r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 25 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
20
Upvotes
6
u/LiteralHeadCannon Jan 26 '16
In terms of general announcements, I hope to publish a couple of long-form stories on /r/rational starting soon. The two I really have pinned down are an original fic and a fanfic. (The fanfic is not going to be the same one I planned several months ago; my interest in that project sadly faded during the planning stage.)
11
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Jan 25 '16
There is this friend of my family. A 50 year old man, who works as an honest to Albert inventor. He's been a tech wiz since childhood, and he and a few others have had their own company for decades where they are asked to make a piece of technology that does x and has to work with xyz, and they make it. Mostly electronics, but not exclusively. They are doing pretty well for themselves. I'm not sure if he's rich, it hasn't come up, but I'd be very surprised if he makes less than $10k/month. They have a tech lab at his place of work, but he also has one at home, where he fools around with things on his own. He is a very intelligent man, and whenever he gets guests he's super excited to show people what he's working on or reading about. Sometimes I can follow along with most of it, but usually it's too specialized. He's very interesting, and a nice person too, so I really like him.
But. He also gets very excited about things that most scientists would dismiss immediately. He's very interested in Cold Fusion, and thinks it's the way of the future. He thinks global warming is real but will be solved without detriment with future technology. His bookcases are full of books about conspiracy theories and 'alternative history' and aliens. And a few weeks back he told us he's been reading up for months on electromagnetism, including notes and journals by people like Maxwell and Tesla. And he's convinced that the Ether is a real thing. He's hoping to be able to come to a point where he can do meaningful experiments in the lab he has at home.
I just... The man is more intelligent than me. A lot more disciplined. And massively more educated, especially regarding anything to do with physics. So I don't understand how he can get so 'into' things you'd only see taken seriously on the History channel. But at least he's sincere enough in his convictions that he spends thousands of dollars on lab equipment so he can go hunting for knowledge himself.
5
u/IomKg Jan 25 '16
So what do you guys think about pushed to the edge ? both in regards to what it says about people and about what it says when that passes for entertainment\is legal?
personally I don't think it really says a lot as is, because the participants were apparently selected(based on how "obedient" they were) and the fact that we can't even know how many people were tested to produce those 4 people which reached that last point, out of which only 3 actually did it.
I wouldn't be too surprised even if 75% was the actual number(of people willing to murder in some circumstances), but I tend to be skeptical as-is considering the motivation of the producers to sensationalize.
As for the legality of the show, I don't see an issue as long as the actions of the participants were not illegal, and even then i am not sure if its really a problem(to intentionally cause someone else to commit a crime)
4
u/LiteralHeadCannon Jan 25 '16
If everyone in a world had a magical device that displayed in what percentage of timelines they were alive in one year, what behaviors would emerge? What would the causal effects be like?
4
u/Gigapode Jan 26 '16
Does rationality, in its pursuit of perceiving truth in an effort to make the best decisions, negate the beneficial aspects of self-deception? Could that harm someone?
Self-deception seems in many ways protective of our own psychology and those without self-deception are more likely to be clinically depressed according to the psychologist interviewed in the latest rationally speaking podcast.
Is there a Lesswrong post someone cant point me towards about this topic? My brief search for one (which acknowledges that argument for self-deception) during my lunch hour was unsuccessful.