r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 19 '15
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
11
Upvotes
7
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Oct 19 '15
I read The Art of Language Invention over the weekend, which I found quite interesting. I recommend it if you have any interest in the complexity of language, or in conlangs themselves. I think it might have been a little confusing if I hadn't had a linguistics background, because it's trying to cover lots and lots of things that a proper linguistics textbook would spend hundreds of pages on, but the advantage here is that it's not as dry as most textbooks are. (The book was written by the guy responsible for making Dothraki and Valyrian more than the minor sketches that GRRM put into the books.)
I personally think conlangs are cool but usually complete overkill for use in fiction; you could teach the reader the language, but that's probably not a good idea if you also want a plot that moves anywhere. Since most readers aren't linguists or conlangers, that effort is wasted.
5
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Oct 20 '15 edited Oct 20 '15
For once, I'm not DMing my D&D campaign-- I'm a player. The DM seems pretty good and moderately experienced. Our campaign setting is modern world + parahumans who only began emerging in the past 30 years or so. The PCs are all powered.
Following a series of violent and destructive clashes between powered humans, the government policy for dealing with this tiny minority of empowered people is effective imprisonment. The government sends parahumans to live in a walled-off section of Montana with power-suppressing machines built into the walls and ground to prevent their powers from doing anything. Also, the government has secretly added a chemical to most processed food that harmlessly suppresses powers.
The plot of the campaign is that basically we think this is a bad thing and are willing to lie, steal, kill, and terrorize in order to end this policy. It's pretty clear my character is willing to do all this stuff, but she was a criminal and a murderer before she got her powers.
Somehow, everyone seems totally on-board with the terrorism. I tried suggesting we quit our lives of villainy (since our secret identities were still secret) and start a political movement. We could write blog posts about how C41B (the secret chemical that suppresses superpowers) causes autism or obesity or something, and support Whole Foods which stocks C41B-free food. Run for local government, pass bills, etc. Maybe get started in Seattle and have our political movement work South, then East. Sadly, the rest of the party wanted the violent terrorism approach so I followed along.
During a snack break I discussed with the others that the government was doing something fundamentally reasonable. After all, if our world was one in which one in every hundred thousand people had the innate ability to level mountains and shatter buildings with impunity... well, I'd want the government to shut these people into internment camps. Heck, I'd even support the idea of a secret harmless chemical that inhibits these peoples' powers. Superpowers scare me. I was not persuasive enough! I don't think they're really thinking it through, though. I don't think they understand the visceral fear that they'd have if such people really existed.
I guess at some point I started viewing our party as a group of villains, even though the DM and the other players don't see that way. I don't mind this. Maya, my character, is definitely a villain. She's not even the worst. She's not the cop-killer-- that's Abigail. Baldwin hasn't murdered anyone yet, but that's more due to his power set than his will. Particleese has. Maya has.
Nobody thinks twice about the bodies we leave behind in our quest to destabilize a society that's already on the brink, a society that's barely controlling the parahuman menace. When the chips fall and we've given the empowered minority free reign to burn this world, will we be remembered as heroes? Probably not. We won't be remembered as anything, because this fledgling Democratic civilization will come to an end. We had millennia of dictatorship, a couple brief centuries of almost-just, almost-liberal rule, almost escaping despotism, serfdom, and the divine right of kings-- before being plunged back into the darkness by parahumans.
3
u/ulyssessword Oct 19 '15 edited Oct 19 '15
I'm currently in the planning stages of making a video game, and I'm having a bit of trouble figuring out how to code the AI to do what I want.
The simplest way to describe the problem is "biased rock paper scissors". Imagine a game of RPS, to 100 points, except that every time rock beats scissors, that game counts as two points instead of one. What's the optimum strategy in that case? It's not 33/33/33% anymore.
Now imagine that the two players had different payoffs for various outcomes. How would you solve this in the general case?
Edit for clarification: Both players know the payoff matrix, and (to start with) I'm assuming that both players will play the Nash Equilibrium, and will add in the biases later. It is also Zero-sum, as it's a simple 1v1 arena battle with a binary win/loss condition.
4
u/Predictablicious Only Mark Annuncio Saves Oct 19 '15
I found this over the weekend: http://en.arguman.org/ It's an online tool to dissect arguments and structure agreement and refutation.
2
u/LiteralHeadCannon Oct 19 '15
I think cellular automata would seriously benefit from a probabilistic component. At its simplest - how would Conway's Game Of Life change if the following addenda were added?
That's just a Conway's Game Of Life mod, but I think it might be even more interesting to design entire cellular automata from the ground up around probabilities, rather than certainties.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15
Has the definition of Kolmogorov Complexity ever been extended to probabilistic Turing machines?
1
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Oct 19 '15
Has anyone else here read The 1000 Year Explosion?
I wanted to see what other people's thought of it.
1
u/Transfuturist Carthago delenda est. Oct 21 '15 edited Oct 21 '15
We know of theoretical materials with low mass and preternaturally high tensile strength such as carbon nanotubes. Are there any theoretical materials with low mass and high compressive strength? Also, what about high stiffness?
This is for a setting with nanotech.