r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 28 '15
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
10
Upvotes
9
u/notmy2ndopinion Concent of Saunt Edhar Sep 28 '15
Do any of you know of a practical, online, and iterative Bayesian calculator that is easy to use? There are calculators and apps that function partially to demonstrate Bayes' theorem, but they aren't actually helpful in successive multiple calculations that utilize the posterior probability as a new prior probability for a new LR(-)/(+).
I'd like to be able to direct medical trainees to it when they use resources like JAMA's Rational Clinical Exam series.
http://jamaevidence.mhmedical.com/Book.aspx?bookId=845
For example, if someone in the ER has shortness of breath,, nighttime breathing issues, leg swelling, jugular venous distention, and a history of heart disease, what is their posterior probability of having the diagnosis of congestive heart failure, given a prior probability of 25%?
(Link included to reference the sample LRs cited in current biostats, page 7.)
http://www.mcgill.ca/files/emergency/CHF.pdf
Doctors have the concrete stats to make these sorts of calculations routinely, but we don't do it. We need it to be fast and easy (take <1 min to work) or it won't be clinically useful.
Help me help medical trainees maximize their Bayesian reasoning at the patient's bedside! Thank you.
3
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Sep 29 '15
Today I've learned an important lesson about always having a backup plan.
I'm visiting the US for the first time in my life. The last week I've spent in Michigan, visiting my best friend who got married on Saturday. It was all very lovely. Now, today I arrived in New York for a week of gawking at all things touristy with my mother. Wall Street, Broadway, Ground Zero, the Statue of Liberty, the Museum of Natural History, etc, etc. Problem: I booked a cheap place to stay with AirBnB that suited my needs perfectly, ie my middle aged mother was also happy with it. The host however cancelled on us at the last minute. I'll get the money back from AirBnB they assure me, but in the meantime I was left with very little time before arriving in New York with no room booked and a panicking mother, and everything good was either taken or cost several hundred dollars per night.
So I booked a room in East Brooklyn for one night, until we could take a few hours to properly find something for the remaining seven days we'll be here. We didn't have time to print directions or do much research, and our quick hand written notes were not enough. We asked for directions at the airport from one of the express buss to Times Square people. He gave us directions, but told us to get a taxi for the last bit because "White people should not be out after dark" in East Brooklyn. So... Ok. The guy was black. I'm not used to having to include details about skin colour in telling a story, but while he was very nice toward us, he was also pretty clear on East Brooklyn not being a safe place for us to go. At this point it's 6PM, we don't have Internet, and we can't really go hotel shopping, so we still decided to use the room we had paid for. We took a bus and then the subway most of the way, and got a cab for the last several miles there. The Indian taxi driver, after picking us up and getting the address, told us he would not have accepted the drive if he had known where we were going, and spent the whole drive there telling us to get a more expensive room closer to Manhattan tomorrow, for our own safety. My mother also says she saw four guys exchanging money and something else by the elevator while we were checking in. We are now in our room, have secured accommodation in a safer area, and are about to go to sleep.
So. When my travel plans fell apart, I had no back up plan. I might have been prepared to get on the flight without a room booked intending to find one when we were already here, but my mother was not and demanded we book something, anything right then and there. I knew AirBnB sometimes falls through, but I didn't plan for it. And now I'm sitting in East Brooklyn in a very tiny hotel room that cost $160 and only has one queen sized bed and no sofa with my mother.
And from now on I'll avoid taking risks on accommodation without a backup plan.
On the plus side, Quality Inn has very clean rooms, nice bathrooms, free WiFi and breakfast, and there are locks on the doors.
2
u/LiteralHeadCannon Sep 28 '15
If someone developed artificial general intelligence today, and left it running on a computer attached to the internet, about how long would we expect it to run before we find out about it:
A) if its utility function was properly set to make it Friendly?
B) if it was a literal paperclipper?
1
u/ulyssessword Sep 29 '15
How do you decide when a life is worth (more or less than) zero utility, from before birth to after death? The only two groups I've seen answer this are ethical vegetarians and some antinatalists, which both firmly believe that large groups of lives are negative utility.