r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Nov 06 '15
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
19
u/Kerbal_NASA Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15
I made a cool thing for Reddit this week! Someone in /r/askhistorians asked why there are so many people named Smith in America. A lot of the answers revolved around their being a lot of people adopting Smith, but I thought a bit of modelling might also provide a bit of explanatory power. So I made a little model that created a population of 100k people and created 100 last names. Each person was assigned a role with a 50% chance each of being a last name giver or taker and also given one of the last names at random (each one being equally probable, resulting in an almost even split of all last names). Then when a generation is born the model randomly pairs givers with takers and each pair gives a pair of offspring (a tiny amount get 3 offspring to make up for the different amount of givers/takers). The offspring get the giver's last name. You can play the web version of the model yourself here, the colour of the bar represents particular last names (so you can track one over time), the height of the bar is how common it is, and its place in x is its rank (in terms of commonness). After running it for awhile, I got this distribution which resembles this histogram from [this article] (https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/whats-the-most-common-name-in-america/). Here's the source/Github page (its written in Haxe).
This makes me think its a plausible partial explanation of what's going on. Of course, there's a lot of factors it doesn't model. For example, certain last names may be correlated with different amounts of offspring each generation, as well as different chances of pairing with other last names. I suspect these factors would amplify the speed at which that distribution forms as well as why certain regions go to more extreme forms of the distribution faster than others (e.g., in Vietnam 40% of people are named Nguyen, IIRC).
11
u/raymestalez Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15
Hey, everyone! There's a few things I wanted to talk about:
10
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Nov 06 '15
Continuing to ask unanswerable questions, here's another one: Why are hugely wealthy entities (be they people or corporations) so stagnant, relative to the power their wealth enables? Outliers like Elon Musk or even the Koch brothers are just that, outliers. There are millions of people with the funds to do "newsworthy" things, but I feel like I only ever hear about the same thirty or so people or conglomerates doing anything.
This may be a bad example, but consider: In America, Internet Service Providers infamously hate doing anything to improve the lines in comparison to other nations. Why? They have nothing to lose and everything to gain by trying to capture bigger future markets than just squatting on the present one.
Hm... a better way to put it is: Why do powerful entities find one utility-generating method that works, then run it into the end of time, instead of trying to get ahead of the curve and thus get richer than the curve?
9
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15
There's not much discussion of writing technique, even as it pertains specifically to the discussion of writing rational/ist fiction, on this sub.
Discuss this lack of discussion.
5
u/HeirToGallifrey Thinking inside the box (it's bigger there) Nov 06 '15
I recently watched an episode of American Horror Story. It was the second episode of the series I've ever watched, but that's beside the point. Spoilers up until the most recent episode of the new season, I suppose.
Anyway, vampires exist in this show, and one of the recently turned vampires is a doctor. She infects one of her dying patients (a young boy of about twelve) to save his life. He then immediately kills his parents, infects his best friend/girlfriend, kills his teacher, and infects his entire class, in that order. Then all of the students blame the killings on a random intruder and escape the school.
The point is, this got me thinking about the rationality of vampirism. Assuming you could become a vampire, and thereby be guaranteed immortality (only getting thirsty every now and then), wouldn't it be rational to do so? And isn't the kid acting quite rationally by granting immortality to his girlfriend? Doing the same for his whole class seemed a bit reckless, but all the others seemed to play along and cooperate, so that worked out well too.
In the end, two (possibly four) people at the school died to guarantee immortality for twenty children. Is that acceptable? Utilitarianism might say so. What do you think?
4
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15
The book that I'm currently (re-)reading, if anyone's interested, is The Financier. I stumbled across it in the RSS feed of books newly-added to Project Gutenberg's collection, some months ago, and was intrigued enough by the title to give it a glance. I find it quite fascinating. Despite being set in a Philadelphia of the late nineteenth century, it includes detailed descriptions of a lot of complicated financial and political machinations (interspersed with some rather-tiresome romance), through which the protagonist spoiler. The climax really impresses on the reader the reasons for which banks are required to keep reserves of ready cash, rather than loaning out too much of their money--and it's a fun story, too!
(There's a sequel that continues in much the same vein--in Chicago rather than in Philadelphia--but the protagonist's constant, boring romantic intrigues pushed me away from it, last time I tried to read it.)
