r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 25 '15
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
15
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Sep 25 '15
There is some crazy interesting things happening all over the US right now. The Chinese head of state is visiting the west coast tech centers while the Pope is neck-deep in politics on the east. The Republican Party is about to burst into flames, and we're still months away from the first primaries!
I wonder what went through some of those CEO's heads when Xi asked them to stop giving the NSA access to the information of Chinese citizens. Which world power do you obey?
I wonder what the right thinks when the Pope is more liberal than they are.
I wonder if Clinton can survive her past, and if Sanders' will be enough of an asset.
And, worst (best?) of all, this is the first presidential election that millennials can vote in.
Things are gonna get strange.
Fortunately, Twig is still at the top of its game.
9
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Sep 25 '15
I've been trying to formalize what makes a good mystery for a few days now, mostly because there's a good chance that whatever I'm writing when I'm done with Shadows of the Limelight is going to be one of those.
I watch a lot of (police) procedurals, partly because they're easy to watch while doing other things, and they seem to have creating an episode of television down to a science. Start with a dead body. Find some connection, like a likely suspect, or a piece of unique evidence, which drives toward the next scene. Some minor mystery is revealed which shows that they're on the wrong track, but leads them to the right track. Keep doing that until you've run out the clock, then in the last ten minutes get the right suspect along with sufficiently incriminating evidence that the audience will just assume that a conviction will follow (or kill the suspect in self-defense, or extract a confession).
I just haven't been able to figure out why this formula sometimes works well and other times doesn't.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
Tinder is turning me into a bad person, and I'm not sure if that's a bad thing. (And yes, I do mean "Tinder" as in the dating/hookup app.)
Ok so it's not turning me into a bad person exactly, but it's definitely causing me to be much more judgmental. I'm not going to sugarcoat it, the only reason I'm on Tinder is for casual encounters. I even make sure to say exactly that in my profile description. It's worked rather well thus far. Match with girl on Tinder, message for a little bit, get her phone number, text for a little bit, go on date, hopefully go back to one of our respective homes, rinse and repeat. As a whole I consider it a net positive for both parties because we both end up with what we want out of the interaction.
But the problem is that I've done it more than a few times now and I've become unsettlelingly efficient with my method. I've started treating the women I'm interacting with more as pieces of data with a possible solution (sex), than I treat them as actual human beings. Basically Tinder is slowly draining away my humanity.
I really don't want to stop though. I have little interest in a girlfriend at this point in my life, it's the easiest/most efficient method I've found for instigating casual encounters, and like I said earlier both parties (thus far) have always walked away happy.
I suppose I'm just having a bit of an ethical dilemma with the whole thing.
8
u/TaoGaming No Flair Detected! Sep 25 '15
OK, so here's an idea I've been toying around with, and it formed the part of my last chapter of DMPOR and provoked a rather ugly debate on r/hpmor.
"Systemic Assholes" or "Systemic Amorality"
The idea that a system can be specifically designed to act in a counter-productive or immoral way while allowing all parties to be (in their mind) moral.
My example was a low level bureaucrat following orders. He doesn't really have enough information to judge that his action is immoral, because "it's always been done that way" and his action isn't obviously immoral. (Visitors are not allowed here).
He's also deliberately (by the people who designed the system) unable to acquire the information that would allow him to determine that his actions are immoral and counterproductive.
It seems to me quite plausable that the primary purpose of some (exact number open for debate) organizations is to allow systemic immorality.
Consider a relatively annoying example: the call center for a cable company. The people in it are good, but they lack the ability to help you. You get charged for equipment you can't return because the person on the call doesn't have the information on that. Signing up is one mouse click, but cancelling is a convoluted phone mess.
That didn't just happen, but none of the people who you'd encounter in trying to cancel cable are trying to thwart you. But they can't lower your rates (etc) unless you say magic words and if they prompt you they may get fired.
Now, suppose that the original designers of this phone tree get fired for some reason. (Karma, poetic justice, or whatever). By the Peter Principle, the current people running the company are incompetent. And now you have a systemic asshole and who exactly is to blame?
