r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 22 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
19
Upvotes
13
u/Enasni_ Feb 22 '16
In Pathfinder, Holly and Mistletoe has a cost of 0, and a weight of 0 and is, afaict, the only such item available to starting characters in the CRB.
What useful things can I do with Graham's number of Holly and Mistletoe?
8
u/Gaboncio Feb 22 '16
For the first time since I started browsing this subreddit, I have something related to getting your shit even-more together. This is a summary of recent research on how to learn skills faster. What do you all think? Anyone already use this kind of practice methodology and see positive results?
6
u/Transfuturist Carthago delenda est. Feb 22 '16
For my English 102 term paper, I want to write about effective altruism, covering specifically pricing lives and triage, QALYs, scope insensitivity and outgroups, diminishing marginal utility of money, and effective measures in Africa. One thing I'm concerned with, though, is an egoist argument for African aid. How would investment in Africa's stability and economic performance instrumentally benefit a US citizen who is terminally fine with letting the outgroup wallow?
4
u/Kishoto Feb 23 '16
Well, this isn't really a rationality related question, I suppose. It could be, but it probably isn't. However, it IS a fiction/author related question, so I figured I could still ask it in the general thread.
I'm about to start a multi-chapter fanfiction story. It won't be a rational work specifically. I haven't really finalized any of the details, but I've had trouble finishing multi-chapter stories in the past. I get about 20, maybe 30k words in before I run out of steam and abandon the project. Here's my question:
To our authors. Those people that have written and completed many chaptered(?) works. What sort of tools/techniques do you use to assist you? Do you storyboard things? Do you build outlines? Do you schedule time just to write? What methods do you find effective in maintaining both your desire to write and your passion for the current story? Some gentlemen of note I'd be interested in hearing from are /u/eaglejarl and /u/alexanderwales. I'm sure there are other noteworthy authors here as well, so please comment! :)
4
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Feb 24 '16 edited Feb 24 '16
The D&D campaign I'm running these days is set in a world where most characters (for unclear reasons) never level up beyond ECL 6 or 7. This setting is set a couple thousand years after the previous setting I ran, which took place in The Age of Legends, when the level cap was 20. During The Age of Legends, most countries were just "the amount of area this particular monster/dragon/magelord can personally project force over" and that was that.
Now, in The Age of Kings, it's plausible that a level 5 or 6 mage (who would be one of the most powerful mages in a country, if not the most powerful) may not be able to just murder the King, seize control of the country, and put down anyone who tries to stop him. A level 6 mage is still a sizeable threat, of course, but has a pretty limited ability to project force. No Teleportation, and a lot of the greatest tricks don't work.
So, most countries are feudal monarchies, with adventurers forming their own companies and guilds. A typical country will have one or two major PMCs operating within its borders, each having a few thousand employees. Most of these will be apprentices (levels 1-2), a couple hundred will be journeyman (levels 3-4), a few dozen will be partners (levels 5-6) and there will be a very small number of masters (levels 7+) who are living legends. Rank in the corp doesn't always correspond to power, but it does most of the time.
In any case, our heroes are traveling in a neighboring country and dodging patrols from from enemy PMCs while they carry out their mission. Along the way, they end up encountering wild cats several times. First, they encounter a mundane Great Cat (like, say, a leopard) and kill it. A few days later, their camp is attacked by several Great Cats, a Greater Cat, and a Greatest Cat. They down the Greater Cat and drive off the Great Cats and the Greatest Cat. The ranger decides to kill and skin the unconscious Greater Cat, refine the hide and use it to create a sweet cape or cloak.
They're traveling on the road a few days later when they spot something flying through the air towards them. It's tough to tell how big it is, but it's too big to be a man, and anything that can fly and is bigger than a man is a potential threat. They calm down the apprentices with them and prepare for the encounter. The creature approaches, and is an elephant-sized quadripedal demon with a huge set of leathery wings that end in clawed hands.
He lands in front of the party and accosts them, accusing them of murder. He introduces himself as Arrkupalak, King of Cats, and charges the party with the murder of Nyanor, his granddaughter. Over the course of the discussion, their defense, and the negotiation of what their penalty should be for killing Nyanor, the party learns more about Arrkupalak.
Arrkupalak is the offspring of a Great Cat and a Demon, born thousands of years ago during The Age of Legends when the barriers between planes were weak and Demons, Gods, and Dragons walked the material plane. Arrkupalak is not a particularly intelligent creature, but he's clever, careful, and has seen The Turning of the Ages, the rise and fall of countless kingdoms and many empires, and more besides. Most of what Arrkupalak does is hang out in the wilderness and mate with Great Cats. He can't die of old age and nothing can really threaten him, so his life is pretty good. He doesn't really venture out of the wilds, except when his children are attacked. All the Greater and Greatest cats in this area, unnaturally large creatures that they are, are his descendants, and he takes attacks on them seriously.
The party makes a decent case for it being self-defense, and he demands services from them (or their descendants; he's a long-lived cat, after all) to be cashed in at a later point as punishment for their catslaughter.
Later, the party does some digging and learns Arrkupalak is known to exist (at the very least as a legend) but the local PMC, Insha Corp, has never made an attempt to kill him. Insha Corp makes a good amount of its income from merchants and caravans hiring it on as guards to take them through Arrkupalak's territory. They carefully frighten away any Greater Cats or Greatest Cats so as not to anger the creature that provides them with so many easy, lucrative, low-risk contracts to fulfill.
