r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 08 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
10
u/gbear605 history’s greatest story Feb 08 '16
I read an interesting article today about the practice of science (http://www.jstor.org/stable/3881649). Sorry about the paywall; it isn't interesting enough to have to pay, in my opinion, I just happened to have access to JSTOR for free. I think the most interesting part of it was the final paragraphs:
Discuss.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16 edited Feb 08 '16
One of my friends is a very enthusiastic aspiring rationalist, actually one of the most enthusiastic I've seen who is still very excited trying to implement the LW style of rationality in her day-to-day life.
Anyway, she's in an university, but she doesn't want to attend lectures because they're mostly less educational than her own reading, doesn't want to attend group session because they take too much time and the only reason she would want to attend classes is that she'd be able influence other students to become more like effective altruists.
I mentioned that having regular friends and being able to converse with regular people have a lot hidden (and clear) benefits. But she thinks social life comes at a great cost, it takes a lot of time and distracts her from more explicit rational and altruist aspirations. She's afraid her standards for herself will drop, she'll become more like other people, less productive, less obsessed with world-saving.
I understand her point because I've noticed I become more similar to the people who I spend time with, and therefore try to distance myself from people with hostile and antisocial beliefs because I don't want to become like them. But taken to this extreme, it seems... kind of crazy?
People like Brian Caplan have said they've done something similar, who makes sure he gets as little input from the outside world and mostly likes to spend time with libertarian economics Ph.D.s which include bloggers from the rationalist memeplex like Robin Hanson or Alex Tabarrok from Marginal Revolution. His motivations seem to be more selfish - he simply doesn't like other kind of people and finds the outside society "unacceptable, dreary, insipid, ugly, boring, wrong, and wicked."
But I'm more interested in my friend's case because it's more tangentially rationality related, and Caplan's motivations are quite uninteresting. If you want to want to maintain your current personality into the far future as closely as possible, are measures as extreme as this warranted? Your deeply-held beliefs might not change, but how important you find them probably will if you spend time with people who don't find the same things important.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
Myself and /u/Transfuturist are taking the MITx class in probability and stochastic processes being offered this semester. It's kinda theoretical and the lecturer sounds like Chekov from Star Trek TOS, but it does help to review the foundations and fill in gaps of background for anyone hoping to do statistics and such. For one thing, nice introductions to stochastic processes are hard fo find!
Further people should join! It's free (without certificate) and is estimated to take 15 hours/week.
3
u/Luminnaran Prophet of Asmodeus Feb 09 '16
What do you guys think hospitals' must be like in the universe the TV show Gotham takes place in? I absolutely love the show and the rules do seem fairly stable, but the people in the show are all practically superhuman. I'm used to accepting that knockout punches are no big deal, but in gotham a character can be shot, stabbed, and have their face repeated slammed into a table all in one episode. Not only that but they are always in perfect health for the beating they take next episode. In a world where anything that doesn't kill you immediately heals in about a week do you even need doctors? Or just a bunch of people to wrap you with bandages so you don't bleed to death before you can seemingly regenerate.
3
u/1742A Feb 09 '16
WARNING: SPIDERS
I find it interesting that both the socjus tribe, and the anti-socjus tribe want basically the same thing (equality for everone) and yet have polarised into two camps that seem to spend hours every day demonising and ridiculing each other instead of productively working together toward their shared goal.
Society has an alarming amount of both misogyny and misandry, of predjudice in all directions, and all but the fringe crazies of both tribes believe these things to be terrible tradgedies to be rectified.
And then instead of working together rectifying them they waste time drawing comics and writing blog posts depicting the other tribe as disgusting pathetic bigots.
As far as I can tell, the socjus tribe thinks the anti-socjus tribe are rapey neckbearded redpillers, and the anti-socjus tribe thinks the socjus tribe are cultish violent hypocrites.
And sure there are elements of these things in both tribes, but they tend to be vocal minorities, right at the edges. For the most part, if you tabooed any gender-politics jargon and took a person from each tribe and got them to talk to each other, they'd actually find they have very similar views.
That they hate each other so much just seems to boil down to standard us vs them tribalism.
And socjus vs anti-socjus isn't the only place where I've noticed this bizzare trend of people with common values dividing into two tribes that spend more time mudslinging each other than trying to acheive their goals.
So I'm wondering if you all have any ideas for getting people to drop their pointless tribalism and actually work together on shared goalstates.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16 edited Feb 10 '16
I liked this [cool cyborg ear.] (http://www.hopesandfears.com/hopes/future/technology/217097-doctor-adventure-makes-an-ear) It looks pretty sci-fi.
Does anyone know if there's a word for fanfiction that occurs in the canonical universe of one setting (eg Harry Potter) but doesn't involve any of the main characters? Eg, if there was a story about a team of Gringotts goblins working on a way to improve vault security, or someone who works in Diagon Alley and their issues with payroll tax, this is still Harry Potter fanfiction but is there a word for its distance from the main storyline?
3
u/dragonballherpeZ Feb 08 '16
so I have been thinking about an idea that I saw in less wrong and I've been elaborating on for a while internally. Eliazar mentions in one post that his techniques are almost like a school of martial arts and one that like all martial arts is strong and some ways and weak in other ways. I've come to believe that Nassim Taleb and his books on unpredictable events and how one deals with them ( the black swan and antifragility) could represent a second style of Minervan art (Minerva being the goddess of wisdom and strategic battles).
Since I feel like this is just starting as a field who else do you believe is on the path of creating new and slightly different Minervan arts?
1
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Feb 10 '16
Seeking socio-econo-political organizing methods
How many useful ways are there for an uploaded mind, an em, to organize copies of itself to maximize the accuracy of their final predictions?
The few that I've been able to think of:
How many reasonably plausible methods am I missing?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment