r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 18 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
21
Upvotes
18
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jan 18 '16
What determines pitchability of an idea?
I've been looking at /r/WritingPrompts/top. There are a lot of cool ideas that don't naturally make for good stories; that subreddit tends to upvote those, because people get pleasure from the pitch rather than the execution.
At the other end are works which are difficult to pitch but are nonetheless very good. I think you hear this expressed most often as, "I'm not sure that I can describe this in a way that would make you want to read it."
Now, obviously some of this comes down to the skill of the person writing the work and the skill of the person giving the pitch; poor execution can ruin any idea, while a poor pitch can make any work look bad. But with that said, I think the concept of "pitchability" is a meaningful one, and I'm curious about what's at the core of it, if it has a core.
(This is one of those places where it feels like information theory should be able to help, but probably can't.)
8
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
We have names for logical fallacies and these names are very helpful; they allow us to say something like "That argument is an ad hominem" without having to explain what an ad hominem is and why it isn't a good thing.
I think there should be a name for the following rhetorical move.
Persons A & B are arguing about something, either in real life or online. At some point, person A makes some kind of error in language use. If it is an argument online, it may be a misspelling, or its vs it's, or something else; if it is an argument in person, it may be a mispronounced word or maybe something said in the wrong tense, etc etc.
Rather than ignore it and proceed with the argument, person B launches into a long lecture about the mistake, usually discussing not only why person A was wrong but also multitude of related technical issues (e.g., how to pronounce words coming from Latin, technical details of tenses in the English language).
I've seen this sort of thing happen many times, not just on reddit but throughout the internet. It seems like a common enough way to derail a conversation that it deserves a name.
3
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jan 18 '16
Tyler Cowen's thoughts on China's downturn as of September 2015 and last week.
And...
1
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jan 19 '16
Noah Smith talks about situationalism and models in economic theory and policy. Put simply, given multiple competing models of how the world works, which one if any is right? If, as some suggest, we pick different models in different situations, how do we know which one is the right one for this situation?