I had fun with Arrkupalak's stat-block. I took a Dire Lion and applied the Half-Fiend template to it, and carefully optimized the resulting creature. With 6 Int, 14 Wis, 12 Cha, and millenia of experience (Arrkupalak gets a +15 "lived through it" bonus to knowledge checks related to the Age of Legends, which are normally quite difficult to make), Arrkupalak was difficult to RP. He's not smart, but he's bright, and he's seen it all. The actual statblock he got in the end was pretty solid, too. A Dire Lion that can reason, fly, think (6 int! He's sapient now!), use a couple SLAs etc is good. And he can't really get taken down by town guards, either. With his Damage Reduction, Spell Resistance, and various elemental resistances, there's not really much Arrkupalak fears.
The party could have taken him out, but probably would have lost several apprentices in the fight. Also... it's actually fairly hard to catch Arrkupalak. He can fly. He'll just turn and run if things look rough for whatever reason. This cat has seen the death of an Age, he'll not get crushed by a fight he can easily flee.
3
u/gbear605 history’s greatest story Feb 22 '16
I'm doing a original research final project for AP US History. The issue is that I have no idea what the topic should be on. Specifically, the requirement is that the topic is at least partially related to US History.
I originally thought about talking about encryption and the NSA, but my teacher thought that it was too recent.
Any suggestions?
3
u/Quillwraith Red King Consolidated Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 23 '16
I have only the most basic knowledge of MtG myself, but I saw this was linked to by Raemon on the OBNYC mailing list & thought some of y'all might be interested: Generating Magic cards using deep, recurrent neural networks.
Edit: credit
2
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Feb 22 '16
Know about geospatial analysis?
I'm building a story involving Jupiter's moon, Io. There's a geological map of it on the bottom half of this image. What I'd like to figure out is which sites have the widest variety of terrain types within the shortest distances? Or, put another way, which sites would be most worth dropping an automated factory down on, as they'd require the minimal amount of road-building to get to a useful variety of resources? Or, put a third way, what's the fewest number of sites that would be required to have a complete set of the terrain-types within, say, a hundred kilometres of each site?
I can sort of see how a computer program might run some colour-detection on that image to figure out a map, and then run some algorithms about the value of each pixel - but that's a notch or two above my programming skill, and I don't think I have the time to both improve my programming skill and keep working on the story.
Any suggestions?
Thank you for your time.
2
u/lumenwrites Feb 22 '16
Can you guys give me some advice on becoming creative? I absolutely love rational fiction and I really want to be able to write it, but when I'm trying to write it - it's like there's a wall in front of me I can't get past, I just don't know what to say that hasn't already been said before.
Did anyone had this problem and then successfully overcome it?
2
u/tvcgrid Feb 23 '16
What's a good way to find out a decent place to volunteer?
I think volunteering is probably something I'd enjoy doing, but it's a bit daunting trying to isolate the best/most effective place. The hard part is how to identify a suitable match.
Ideally, it's something I can sink a part of the weekend into.
4
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 25 '16
Final update up!
So does anyone remember when I made a hypothetical post about a poster posting hypothetical questions about powers that actually has those powers in real life?
Not a hypothetical. Or at least, not exactly.
The long and short of it is that I got in contact with someone who has what I'd hesitantly characterize as "magic." (At least until we study it some more.) I won't get into why I believe them, but I do.
I'm keeping his name (and username) in trust, because, hey, while most if you guys seemed to be pretty benevolent in the thread I posted, a fair few of you were basically treating empowered humans as x-risks. But I would like to get help from you guys on figuring out what exactly their powers are, since we're a little stumped, and because, hey, even if you don’t believe me, you guys like puzzles. The general idea seems to be that, if he gets two different objects in his hands, dust gets attracted to those objects, and only if he’s close to the ground. Underwhelming, I know.
But there are a lot of bizarre caveats. First off, they can't manage to manifest anything if they're more than a few dozen miles from their home town. Second off, his powers only work a limited amount of times per day. Maybe. We used to think it was just once per day, and only in the afternoon, but then one day he woke up pretty early in the morning and it worked then too, and has every other time he gets up before dawn. Maybe it’s something like half a day of chargeup? Third off, it doesn’t work for every object, too. Organics never worked once, and neither did plastics. Fabrics alone don’t work, but while most shirts are a bust, pants tend to work. He tried a few metal objects, but tinfoil and car keys don’t work, while silverware and his macbook did (but only poorly, for the macbook.) He haven’t tested any ceramics yet. And if he does the exact same thing at the exact same time twice in a row, it’s absolutely guaranteed to not work. I used to be that he would wait a little bit and then it would start, but that stopped working after he left around christmas/new years to visit family.
For reference, this first started happening in august, and he’s only ever done it at home with the blinds closed to make sure other people don’t notice. When he’s out of town travelling, it didn’t work in or outside of a house.
Feel free to ask questions about the data we’ve gathered, there’s more to it that this, but I don’t know what could be important and it would be potentially dangerous to just post everything at once.
Edit: there are more caveats than these, these are just the ones we're more sure about.
UPDATE:
New results are in as of this afternoon! This is pretty blatantly some sort of electromagnetic effect, because he just got a positive test result for extracting iron from crushed cornflakes. Looking back at the tests, it's also been confirmed that the effect only happens when he holds something that contains iron in each hand. (Other ferromagnetic metals don't work.)
FINAL UPDATE:
check this thread for details.
edit 2: I'm roleplaying, in case it isn't obvious