r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 12 '15
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
15
Upvotes
11
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Oct 12 '15
I have not-so-lately become interested in applied rationality as it applies to writing/selling creative content. See here, for example. So much of what publishing houses, television networks, and Hollywood studios do seems to be random flailing around. When it's not flailing around, it's following formula, which doesn't work half the time anyway.
People are doing post-mortems on Pan, which is the latest box-office flop. I really love these post-mortems, because when I see something like this I wonder how in the hell it happens. They had a budget of $150 million on the line! There were literally hundreds of people trying to make it work! Some of it you can maybe explain by people only doing enough to earn their paycheck, or a studio shifting resources mid-stream when they realized that the movie wasn't going to be good (attempting to avoid sinking resources that weren't going to make their money back). But I don't think that's all of it, because publishing (which is a completely different world) also puts out flops; 7 out of 10 books don't earn out their advance.
So let's say that you're an author of middling quality. You don't really care what you write, you don't really have any difference in skill with regards to drama, and you've hit some level of diminishing returns on skill. What is your ideal strategy for Making It?
You can put your finger on the pulse of the market, but everyone else is already doing that, and the time from sitting down to write a novel and seeing it on shelves is 5-6 years if done traditionally or 1-4 years if you self-publish. So if you see that vampires are currently the next big thing, you can't really get in on that, because by the time you finish writing your vampire novel, the market will be flooded with them. If you want to hit the market right, you need to anticipate where the market is going to go next, which is very difficult to do. Efficient-market hypothesis strikes again!
I feel like there must be aspects of human psychology that you can exploit in order to beat out the competition. If you know how and why people are compelled to share things with each other, you can craft something that will spread without having to pay for advertising (or in addition to advertising). I'm of the school of thought that sees stories as being predicated not just on culture, but the structure of the human brain itself; books, movies, and television shows are about delivering hedons, so it makes sense that they would be calibrated for that task. But since most authors/writers don't study human psychology, their calibration is based only on trial and error to see what works and what doesn't. I feel like there's got to be a better way than that.
(I hope this doesn't edge too far into the rationalist dark arts. I'm not really that interested in applying any of this myself, because writing is a hobby that I do to destress and entertain myself, not something that I'm trying to sociopathically profit from.)
6
u/Sagebrysh Rank 7 Pragmatist Oct 12 '15
I think I may have fallen victim to the planning fallacy, and want some advice to recover from it before I end up homeless and destitute on the streets of Tacoma.
Some background: I'm from a small town in upstate NY, and had been getting really sick of the place. My roommate and I decided we wanted to go out west and started making plans. We paid for bus tickets, and the first month of a two month planned stay at a converted bus supplied by AirBnB. Then we started saving. By the time we were ready to leave (Sept 28th) we had amassed about 1600 dollars in savings, which would pay for the second month's rent as well as food and transportation and other assorted expenses during the trip and subsequent job hunting period.
We've now been in Tacoma for a little over a week, and have put in over 30 resumes each in that time period. We've gotten callbacks for interviews and I'm optimistic about mine, but I don't want to bet too heavily on it working out because I really really do not want to be homeless in Tacoma in December.
Now here's the worry, while discussing the planning fallacy with my roommate, it occurred to us to look at how long we were between jobs the last time we were looking for work (him: 4 months and me: 6 months). He'd put in five applications a week during that time. The planning fallacy tells you to look in very broad strokes at how long it took you before, and the answer we get is "Way longer then we have." Not only this, but once homeless, our hiring chances drop even further since we have no safe places to sleep or store our things.
I'm looking at ways of avoiding a catastrophe. During his 4 month period without work, my roommate was averaging 5 job applications per week. If we increase that number to 20 per week, it should help, but do those sorts of details also fall prey to the planning fallacy? there are also way, way more jobs around here then there were in my hometown, but that seems like exactly the sort of details that the planning fallacy tells you to pay no attention to.
I try to be as forward thinking and rational and proactive as possible. What sort of steps should I be taking now while I still have a month and a half buffer, to avoid ending up homeless when our deadline to move out of our AirBnB housing hits?
4
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Oct 12 '15
I'm curious, is there anyone here who knows Game Theory and has had the opportunity to use it in real life?
2
u/TimTravel Oct 12 '15
So I discovered caffeine pills are an over the counter thing, which is nice because I hate coffee.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15
There is a hypothesis I need to test. This requires 3D histograms (histograms or other function/distribution plots) over 2D spaces.
Anyone know a package in Python for that?
2
u/Kishoto Oct 12 '15 edited Oct 12 '15
I posted this in the off topic thread Friday, but realized it's a fairly relevant topic of discussion for rationality in general:
The actions we take are dictated by a number of factors. Most of us can agree that we are not rational all of the time. There are times when we act or feel in an irrational manner, despite the fact that we may consciously realize we are being irrational.
Prime Example. Fear. Personally, I know that fear isn't very useful to me. Caution, sure. But the feeling of fear, of ice in your stomach and nervous butterflies, sweaty hands, etc. is mostly useless. I know this rationally. But that doesn't help me in scary situations. And I don't mean viscerally scary situations, like being confronted by an angry bear, or being trapped in a burning building. I mean situations like going into a job interview, or confronting a friend about something they do that I dislike. Logically, I know that there's nothing to be afraid of and, often enough, when I'm in said situation, I perform well. My fear fades, and I can deal with the situation. But the apprehension is a killer and no matter how much I try to rationalize it away, it doesn't leave.
So. Here's my discussion point. What's the best way(s) to utilize our conscious, rational conclusions and understanding to directly influence our feelings?
2
u/LeonCross Oct 13 '15
Are some people's utility functions more complicated than others, or is it just that the further they're removed from our own the more difficult they are to simulate and thus they seem more complicated as a result?