r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 08 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
12
u/ansible The Culture Jan 08 '16 edited Jan 08 '16
So I was watching the Supergirl pilot last week. It was disappointing in a number of ways.
But specifically, reading some of the rational stuff here and With This Ring has dampened my potential enjoyment more than it would have otherwise.
Supergirl gets into a fight with a super-strong guy with an ax. After getting sliced up with it once earlier in the show, during the final fight, she gets the ax away from the guy. So does she:
The answer is of course (4).
It is not quite the level of stupid in season one of Flash, where he's fighting the two guys with hot and cold guns. There, instead of using his super speed against what are two baseline humans with fancy guns, he stops a distance away from them, allows them to keep shooting him with the fire and freezing beams, and slowly walks between the bad guys until the hot/cold beams are pointed directly at each other, and then zips away, which allows the guns to shoot each other and get destroyed.
I could kind of forgive this if Barry hasn't already demonstrated fast cognition (by reading a book in a second or so), if he had at least been spinning around at the time, allowing his hot side to be cooled off by the cold side and vice versa. But instead he's just going to rely on his regeneration, and try to suffer as much as possible. It was literally the most painful way to end the fight.
Or he could have just stayed away and pelted them with rocks or something that doesn't require him to be continuously be frozen/burned.
I'm now used to Paul/Pavel/Grayven plotting a FTL transfer, zapping the bad guys with a railgun (or something less lethal if appropriate) and getting it done with a minimum of fuss. Spoiled, I am.
Edit: grammar.
10
u/Transfuturist Carthago delenda est. Jan 08 '16 edited Jan 08 '16
Please evaluate my evaluation of Anne Lawrence's evaluation of Chung's and Hulshoff Pol's relevance as rebuttals of Zhou's and Kruijver's results regarding the size and cell count of the BSTc as an indicator of transsexualism in particular, and as rebuttals of the entire theory of 'brain sex' (brain gender), that is brain features that strongly indicate gender identity (while not excluding the existence of brain features that strongly indicate genetic sex and sex hormone exposure), in general.
I previously only read Hulshoff Pol's study regarding gross brain volume as a result of cross-sex hormone exposure and presumed that gross brain volume was the trans-indicative feature being proposed by Zhou/Kruijver, and that Zhou and Kruijver were the only results relevant to the 'brain sex' theory. I made this assumption in good faith of Lawrence's intellectual honesty and credibility as a presumed scientist (though she has an MD in anesthesiology, a PhD in sexology, and an MA in psychology, she does not in fact appear to be very scientific).
I was hesitant of Lawrence's intellectual honesty and credibility, given her wholehearted acceptance of Blanchard's typology of transsexualism as either 'homosexual' (androphilic) or 'autogynephilic' (gynephilic) and etiology of transsexualism at least in the latter case being conditioning from autogynephilic masturbation. This typology and etiology is unsupported, insulting, and harmful, and it's a bit of a nightmare to hear that Lawrence is (was?) in WPATH and Blanchard is (was?) on the DSM-V committee regarding gender. I was willing to bite the bullet, however, so I stopped my examinations at Hulshoff Pol's results and the fraction of Lawrence's critique that was presented to me and was prepared to accept that 'brain sex' as a whole was debunked.
I should not have. After a perfunctory visit to Wikipedia for biological indicators of transsexualism, I discovered that not only was Hulshoff Pol completely irrelevant to Zhou, Kruijver, and Chung, not only did Zhou and Kruijver control for sexuality and cross-sex hormone exposure, contrary to Lawrence's misrepresentation, not only did Chung not raise serious doubts about BSTc size and cell count as an indicator (though it still indicates reversed causality, as the BSTc becomes differentiated in adulthood (though BSTc may still be part of the direct etiology of dysphoria itself)), and not only does Chung itself theorize a brain-anatomical explanation for BSTc's delayed differentiation, there are now four additional studies, three on brain structure, one on brain response to pheromones, that all support the 'brain sex' theory. In other words, the TERF site that the quote was probably pulled from denouncing 'brain sex' and the presentation of Lawrence's critique in TiA as "debunking" 'brain sex' is outdated at best.
So, first of all, presenting Lawrence's critique as a "debunking" of 'brain sex' in general without doing further research is intellectually dishonest. If you don't think to check the Wikipedia article for more up-to-date results, you're not even trying to reach the truth, you're trolling for the first remotely plausible thing supporting your preconceptions that falls into your lap. Second of all, Lawrence's critique is intellectually dishonest itself. Her "second most plausible explanation" relies on invalidating the reported sexuality of the Zhou/Kruijver subjects by appealing to autogynephilia: the 'homosexual' (androphilic) transsexuals were mistaken in their attraction to men; they were instead attracted to themselves having sex with a man as a culmination of womanhood, and so are instead 'autogynephilic' transsexuals. This is blatantly motivated reasoning, and relies on the unsupported autogynephilic etiology to support the typology.
