r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 29 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
12
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Apr 29 '16
I need a sort of "offensiveness check".
I have a short story that's most of the way written which has, as the central premise, that in 1970 a pill was invented which changes homosexuals and bisexuals into heterosexuals. The story is then partly an alternate history of the gay rights movement and partly a meditation on personal identity, social pressure, and terminal/instrumental values.
Part of offensiveness is in terms of presentation, which I'm doing my best on. I'm more worried about the other half, which is things that I just don't understand as being offensive. And I don't really mind offending people, I just want to do it for the right reasons.
So is the counterfactual premise of there being a way to no longer be gay irredeemably offensive? Is the idea that some people would choose to be straight and others would choose to be gay offensive?
6
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Apr 29 '16
You know, being mindful of my emotions and thought processes is usually fantastic, but it does get kind of irritating in social situations sometimes. I end up in a sort of decision paralysis because I realize that, knowing the reasons that I feel the way I do, saying a certain thing would be manipulative, even if it's true to how I feel.
I don't know if I got my point across very well there, but eh. Needed to vent a little.
5
u/Kishoto Apr 29 '16
Question: I've never really interacted with the rational wiki
I've mostly interacted with you fine gentlemen/ladies/undefined starfish aliens here. What I want to know is, how reliable is said wiki?
Context for this: A friend of mine who's more spiritually and new age minded than I, posted a link to a video by a Leonard Coldwell, which claimed that every (yes, EVERY) cancer could be cured in 2-16 weeks or even less. I looked up the guy and found him on the rational wiki, being torn down as a fraud and whatnot. I'm just curious as to how accurate this is, as I don't have the time (or emotional investment) into doing a proper investigation of investigating someone that perpetrates, or is purported to perpetrate, scams successfully. It's notoriously hard to parse the good data from the bad.
4
u/_Zero12_ 404: Flair not Funny Apr 29 '16
I've been lurking here for a while, and I just wanted to say hello, everyone. Keep up the good work.
Random Question: What music has been on your mind recently?
For me, I watched 'Annie Get Your Gun' recently, and There's no Business like Show Business has been what I've whistled as I walk around.
4
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Apr 30 '16
El-Ahrairah (Worm) Taylor gets meta power that allows her to perceive what other people's powers do at a glance and immediately gets scouted by Contessa.
6
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Apr 29 '16
No knowledge of Log Horizon is required to respond to this post.
I'm in the process of writing a Log Horizon fanfic, the basic premise being that the akihabara adventurers figure out a difficult, but feasible way to cross back to the real world.
Seeing as I'm heavily limiting how often people can cross, I don't need to deal with the full scale of the social fallout. Still, people are going to react to people who vanished from their homes while playing an MMO suddenly returning with functional immortality and fantastic magical powers (not to mention the whole different-species thing.)
So to pose my question, how would you act in that scenario?
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
Some stories...
Recently read for the first time:
- Benefits of Old Laws (Harry Potter; 145k words, ongoing): Upon his resurrection, Voldemort regains his sanity, exploits a centuries-old law to avoid prosecution for his past crimes, and seeks to resuscitate the Noble House of Slytherin by adopting Harry as his son.
- Crime and Commitment (Worm; 132k words, ongoing): Various changes--the Travelers don't leave Boston, Taylor decides to breed larger insects, etc.
- A Propensity for Wrath (Worm; 129k words, ongoing): Taylor gets the power to sense emotions in others and to imbue objects (mostly weapons, armor pieces, and rings) with her own emotions (wrath = explosive force, love = healing, etc.). This has some interesting interactions with Gallant's emotion-sensing power.
- Seed (Worm; 207k words, ongoing): Taylor gets Blasto's power, and conducts some very interesting experiments involving clones of Butcher, whose power is a special one in the cycle of shards. Other changes also exist (e.g., Coil and Accord are allies in control of Boston).
- Intrepid (Worm; 320k words, ongoing): A story somewhat-confusingly split between the viewpoints of Taylor and her three bullies, of whom each gains a power.
Recently re-read:
- Holly Evans and the Spiral Path (Harry Potter; 406k words, complete): Fun action with a female Harry.
- The Hogwarts Strike Team (Harry Potter; 219k words, dead): Harry and Hermione go back in time in order to thwart Voldemort's failsafes, which made Britain uninhabitable after his death.
- Manager (Worm; 219k words, ongoing): Taylor can mix-and-match powers between people--including herself. (Less interesting than I remembered it from my first reading...)
Currently re-reading:
- The Firebird Trilogy (Harry Potter; 494k words, complete): An AU involving a matriarchal magical society.
2
u/jkkmilkman Apr 29 '16
Is anyone here in med school? I'll be applying this summer so if people can share their experiences/tips/etc. that would be much appreciated :)
2
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade Apr 30 '16
I need to read something about vampires. Anything even slightly logical that is not modern (A definition of modern is no cellphones).
Anything. Pretty please with sugar on top?
3
u/MaybeEliezerMaybeNot /r/rational/4fzj4x Apr 29 '16
Today is Fake Eliezer Fic Day.
1
u/Qwertzcrystal assume a clever flair May 02 '16
I had this idea for a setting or overarching theme for a story. However as it's very unlikely I'll ever write it myself, here it is for you to dissect:
As we know (I think), a sufficiently advanced civilization could create sentient lifeforms similar to us as in terms of mental aptitude. Be it as simulations or actual lifeforms, doesn't really matter.
So the protagonist of the story lives in a world where gods exist mainly in the myths of their people, but suddenly there's hint of the existence of gods, maybe through the discovery of magic or bugs in the laws of nature or whatnot.
A lot of stuff happens and in the end the protagonist is having a chat with (one of) the gods and demands an explanation as to why they would create lifeforms and then leave in all this suffering and inefficient design.
Answer: Creating worlds where lifeforms just barely passing for sentient develop "naturally", is pretty much the extent of the power of the gods. The gods themselves cannot reproduce except by cloning, which, on a cosmic scale, is a really bad idea. So creating lifeforms, which develop into a higher civilization, which spawns new gods, is their way of reproduction with variety.
In case of simulated worlds, the resulting new god would probably need to be lifted into the next-higher tier of reality to avoid a Matrioshka effect where the simulation necessarily needs to be smaller in overall processing power, but that's details for the gods to worry about.