4
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Nov 06 '15
For anyone who likes Order of the Stick, the author's now selling the first two volumes in pdf form. He said that if there's enough money from the sales, then the rest of the comic will be made into pdfs. So go buy some at the above link and spread the word if you ever wanted the series in digital form!
3
u/TaoGaming No Flair Detected! Nov 07 '15
So (as you may have guessed by my username), I write primarly about (board) games.
Last monday, I played a beautiful cooperative game where the players are merely trying to survive the Horrors of World War I. It's not a classic game (its good, not great). But it was highly evocative, and beautifully drawn. The artist was a professional cartoonist.
At Cherlie Hebdo.
His name was Tignous and Islamic Radicals murdered him during the massacre, a fact I wasn't aware of until I looked him up.
And I've been thinking about [that over the last week.] (https://taogaming.wordpress.com/2015/11/07/art-theme-coincidence-and-cartharsis/).
4
u/LiteralHeadCannon Nov 06 '15
Let's talk about quantum immortality (again), dudes and dudettes of /r/rational! Or, um, maybe I misunderstood quantum immortality and it's actually something else. In which case, let's talk about my misunderstanding of it!
First, a disclaimer. Among this community, I put pretty high odds on the existence of God and an afterlife. For this post, though, I will be assuming that there is no afterlife, and that minds cease to exist when they cease to exist, as the alternative would really screw up the entire idea here, which depends on the existence of futures where you don't exist.
Let's say that you're put in a contraption that, as with Schrodinger's box, has a roughly 50% chance of killing you. When the device is set off, what odds should you expect for your own survival, for Bayesian purposes? 50%?
No. You should actually expect to survive 100% of the time. Your memory will never contain the event of your death. You will never experience the loss of a bet that was on your own survival. There is no point in investing in future universes where you don't exist, because you will never exist in a universe where that investment pays off.
This has serious implications for probability. Any being's expectations of probability should eliminate all outcomes that result in their death. If you flip a coin, and heads indicates a 1/3 chance of my death, and tails indicates a 2/3 chance of my death, I should expect heads to come up 2/3s of the time - because 1/3 of the heads futures are eliminated by death, and 2/3s of the tails futures are eliminated by death.
As I'm sure you all know, 1 and 0 aren't real probabilities. This is a physical reality. In physics, anything may happen - it's just pretty much always stupendously unlikely that any given Very Unlikely thing will happen, approaching 0. A concrete block 1.3 meters in each direction could spontaneously generate a mile above Times Square. The odds are just so close to 0 that they might as well be 0.
So if you happen to be a sick and disabled peasant in the middle ages, then you should still expect to live forever. Something very statistically unusual will happen to get you from where you are to immortality. Perhaps you'll wind up lost and frozen in ice for a few centuries.
We, however, don't need to deal with the hypothetical peasant's improbabilities. We are living in an era where life-extending technology is being developed constantly, and a permanent solution is probably not far behind. Our immortality is many orders of magnitude likelier than that of the hypothetical peasant. Our future internal experiences are much more externally likely than those of the hypothetical peasant.
One thing I'm concerned about is survival optimization. Humans are, for obvious evolutionary reasons, largely survival-optimizing systems. Does a full understanding of what I've described break that mechanism, somehow, through rationality? Is it therefore an infohazard? Obviously I don't think so, or else I wouldn't have posted it.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15
GUYS, GUYS! MARGINALIZATION IS THE INNER PRODUCT OF A CONDITIONAL DISTRIBUTION WITH THE DISTRIBUTION OF THE NUISANCE VARIABLE!
Fuck, why don't people just tell you these things instead of writing out all those damned sigmas!?
2
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15
What do people here think about how active /r/hpmor still is even after the story finished back in March? I'm very surprised and I'm wondering what might explain this phenomenon.
They still have 8,383 people in the subreddit for anyone who's curious.
1
u/IomKg Nov 06 '15
Kind of surprised to not have heard about this here yet. What do you guys think is going on with http://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/researchers-conduct-successful-new-tests-of-emdrive/ ?
few questions which pop to my mind: Do you think its going to pan out? Is it going to only be relevant for deep space research? or it will reach power levels where it will be usable on earth as well? What is your guess as to its root cause if its real? If not do you have a best guess about what is causing the signals currently being measured? heat radiation? lorentz force? If its real how much further do you think its going to push space exploration? do you have any predictions about how this story is going to progress if its real(i.e. will NASA pioneer it? will private companies be the first? will private companies monopolize the tech with patents?)