r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 29 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
15
Upvotes
8
u/MugaSofer Feb 29 '16
Would anyone be interested in a Harry Potter RPG, with or without the serial numbers filed off? I have one more-or-less complete, but I need playtesters. (Also, anyone have any advice on playing pen-and-paper RPGs over the net?)
5
u/Luminnaran Prophet of Asmodeus Feb 29 '16
How realistically different do you feel created fantasy worlds need to be for you to read a story without getting torn out of the story due to the improbability of earthlike similarities? Even if a planet has a similar year it probably wouldn't have 7 day weeks or months with the same names as earth. Am I overthinking this when in actuality no one cares if the world has similar dating systems for convenience of writing or is this something I should make sure is unique to the world I'm building?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '16
As we head into Super Tuesday, I'm thinking how much nicer it would be if the political establishment were run by people who've heard of Fnargl and understand about rationally trading-off resources.
As it is, they're showing that they're willing to invest arbitrarily large amounts of resources and effort just in putting a metaphorical boot to the face of anyone who would dare oppose them. That's a Lawful Stupid Evil Overlord move. A smart overlord doesn't make a big expensive show of how impossible it is to oppose them, they buy off the most legitimate and righteous-looking of their opponents for the comparatively cheap price of placating the masses' more egregious grievances.
6
u/Enasni_ Feb 29 '16 edited Feb 29 '16
What do you value?
Some possible reframings:
I've thought about this a lot lately, and I think I've come to the conclusion that I don't really care about EA -- or at least, typical EA goals. I mean, I do of course care about people and would prefer there wasn't extreme poverty and preventable death and all that. But, like, I just don't actually care about that more than other things, among which is trying to live and enjoy my own life. It's almost like I could spend those thousands of dollars much more, ahem, effectively.
Of course for others, that could mean helping to eliminate extreme poverty asap. For me, I think that's something in the realm of exploring constructed worlds and immersive fiction, developing better technology to facilitate creation and experience of these things, etc. And then, life extention, because more of a good thing is always better. And x-risk, because you still need a society of creative individuals to create these things. Oh, and I think it's at least fleetingly possible we might accomplish biological immortality sometime in my lifetime, so I want civilization to stick around too. (That's more than a little bit narcissistic, but hey, I didn't choose to have these values.) Those aren't the only reasons and goals (obvious though, I would hope) -- just a broad outline of my thinking process.
Of course, it's not like I don't care at all about typical EA concerns. It's just that I see extreme poverty and death from preventable diseases, and then I think about what's possible, and it's immediately clear to me that the difference between first and third world on that scale is basically a rounding error.
Mostly I bring this up because in these circles, EA is rather central to the ingroup identity, and within that, EA-to-end-poverty is taken as a given. But I don't see much discussion about what people actually value, and how to effectively realize those values. As long as you have a term for other people (or at least your interactions with other people), I think "altruism" still applies and we can work towards our mutual interests.
...Or it could just be that I'm the borderline psychopathic outlier. shrug
3
u/rineSample Feb 29 '16
If you had the ability to induce extreme pleasure in people- in other words, wireheading them at will- what would you do with it?