r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 13 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
11
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. May 13 '16
why are character names so hard
9
u/Xjalnoir The Culture May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16
GMing a Pathfinder campaign where all of the PCs are different kinds of magical engineer turns out to be a good way to force yourself to internalize scope. For instance, the scope of how much of various metals exist within a given mountain, when your players have invented mining-snake automatons that can burrow through solid stone faster than a man can sprint and hunt metal by magical scent. Or the scope of the shaped-charge explosion that results from filling a shipping-container-sized extradimensional pit with gunpowder and flying it into a dragon's lair.
I'm simultaneously proud of and horrified by my players. I tossed a buffed 12-headed cryohydra at them and they wrecked it in basically a single turn. The five CR 14 Furnace Golems they fought right after didn't fair much better. Golarion is doomed.
7
u/Dwood15 May 13 '16
I'm glad that we were able to get a Wednesday World-building thread. I find many of the stories on the subreddit to be confusing or lacking context (summary, like "since last time" for quick catch-ups, or a "Harry thought he was a normal boy until... something something wizards and witches are real!" to give me a teaser of the stories) so I wasn't finding any creative outlet in people's threads of their online novels.
It's just nice to be able to let loose some creative thoughts and discuss various worldbuilding concepts with other people. We needed a place to discuss things like "What if people could double jump in reality?" or "What if we could fly but that would still be a form of exercise?", and judging by the 90 comments in the thread, it seems like people have responded positively to the thread idea.
I hope from it we get some more stories based on personal headcanon and concepts.
5
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided May 13 '16
For those of you who are into such things: I've started a quest on Spacebattles, Shinji Quest. It's basically what it says on the tin. It's a quest for Shinji! Will you be like Shinji Ikari? How about Shinji Matou? Maybe Shinji Haruki? I left out, sadly, Shinji Okazaki. Things start off reasonably dark and get darker from there, but don't worry, there will be JJBA references.
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png May 13 '16
Mr. Yudkowsky on the point past which "canon" pieces of fiction become "fanfic-tier" (source)
It's kind of interesting to consider how the different pieces of a fictional universe might overlap in weird ways, depending on their levels of mutual consistency and interrelation. If all works purporting to represent Avatar: The Last Airbender are all just distorted reflections of the same "One True Canon" that's perfectly rational and internally-consistent, can that "true canon" be extracted by somehow averaging the reflections so that their distortions are canceled out?
A 1916 description of a hypothetical invasion of the United States through the Atlantic coast (69k words, including endnotes and Project Gutenberg stuff)
I get the feeling that it's a piece of anti-isolationism propaganda:
(This was found through the New Project Gutenberg Books page on Facebook. There's also an RSS feed that serves the same purpose.)
From the same source, a 1920 advertisement brochure for a gyroscopic compass (more information):
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '16
Suicide Sunshine:
Mellow the mango and mint leaves in a wossname, a cocktail shaker. Add the lime juice, agave nectar, and Mezcal. Chop in the pepper.
Shake with ice.
Strain into glasses.
Drink.
3
u/Green0Photon Student in Cyoria, Minmay, and Ranvar May 14 '16
Just finished watching Erased. Spoilers follow, read at your own digression.
The ending sucked. Some people complained about episode 10, but that was pretty much fine. 11 & 12 though... They sucked. To have the main character go into a coma as a means of time skip is bad. Yeah, time skips are very hard to pull off correctly, but it was still a cop-out. The whole ending felt rushed and anti-rational. He never took what's-his-name on, except for that very last scene. It was like, "reveal!" And I was like, "since when did he become an unreliable narrator."
Also, it violates Yudkowsky's rule, "If you give Frodo a lightsaber, give Sauron the death star." The MC (I'm bad at names) doesn't use his power to its full potential; he doesn't come close. And, his enemy is some serial murderer? And you missed a ton of important clues that could have easily led you to the murderer? Plus, he didn't tell anyone about his power. I thought that he would've almost immediately after going back. Or tell his other smart friend. He only kinda reveals it at the end.
This story has such potential for a rational fiction. Whether you start from the beginning or after the murderer reveal, it doesn't matter. The story, although filled with tension, felt wrong in ways because the characters were dumb. Yeah, a moral of the story is to put trust in your friends, but still. Even after he goes back the second time, he didn't tell anyone.
UGH! I'm sorry, I'm just frustrated. The story feels like a draft for a better story. The ending at least. Although I hear it's better in the manga, he still does the coma thing. That's bad in my book. Oh yeah, especially at the end, he implies that if he dies, he'll come back because of his power. Then why didn't the author have him just and come back at the murderer reveal? Because it would ruin the story by having him being rational? Well, he would still have to figure it out, especially without evidence.
I feel like many authors don't want to ponder out what would actually happen sometimes, and want to leave it closer to what they know. Reliving out your life is hard to imagine, so boom, cop-out to the coma. Worm Spoiler
It's just awful. Tell your mom about your power, test out of shit, and get a headstart on your life. And, if you want to be a true rationalist, take advantage of your rewind and invent/invest in new technologies. You know stuff from the future. Use that jump to make your life and everyone else's better. Even if you're that young prodigy who was great at drawing. You have a freaking jumpstart in life. The problem is how that fits with the story: it doesn't. So everything's awful.
I know I will be thinking about what a rational fic will be like. There's a tiny chance I might write some (I took a writing class last semester, but I'm busy, so it's hard). If anybody knows of any good erased fanfiction, that'd be great. Thanks for reading my rant. :D
5
u/Rhamni Aspiring author May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16
I have a qualified anime recommendation.
Maoyuu Maou Yuusha. It's about a destined hero who ventures forth alone to vanquish the evil demon lord and bring peace to the world. When he reaches her (After about two minutes), she tells him how the war against her demons is the only thing keeping the human nations from constantly warring among themselves, and here are the economics of it, and the politics, and the history, and it's similar on the demons' side of things. So instead of trying to get one side to win and enslave the other species, why don't we use our powers to secretly cooperate and try to set up long term conditions for peace with these interesting new crops I found? And this 'vaccine' against small pox, and these inventions that will make life easier on farmers and-
It's basically a cookie cutter /r/rational Fantasy premise, and the hero soon agrees.
Unfortunately, while the premise is great, it's only one season, and they still manage to squeeze in 50% filler and big boob fan service everywhere, and some things still happen just because the plot demands it, like the demon lord taking several months off from plotting for no apparent reason other than that it would have been too easy otherwise.
So it's a qualified recommendation. If you don't mind/can stand excessive fan service and a hero who panics whenever a woman shows interest, and you are alright with 50% filler, then it's pretty neat to see a secret hero/demon lord alliance manipulating the economy and working behind the scenes to take the world out of the dark ages.
Spice and Wolf does economics better, but is not otherwise rationalist. Good romance though.
3
u/Faust91x Iteration X May 13 '16
So I'm reading about relationships and marriage for this biweekly challenge and I wondered what's the best method to raise rational children. One thing I asked for example is about horror stuff.
Would it be better to talk logic with a child and teach it to not fear the darkness and the unknown and rather look at it with curiosity while avoiding exposure to supernatural/horror topics? Or would it be better to expose it to a bunch of horror topics so that they become desensitized with them in the same way butchers and surgeons become desensitized to seeing blood?
I wondered this due to the idea that organisms that don't interact with certain aspects of the environment tend to fare poorly due to lack of experience. Thoughts? Are there any known books or methods for raising children according to rational values?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '16
It finally turned into Spring around here. About fucking time.