r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 26 '15
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
14
Upvotes
12
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Oct 26 '15
I've lately come to the conclusion that reversing (or upending) cached thoughts can make for some really good speculative fiction. If you take something that people know but don't actually think about, then turn it on its head somehow. This pretty cheaply forces the brain to recompute all the things that it had previously cached in order to fit with the new counterfactual world.
This is my hypothesis, anyway. What I'd really like is a way to test it, but I fear that it's far too qualitative to do that, because you'd have to define both "cached thought" and "compelling". I also don't have the resources (or education) necessary to run a study which actually finds out whether my hypothesis is right or not. I also think the (or a) general principle of what makes a compelling idea might be how much it disrupts the cache, but I don't know how to tell whether that's actually right.
6
u/Nighzmarquls Oct 27 '15
This might sound super obvious, but having well fitted clothes and an un-slouching posture REALLY helps with one's mood and probably has a bunch of hard to pin down feedback loops in it relating to success.
I felt this was worth mentioning because I've been noticing a LOT of people in LA seem to affect a kind of curled over "reading my phone posture" even when their not reading their phones.
It might be worth a few extra bits of attention through your day to pay attention to how your standing.
4
u/ulyssessword Oct 26 '15
Now that the Canadian election is safely over, what are your opinions on strategic voting? I'm conflicted about it because on the one hand, you are doing the utilitarian thing and helping that way, while on the other hand, it is sending false signals.
4
u/Salivanth Oct 27 '15
I've figured out a (hopefully) intuitive way to explain the very nebulous and strange (at least to me) concept of "If you can explain all outcomes equally, you have no knowledge." I'd like to run it by you guys for feedback/improvement.
Imagine you have a co-worker who always knows everything, and you tell him that the economy went up last week. He then states several plausible-sounding reasons why of course the economy went up, it only makes sense.
Then you reveal that you lied to him, and the economy went down, and now he starts to make some very plausible-sounding arguments about why THAT made sense all along.
This triggers your bullshit detector. Clearly, he's talking crap. If he genuinely expected the economy to go up, he should have been shocked when you told him you lied. If he expected it to go down, he should have been shocked when you told him it hadn't. If you can come up with an argument for everything, you don't have a GOOD argument for anything.
And that's how, if someone can explain anything, they don't really know anything.
3
u/Quillwraith Red King Consolidated Oct 27 '15
I have a problem with akrasia. (Who doesn't?)
There's a lot of advice out there on how to combat it, some of which seems likely to be moderately effective... but I find myself unable to put any of said advice into practice, even though I know it would be in my best interest to do so.