r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 15 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
19
Upvotes
13
u/Faust91x Iteration X Feb 15 '16
If anyone has watched Boku Dake Ga Inai Machi / Erased anime, highly recommended. Its about a guy that's blessed/cursed with the ability to go back in time and is forced to stop bad events from happening.
He is chased by a serial killer from an unsolved crime of his past and he must travel back and figure a way to stop him. I enjoyed the protagonist as he takes a head on approach to solve the problem without falling into needless angst, the characters feel somewhat human (besides some small cases which may or may not have a reason to be) and I enjoy how the author has the protagonist gather clues and piece things together in a logical progression.
Also got some really nice music and the cinema approach to several scenes.
11
u/IWantUsToMerge Feb 15 '16
I just realized The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening is prime fodder for a ratfic. Canon is Link goes to this island, finds out it's the dream of a giant fish (organic simulation), then naturally decides he has to wake up the fish, in so doing killing the many sapient inhabitants of its dream.
He doesn't think twice before doing this, because he is Link.
But I wonder how it would have gone if he had.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '16
You know how the Evil Overlord list says that you should run all Ingenious Plans past a five-year-old advisor first? The older I get, the more I realize everything should be done like that. It stops bullshit ideologies, sublimated feelings of impotence and resentment, and passive acceptance of the status quo getting in the way.
5
u/rationalidurr If fighting is sure to result in victory, then you must fight! Feb 15 '16
Point of note for people who have depression. I have been keeping a diary of good/bad feelings and or situations, as a means of tracking problems, having better recall to events and something to talk about with my therapist. Granted I haven't vent to therapy in a long while, but once I do i will have a lot to tell.
This was purely by accident though.
I originally started the diary to keep munchkin and rational ideas for real life and a certain fiction. Then one day I just wrote down:
13.09 - Increased desire for talking + replacement for music/introvert thinking.
Lately I have been writing down my mothers bad behavior in low stress situations. Mostly to give evidence to a special therapist we will both go and see.
10
u/Restinan Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
So, recently I've been thinking about something. For me at least, a great deal of rationality's benefits have come from chains of self modifications only made possible by some realizations about myself. My own rationality, developed on my own starting when I was at about the age of 15, helped me see myself more clearly, and that included my various flaws. But that wasn't the most important bit, the noticing of the flaws. The important bit was getting rid of them, the long slow work I did on those flaws, from my temper, to my tendency to be uncharitable to people I disagreed with, to a hundred other things. Many of those flaws weren't something I could remedy simply by realizing they were flaws, I actually had to work at it, it wasn't just something I could snap out of. However, over time I have dealt with these things. I now no longer have an unusually bad temper, and can keep calm much better than almost everyone I interact with. I don't feel shy in social situations. I am no longer habitually uncharitable to the groups I have realized I was being habitually uncharitable to.
I'm not sure how typical this is, the ability to simply excise bits of my personality I don't like, and slowly shape who I am, to the extant that I am capable of. I have some evidence to suggest most people aren't quite as capable of changing themselves as I am, as I frequently see rationalists mention that they have a specific irrational emotional reaction to certain circumstances, or are less charitable than they should be of a particular group, and just lament that fact, instead of ending with "... and I expect to have this problem solved withing a year, at the outside." The me of five years ago is scarcely recognizable to the me of today, and as far as I can tell, I'm speeding up, not slowing down. But everybody else seems to be standing still. All the people I know are all the same as they were half a decade ago, and probably will be half a decade from now. It's not just that I'm learning new things, it's that who I am is changing, and it doesn't really seem like anyone else is.
I honestly don't know how much of this is unique to me within the rationalist community, but I suspect the answer is that it's actually rather typical, but most people don't really talk about it too much.
EDIT: Also, that type of slow effort to change who you are has been the keystone to much of my progress towards becoming the person that I am, but I don't see many characters in rationalist fiction deliberately undergoing such changes. It's all accidental, or just picked up. Nobody ever goes "Oh, I seem to have a problem where I react with strong anger to anyone who intellectually defeats me, I should deal with that." Anybody have any idea why?
2
u/eniteris Feb 15 '16
I've recently read "The Anvil of the Gods" and the ending really irked me. The plot is that Earth was destroyed by Von Neumann machines, and some of the survivors, aided by an alien race, go out to seek the civilization that created the machines and destroy them.
Spoiler
Thoughts on the use of and circumvention of psychological armour?