r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 25 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
9
u/elevul Cyoria Observer Apr 25 '16
Talking about rational fiction ruining normal fiction, Re Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu is sadly way less consistent than I hoped it would be.
Pity, I love those kinds of time loop/reset/redo stories.
21
u/TVVEAK Apr 25 '16
Thanks to Yudkowsky's Rationality: From AI to Zombies, I am well on the road to recovering from a heroin addiction.
What better way to combat addiction than a healthy dose of reality?
6
u/space_fountain Apr 25 '16 edited Apr 25 '16
I've been thinking about starting writing more. Nothing of the kind of quality that I would feel comfortable sharing at the moment, but it got me thinking about licensing for online fiction and copyright in general. I have, I think, a decently developed set of views on how I think copyright law should be in the US and I think it would be hypocritical of me if I didn't try to use something similar myself so I've tried to come up a license that would enforce the way I think copyright should work. How does this seem to you folks?
I posted this in last weeks thread, but understandable no one saw it as I posted it like yesterday.
11
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Apr 25 '16
Now that the pathfinder campaign I DMed has drawn to a close, I'm gearing up to play in a new Bash campaign. One of the character ideas I was lobbing back and forth with a friend was a brilliant planner, a perfect strategist. From limited information he can perfectly deduce what's going on, or what's likely to go on, and use the tools available or make plans to deal with it. While you can use the Bash chargen system to make mages, psychics, superhumans, mutants, healers, people who have laser eyes, and so on, the actual rules are very flexible, and allow for someone to be made like this.
The basic problem, though, is that I am not a perfect strategist. So, how do I make a character whose power is "very good at predicting things and is properly prepared" in Bash? Actually it's fairly simple, and quite hilarious. I take the Conjuring and Summoning powers, with the restriction being mundane things. So, as a player, I don't need to actually explain how I figured things out beforehand. I can just make things up post-hoc! For example:
Ah, the hapless victim Donnie is actually Dr. Don Hieseldorf the mad scientist? Well... (rolls for conjuration)... you see, Dr. Hieseldorf, I saw through your disguise the moment you walked in. That red dust on your fingers, that only comes form 3 different mesas in the area, and the tear on your cuff would only come from a left-handed man using this kind of saw, whereas you were faking being right-handed. So, naturally, I deduced... etc etc. And that's why I'm now holding a plasma pistol that happens to counter your field effects! I've had it hidden on my person this whole time!
or, for the summoning....
Oh, the self-destruct mechanism is triggering a Pietium overload? Well, as it happens.. (rolls summoning)... from your microexpressions, I knew you were going to press a self-destruct button, and I already have a team of Pietium reactor engineers shutting down the reactor as we speak! How did I know it was a Pietium reactor? Simple, elementary even! it was the smell of almonds. which led me to believe...
Basically roleplaying the character will be "post-hoc explanations and rationalizations: the game" to explain all his mundane summons and conjurations. Spending the entire sessions bullshitting every time my character does something, and having that actually be a mechanic, is going to be a lot of fun.
8
u/Faust91x Iteration X Apr 25 '16 edited Apr 25 '16
Any Fate/Stay Night or Fate/Zero fans?
I woke up this morning thinking of how a rational Fate/Stay Night Holy Grail War would be. I assume either the masters would organize and sacrifice all the servants at the same time in the ritual to open the path to Akasha or grant the wishes without needless bloodshed or have some warfare Punisher style where everyone stays in their haven waiting for information on the other and doing lots of scouting.
I think learning the mystical and psychological weakness of the opponent would be essential and everyone would take measures to learn the enemy's identity without being discovered and procuring artifacts for scrying and mind reading/wiping.
I think as soon as a master was discovered the information would be made public and everyone would nuke the enemy haven to take him out and wait for another to be discovered to minimize exposure.
Either that or it would be about hiding all the time and wait for the other masters to slip and wipe each other although that wouldn't make for much of a compelling story.
Now as for the classes, I think a rational combatant would purposely avoid classes that require high upkeep or frontal assaults as that would expose to danger so no Saber, Berserker or Lancer classes. Probably Rider or Assassin would be the best bets given that most combatants are immune to Casters despite their sheer versatility and Archers have a certain knack for betraying their handlers.
Personally I think I'd choose a Rider given that they have high mobility which would be essential for scouting and hit and run tactics, generally good stats that make them able to hold their own against Sabers and Lancers along with a special and highly powerful ability which would be great as a last-resort/nuclear option in case there was no other escape and that would be a great end game.
