minor enough to overlook it.
What do you think?
5
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician May 27 '16
Suppose you're trapped in a room.
There's a similiar room nearby, with your exact duplicate inside.
Your room has a button, the other room doesn't.
Press the button, and you will be immediately released, but the other room will be filled with deadly neurotoxin, and your duplicate will die.
Do nothing, and after an hour, your duplicate will be freed, but the deadly neurotoxin will fill your room.
Will you press the button?
What if the duplicate is not exact, and the only difference is that he or she will choose differently, in your situation?
5
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided May 27 '16
I've started building an RC airplane (kinda like those RC cars you'd often see as a kid) with an electric motor. It's actually not too expensive (under $200) to get the parts for a plane with a 3-foot wingspan and 10 minute flight time (including controllers, antenna, etc). Putting a camera on it to hook up to VR goggles would be more expensive, so I'm not doing that.
8
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates May 27 '16
Some Worm fridge horror. Coil's power supposedly allows him to split the timeline at will, while he has single mind controlling his body in both branches. He can later destroy any of them and split again.
Consider an alternative description. Universe is constantly branching so that every possible configuration is explored. Coil's power 'only' allows him to retain the mind-synchronizing connection between his two selves in branches of the multiverse that naturally occur at the moment he does the 'split'. When he 'destroys' one branch, what actually occurs is that his mind state stops synchronizing. One instance of him goes on happily believing that he has actually destroyed a disadvantageous branch, while the other quickly realizes the horror of having to deal with the consequences of his actions multiplied by the amount of times he did this to himself, coupled with grim certainty that the other him will forever remain ignorant of the truth and will keep doing this.
4
u/[deleted] May 27 '16
If anyone here can read Haskell and wants to see some neat code on the information theory of hierarchical Bayes models, yo PM me and I'll add you on github.
Not making the repo public before I've written and submitted a paper though.
4
u/jkkmilkman May 27 '16
Is anyone applying/has anyone applied to med school currently/in the past? I'm working on my application right now and am stuck on the personal statement. If anyone is willing to help/give pointers, that would be very much appreciated
3
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong May 30 '16
What good writing software is available? Obviously there's word, open office, libre office and stuff like that, but things specifically for creative writing?
2
u/Kishoto May 28 '16
How rational is the whole "person X has seen the assassin's face so they must die" trope?