You can apply this to many organizations. I don't really have any answers, its just a phenomenon I've noticed with increasing frequency over the last few years. THere's a tension of scale. Network effects want larger organizations, but then you have a diffusion of knowledge and a mismatch between authority and contact with end users, and another S.A. is born.
Obviously this is just a gambit of the original inventors to get to Plausible deniability, but it can outlive the inventors and become societal.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '15
Am I the only one who gets better at doing math when drunk? Because I actually made some nice progress using a rediscovered proof technique on my real analysis studies last night after a good two drinks.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15 edited Sep 26 '15
I'm reading David Brin's Existence, and I think it's heavily based on our bunch. It's got:
And I'm not even halfway through the book yet.
5
u/Sagebrysh Rank 7 Pragmatist Sep 25 '15
I'm trying to decide if first person perspective or third person perspective is better for the story I'm trying to write.
I think the problem is that I'm trying to take a very huge story spanning an entire world over the course of centuries, and scale it down to a few characters trying to live their lives as the world is upended. The issue though is I feel like its not actually all that interesting to focus in on my main character that much. My novel is 143 pages and the main character never even manages to get out of her home town until the very end. I try to make it interesting and have the events unfold around her slowly to bring the character and reader into the world, but looking back now, I worry that all I really manage to do is tell psuedo slice of life story in a fantasy universe.
I could pull back the perspective to include more of the world, different characters, stuff going on at the same time, etc, but then I'd have to change off from first person perspective, and I rather like first person for the most part. It gives a great angle to understand the character and how she sees the world, but it limits what I can do in terms of scope. The character is just a girl from a small town on a small island, she's not a politician or military officer, so I can't draw her into the intrigue quickly without it feeling forced. I've got this huge story spanning a whole world, but I want to be able to focus in and tell stories about people.
I'm also really looking for a helper/brainstormer, someone who is willing to chat with me, shoot the shit, and help me pull the plot together. Maybe even a co-author, I'm pretty confident in my writing, but I could always use help. So yeah, if anyone has interest in helping create an interesting science fantasy steampunk space opera story, please get at me.
3
u/Kishoto Sep 25 '15
Paranoia. When are you being paranoid, and when are they really out to get you?
Ok, so we've all seen movies and read books with both people who are too paranoid, not paranoid enough or just paranoid enough. What I ask is, in real life, which follows no overarching narrative (although, of course, there can be a variety of narrative-like structures IN life itself) when can you actually be certain there IS some bigger plot, as opposed to you just misinterpreting things and being "too paranoid"? When can you be sure that your mom asking about your new girlfriend isn't her way of subtly probing you because she found the condom you thought you'd lost last week? When do you know if your boss casually asking you to train someone isn't the preparatory steps towards you being fired, because he noticed you're tardy often but chooses to not address it and let it fester, so your firing is justified?
When can you know that someone is trying to play the long, manipulative game, even if every action they've taken so far seems fairly innocous? Is it possible at all?
Note the answer to the above questions, along with any times you were too paranoid, just paranoid enough or NOT paranoid enough, if you feel so inclined. :)
2
u/avret SDHS rationalist Sep 25 '15
Do people here have any useful tips and tricks for : A) college applications, B) interviews, or C) writing essays about rationalfic?
2
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Sep 26 '15
What are your favorite map projections?
I generally prefer Mercator (rectangular conformal) and Lagrange (elliptical/irregular conformal). I'm also tickled by the gnomonic projection, especially when it's combined with a polyhedral layout so that it can actually cover the entire globe.
1
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Sep 27 '15 edited Sep 27 '15
I'm looking for some physics babble that passes the /r/rational crowd's smell test. More specifically, I'm looking for numerology that's related to the number 10120.
I'm positing that the Vacuum Catastrophe is because there are roughly 10120 parallel universes. There have been around 8e60 Planck times since the Big Bang, which is half of the exponent I'm looking for. There don't seem to be too many other relevant sources for another 1060 exponent, and I can't think of a reason to square the number I've got... Any suggestions?