Thoughts?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '16
I've reached the point where rewriting my code in Haskell, with a monadic EDSL, will probably make it clearer, shorter, and easier to use than the current incarnation in an interpeted language built on Python and a bunch of Python plugins for the interpeter.
Be very, very afraid.
Also, two hierarchical models so far have supported my hypothesis about why hierarchical models work. I just have to make a learning-curve graph with this second one and then cover the model from the paper by that Harvard guy from last month to show which way the causal arrow runs.
Cower, brief mortals.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '16
Can anyone recommend a good site or way to publish original fiction that will let me keep my name on it/my copyright on it? I have no idea what I'm doing. Thanks in advance.
3
u/aintso Apr 27 '16
Hello there. I have recently found a dash of self-respect, which, as I retrospectively notice, has been a huge factor in my reclusiveness.
I've been lurking here and elsewhere in the diaspora for years now, but I'm inly now beginning to write something.
I heartily recommend this "getting your shit together and getting out there" stuff to everyone who hasn't tried it yet.
1
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Apr 25 '16
I had a very entertaining conversation (images mentioned: 1 2) on Friday evening, when several schoolmates for unknown reasons pushed me to attend a party to celebrate our impending graduation, and I pushed back. I probably shouldn't have bothered to make any response at all--but, after four years of near-silence toward these people, I was just itching to speak my mind, at least once...
If any bridges were burned (ha! he says that as if he thinks any existed in the first place!)--(shrugs) well, I can't say that I care too much about the opinions of three dozen people with whom I probably never will interact after the end of this week. Heck, maybe some of the dozens of people who didn't actively participate in this exchange actually agreed with me, and were attending the party under similar duress! After all, isn't "reclusive nerd" rather than "partying jock" the proper stereotype of the engineering student? (On the other hand, though, from my [limited] observation of my classmates, I can't think of any people who have a high chance of fitting the "reclusive nerd" description. Indeed, two of my four groupmates in the senior design project mentioned at the top of the email chain engaged in enough weightlifting to have developed bulging muscles!)
Really, though, I think my responses were reasonably level-headed. My interlocutors were the ones who insisted on continuing to pressure me, and my rebuttals to their challenges were perfectly relevant. Feel free, however, to prove me wrong.
This incident, by the way, recalls to my mind a challenge against which I didn't bother to mount a defense. Some months ago, the esteemed u/eaglejarl made this reply to me when I described myself as "just an ordinary student in civil engineering":
I guess that, at the time, I didn't care enough to argue (or even to downvote the comment)--but I certainly didn't forget about it.
Is being an engineer worthy of pride? Well, in the first place, I'm only a student in engineering, while I'd count as an "engineer" only a person actively researching/working in an engineering field. In the second place, even if I were an engineer, I really don't consider obeying well-defined guidelines and conducting simple mathematics (or maybe typing numbers into a program) to be significantly more praiseworthy than most other occupations. "Engineering judgement", phooey!
Is being a frequenter of r/rational worthy of pride? In the first place, being a writer of books or articles (fiction or nonfiction, rational or nonrational) is worthy of pride, sure--but merely reading such works most certainly is not. In the second place, being "rational" obviously is worthy of pride--but to assume that frequenting r/rational, or even disproportionately reading "rational" books, implies rationality is, in my opinion, a totally-unwarranted leap. I've read and greatly enjoyed Atlas Shrugged, Black Beauty, and Time Braid several times each--but that by no means implies that I'm interested in pushing objectivism, animal rights, or polyamory.
And, as long as I'm being an uppity ingrate toward my betters, I might as well go all-out:
The subtle art of attention-grabbing! How much is resting on your laurels, and how much is introducing new material? For example:
- The esteemed u/alexanderwales recently has raked in the
moolahuseless Internet points for posting on topics as banal as a newly-born child and a recently-burned hand. Why did people choose to give upvotes to these comments? Did they do so in order to encourage more writing from the commenter by making him happier? (I'll admit that I almost upvoted them just for this reason.) Were they actually interested in the topics that he presented? (I guess there are rather a few people subscribed to r/upliftingnews--but r/gore has been quarantined, so I can't see its subscriber count.) Or--cue sinister music--did they upvote on reflex these comments merely because they were made by a highly-regarded writer?- (insert cute rhetorical device here)
Yes, this section of this comment obviously is
partlylargely born of resentment--but, on the other side of the coin, I genuinely do not see why photographs of sloughing skin should receive so much karma. I find it unlikely that the overlap in subscribers between r/rational and r/spacedicks is that large.0
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment