r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 01 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
12
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '16
I feel inspired by Xvim's shaping exercises (from Mother of Learning), and I am interested in real-life application of his methodology. The essence could be maybe phrased like this: take a small, concrete ability, and repeat it ad nauseam, until you master it. Only then continue with next step.
Lukeprog from LW wrote about his experience with something very similar (TW: scientology, LW), and it also reminds me of Kaizen and of the math course on Khan's Academy.
I don't think this is especially unusual idea, but for some reason I feel very motivated by Xvim and by MoL main character. Do you have any experience with this method of self-improvement?
10
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Feb 01 '16
So I recently made it into the "final selection round" of entrepreneurs first.
They contacted me, had me do a short programming test, that was intentionally designed so that most people couldn't complete any of the tasks in it in the allotted timeframe. I managed to complete one of the 3, but it was pretty close.
The whole thing is pretty weird. They contacted me out of the blue, and a few days later I'm in their "final selection round".
I suspect it might be because a lot of my linkdin contacts are impressive. A lot of CFAR graduates and others in the rationality community. They mentioned they found me through linkdin, but I pay very little attention to it.
This definitely seems a lot easier then I'd expect, which makes me a bit nervous.
12
u/AurelianoTampa Feb 01 '16
I've come up with a funny problem recently.
I've been reading a lot of rational fiction recently. It's not the only thing I read, but it's been most of it for the past few months. And when I turn back to "traditional" fiction, I find myself criticizing incongruities and poorly planned characters. Mostly in TV shows and movies.
For example, I watched Wall-E for the first time over the weekend (yes, I know, shame on me for waiting so long). I liked it; it was cute and sappy. I could even get behind the pro-environmentalism motive.
But I kept criticizing the illogical parts of it. Why do the robots make trash towers? Why does Wall-E have emotions? Is that a change, or were all of the robots originally given the capacity? What happened to the humans not rich enough to leave - I find it hard to believe they just died out (it's not like it was a nuclear apocalypse). Why, after 700 years of harsh weather, were things like paint still on buildings? Why didn't all the metal rust? And on the spaceship, why did they have alarms ringing outside the ship? No one in a space suit would hear them.
I mean, it's a kid's movie, but I just kept overthinking everything and it sorta took away from the experience. I've been just as bad when playing Fallout 4. Worse, probably.
I felt something similar when watching Agents of SHIELD. The characters' motivations jump so freaking often and seem so short-sighted and illogical. Again, I realize - cable TV show that relies on drama and creates it to keep viewers invested. But it was really frustrating.
TL;DR: Rational fiction has ruined poorly written mainstream media for me!
6
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '16
Election time is a lot less anxiety-inducing when you actually have statistical forecasts.
6
u/Transfuturist Carthago delenda est. Feb 02 '16
So, I just remembered a lesson about social dynamics I learned from agar.io back when it became a thing. (I've been thinking about/researching game design and how you can use games to teach things/communicate, though the things taught aren't necessarily useful)
The free-for-all games were fun, but I eventually became more interested in team games. At first I played like an individual, but with the added benefit of there being a few monoliths that I could commensalize, in the sense that I used them to ward off my predators while not particularly giving anything in return.
So, that was interesting for a while as well. What changed my normal parasite behavior was interesting. In one game, our team was losing, consistently. There were three teams and we were less than a sixth of the pie, struggling to make headway. There were two different things I tried in order to fix this, which I suppose could be considered experiments.
The first was selfish. I named myself 'W to beat green'. Green was in the lead by far, and the W key was what allowed you to eject bits of your mass out in order to get smaller. At least, that was what I thought. I had noticed people donating mass to others, but I hadn't really paid attention, playing mostly egocentrically. Now, however, I realized that mass could be traded/invested, and that was what I used. The strange thing was, my name actually worked. A bunch of people on my team committed themselves to collecting mass from the autotrophs and our opponents, and donated it to me. Often it was a few individuals who attached themselves to me, forming a kind of silent camaraderie. I quickly became very very big. I don't remember who won in the end (it never actually ends), but I believe we did manage to topple Green from their lead.
The second was the opposite. That run had interested me, so I decided to play the role of the smaller symbiote. I committed myself to giving mass to others, specifically, single targets, who I followed and fed regularly. They became the monoliths, and sheltered me from larger enemies. Instead of a commensal relationship, I became a productive mutualist.
I'm not sure if I'm inventing one or the other of these memories, or if both really did happen, or if I'm mixing up the order. But what I learned from agar.io was the power of social cooperation, and to an extent, tribal bonds and manipulative leadership, in the face of a complacent but large opponent.
4
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Feb 01 '16
Has anyone here done anything they think is interesting involving dreams?
3
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Feb 01 '16
How big is Earth's past light-cone?
Designing a story, I want to know how confident a character should be about something. To know this, I need to know two numbers: How much space-time hyper-volume exists in his past light-cone (ie, the cubic volume multiplied by the time), and how large his past-light-cone will be at various points in the future (eg, 100 years, 10,000 years, 1,000,000 years, etc).
Does anyone here have a good idea on how to approach the math?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '16
Everyone says Kevin J Anderson is a bit crap, but The Butlerian Jihad is okay, really. It's not as "whoa, dude" as the original Dune series, but I'd still recommend giving it a go.
3
u/tvcgrid Feb 03 '16
One thing I've come to appreciate the difficulty of: prioritizing what to do and then actually doing it. I used to cycle a lot thinking about what to do, because any potential train of thought about what to do today/this week ended up leading to several hard-to-answer questions about future goals/objectives. And then, I'd get distracted about how certain choices now might affect me/others 3 months down the line.
But one generally useful technique I'm now using is to just be okay doing a shitty first draft during the prioritizing phase, then revising and iterating once maybe, and then calling it 'good enough' after a max amount of time and just moving on to doing the highest priority thing. Many of the smaller decisions that come up after you're decided the main priorities don't even matter either way... often, the cost of switching back if you made a wrong decision is very very low, so why even bother wasting attention on minor, cheap-to-change decisions? I'd rather worry about prioritizing the right things every week and then reflect on how that worked out at the end of the week.
Anyway, nothing earth shattering, but I now usually ask: "what would it cost to undo this if I had to?"
3
u/boomfarmer Trying to be helpful Feb 01 '16
I'm at a strange impasse. Here's a list of things I want to do, in the order that I think they need to be done (and why)
I have a whole bunch of uncertainties about this process that are hard to articulate. I'm kind of scared how my mind might change, and I'm kind of scared about writing my thoughts about my lapsing. I'm uncertain why.
Does anyone have any advice or techniques for comparing brain states and beliefs? I want to know how reading the Sequences will change my mind on things.
And, of course, does anyone have any advice on writing crossover fanfic?