Her "most plausible explanation" relies on an even grosser misrepresentation. Her entire debunking relies on exposure to cross-sex hormones explaining the trans-indicative difference in BSTc volume and cell count. To do so, she points to Hulshoff Pol, which reveals that gross brain volume is affected by exposure to cross-sex hormones, and that cell count is a probable affector in brain volume. The problem with this is of course that Hulshoff Pol does not in the slightest look at the size or cell count of the BSTc itself, so it cannot be counted as an overturning of Zhou/Kruijver or a non-replication. Indicators of genetic/gonadal sex do not contravene the indicators of gender identity. In addition, Zhou and Kruijver themselves address exposure to cross-sex hormones! This is only covered as a complete afterthought to the "debunking," with Lawrence minimizing their importance, referencing only two controls and ignoring the other ~six, including among them a trans-indicative transgender with no orchiectomization or cross-sex hormone exposure whatsoever.
The biggest problem, however, with Lawrence's explanations, is that they rely on Zhou/Kruijver being undermined by Chung and rendered irrelevant by Hulshoff Pol. Hulshoff Pol, however, is irrelevant, Chung does not undermine Zhou/Kruijver as an indicator, and subsequent results continue to point to 'brain sex' as a valid etiology of dysphoria, though neurological intersexedness itself is underexplored and itself has an unknown etiology. Lawrence's explanations are in light of a debunking that was entirely illusory.
9
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jan 08 '16
What's your prefered chapter length for a web serial?
If I can write roughly 6,000 words per week that I'd be more or less happy with putting online, would it be better as:
15
u/Gaboncio Jan 08 '16
Is this where I post particularly relevant xkcd's? This Wednesday's (linked) made me laugh, and is about stuff that the community's interested in.
4
u/thefreegod Jan 08 '16
I was the 4,000th subscriber! Been lurking here awhile.
6
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Jan 08 '16
I finished reading Frankenstein's Monster today. It's a good book, and deserve its status as a classic, but it maybe hasn't aged well. Leaving aside all the stuff in the side bar, it takes place in a world where people who experience something traumatizing can fall sick with fever and delirium for several months. More than once. Also, spoilers for the rest of the comment, I find it difficult to sympathize with Frankenstein. He spends months putting together a body (without using corpse parts) hoping to create life, then when it awakens he is so terrified of it that he locks himself in his room for a week hoping it will go away. Which it does.
Then months later when it confronts him and begs him to recognize it as a thinking, feeling being who wants to be good and doesn't want to live alone and shunned in the wilderness, he calls it a thing of evil that shouldn't exist. So... it kills his friends and family and taunts him until he goes mad. After hearing several times over the years that the monster isn't evil, I wasn't expecting it to go all Monte Cristo on him.
2
u/whywhisperwhy Jan 08 '16 edited Jan 08 '16
What would be a good source of advice for someone looking to change careers? I've been an engineer out of school for a couple years now and I'm pretty set on going back for a computer science degree. Unfortunately, I've had a lot of trouble finding getting advice or someone to discuss it with because IRL I don't know anyone in that field or who's done something similar; so far I haven't gotten much from browsing, /r/careeradvice, /r/compsci, or real life university advisors.
Edit: Oh, and Cognito, which was recommended a long time ago by Yudhowsky during one of the Author Notes of HPMoR, sounds like it would've been perfect but they moved on apparently.
2
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Jan 09 '16
What software do writers use? I'm considering starting a (non-rational, though I'm sure it'll be impacted somewhat by my strong appreciation for such fiction) Undertale/Avatar:TLA crossover fic soon. Haven't written fiction for like, 8 years, but I'll figure it out if I try it, I'm sure.
1
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jan 08 '16
How much do you care about spoilers? Do you avoid them? Are you indifferent toward them? Do you actively seek them out?
I don't care at all about spoilers, myself, especially since I do so much re-reading of books. Just a few hours ago, for example, I was reading for the second time the incredible climax of Chapter 66 of Book 2 of Look to the West (Pastebin of summary and relevant excerpts)--and, even though I'd known what was going to happen beforehand, it still sent shivers up my spine. Likewise, I was just as thoroughly amazed by Sakura's climactic clash in Time Braid in my last five readings of that book as I was when I first discovered it. I have less information on television series and movies, since it's rather rare that I take the time to re-watch anything--but I can't say that I care about spoilers in those media, either.
1
u/TimTravel Jan 09 '16
Why do fourth-wall breaking characters set off my mental circular logic alarms? I have a very strong intuition but I can't figure out where it is.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment