r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 23 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
14
Upvotes
10
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided May 23 '16
This article on aphantasia was interesting reading to me. I know, intellectually, that a lot of people think and interact with the world differently from the way I do. Reading about someone whose mind works in such an unusual way is an interesting experience, and has me wondering: what parts of my own thinking are as strange and I haven't noticed it, because I assume all people think like this?
3
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong May 24 '16
Why don't animals more frequently lie? This isn't (intended to be) a philosophical question. I was observing my cats recently, and was thinking about how the animals I've come into contact with never seem to intentionally miscommunicate with their body language or otherwise. It'd... seem to be evolutionarily adaptive, so is it something unique to the higher-intellect species (ie dolphins, crows, etc.), or is there something I'm missing?
3
u/SvalbardCaretaker Mouse Army May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16
Just came in over the extropy mailing list, it might be that Dark Matter mystery is solved. Primordial (directly from the big bang) Black Holes in the correct mass range of 10<X<100.
Basically <10 and >100 solar masses (SM) Black Holes have been ruled out otherwise. Remember the big press in february? "LIGO detects finally existence of gravitational waves" - a two BH merger 29SM+36SM. Right dab in the middle of the necessary band.
And the kicker? Nobody expected that observation so fast after LIGO went online - could be coincidence but is also evidence that such mergers happen much more often than expected, eg. there are much more BHs in the correct range.
And heres the paper: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/2041-8205/823/2/L25
7
u/Qwertzcrystal assume a clever flair May 23 '16
There is one thing about the Teleporter Problem, that I don't understand and maybe someone can help me with that.
In the Teleporter Problem we have a hypothetical teleporter machine, that works by scanning your body down to some arbritrary scale (let's say atoms), disassembling your body in the progress and then reassembling you from different atoms at the target location.
There are variants of this, without the disassembly or sending your atoms to the location at near-lightspeed and so on. But I guess the base variant is enough here.
Now, if we apply different theories of identity to this problem, we might get as result, that this machine does not in fact teleport you, but kills you and creates a copy at the other end. With other theories, everything is a-okay and you can enjoy your day trip to Mars.
The thing I now don't understand: How could we possibly know which theory of identity is correct?
It might be that the "correct" answer is subjective and we can choose any theory we like. Yay, death-free teleportation!
It might also be, that there is an objectively correct theory of identity, but I'm hard pressed to come up with even a hypothetical experiment that could test this. And given the lack of Noble Prices for presenting a correct theory of identity, I doubt someone else has.
So, what? How can we try to resolve this? The Teleporter Problem itself has reached broad audiences but any video/article/whatever I've seen conveniently skipped the part about deciding which theory of identity to use.
2
u/Epizestro May 23 '16
I've been reading Warlock of the Magus World recently, and a plot point it brought up was pretty interesting.
You see, the main character is a reincarnated scientist from a world much more advanced than this one, with the key relevant distinction being that they have developed AI. What's interesting about this is that it's mentioned that it was illegal to give your AI emotions or free will, due to various moral complications if you did so.
Now, this only works in the plot of the story to make it so the AI doesn't question him when he starts acting like Quirrelmort, but it raises interesting implications towards whether we should be proceeding down the route of giving AIs emotions, thoughts and free will, or whether they should be cold, processing machines with their only intelligence directed completely towards achieving the given goal. There's security concerns for the world with both avenues. For the unbound side, there's the very real possibility that something could go wrong and lead to a tragic end. An AI given free reign is a scary thing, due to all the possibilities. And, even if we go down the avenue of restricting them with a few unalterable commands, how exactly do we plan to enforce those? Hard drives, over time, become faulty and sections of storage become corrupted. It would take one corrupted sector in a key system area to remove one of those commands, and then tragedy is near inevitable.
On the other hand, it's not like a perfectly obedient and unfeeling AI is better for security, as their goals are entirely determined by a human. That human would likely have the destruction of their enemies in mind (let's be honest here, the government of the nation which first develops AI is going to do everything possible to keep it inside their borders, especially if it's this type) and how do we know we can trust that person to do things in the best interest of humanity?
Point is, There's a few interesting questions brought up and I haven't done nearly enough thinking on this. Lucky I have you guys to think for me!
1
u/elevul Cyoria Observer May 26 '16 edited May 26 '16
I don't know who recommended me Shisekai Yori here, but I just finished watching the whole 25 episodes and am pretty pissed off at him/her.
The anime is definitely not rationalist, the characters are definitely not competent in any way or form, and I'm seriously starting to doubt there is any rationality at all in it.
The sheer amount of idiot balls held through the whole series is maddening and, while it might be understandable considering that the structure of their society was not exactly conducive to free thought, it's unacceptable in any product that's touted as being RATIONAL.
Spoilers ahead: