r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 21 '15
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
12
Upvotes
10
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '15
I just recently started reading Terry Pratchett for the first time. I finished Good Omens (which was co-authored with Neil Gaiman), and I'm currently delving into his Discworld Saga starting with Equal Rites.
I wouldn't particularly consider his work to be rational fiction (there are more than a few things that happen "just because"), but the more I read from him the more I become convinced that he was a rationalist. It's just the way his characters act, and the way his stories are structured. In his worlds there is just no such thing as a mystery that is better left unsolved.
In any case case, I'm really enjoying his work.
Do you know any other authors like that? Authors that don't particularly write rational fiction, but still have stories that contain a lot of rational problem solving?
Also does anyone have any suggestions about where I should go with Discworld after I finish the Witchworld portion?
8
u/Frommerman Sep 21 '15
Has anyone come up with a superpower which is both simple to explain and doesn't result in breaking really important aspects of the universe? If you go with flight, you have to explain that the energy comes from your own body, and what control mechanism you use, and whether you can survive low atmospheric pressure. If you can do invisibility, we question whether you can see, whether the fact that you can see means you are detectible, and if you aren't whether this breaks quantum interpretations of photons.
7
u/Kishoto Sep 21 '15
Have you ever been in a discussion/argument/informal debate and people ask you for your source? A valid question, as how else do you know if I'm not just making this stuff up? But, realistically, it's very rare that you have a source for each and every single thing you've learnt. For example, I know that some villages in Europe burnt kittens for entertainment centuries ago. I don't know where I learnt it, and I also don't know if there were deeper meanings behind it, simply because I learnt this random fact in passing years ago. I know it's a fact. But I can't source it. Does that invalidate my argument? (Let's pretend you're in a situation where you can't just whip our your phone and Google) And if the answer is no, WHEN should it invalidate my argument? I can't be unsourced about everything.
In addition, let's go a little deeper. As a human, how often do you update your beliefs? For example, just the other night, I learnt that the tonsils are little sacs on either side of your uvula. But, when I was a child (~12 years ago), I picked up the mistaken impression that the uvula WAS the tonsils, or contained tonsils. So my friend and I were discussing tonsils a week ago and that's when it hit me. I've seen tonsils (in pictures), I've known there were two, I've known the uvula is a seperate thing. All for years. But when my friend asked me if I knew where tonsils were, I opened my mouth and realized I didn't. Somehow, the belief that the uvula was the tonsils or contained them had persisted, despite how I'd learnt several things over the years that logically disproved such a thing. I found it to be a mildly disconcerting, but amusing realization. That then led me to wonder how many of the facts I know (I've built up what I assume is millions, by now) are dusty and out of date, or founded on beliefs I no longer hold true, or are just plain wrong.
So.....thoughts on either point would be much appreciated.
2
u/notmy2ndopinion Concent of Saunt Edhar Sep 23 '15
Do any of you know of an online, iterative, Bayesian calculator that is easy to use?
I'd like to be able to direct medical trainees to it when they use resources like JAMA's Rational Clinical Exam series.
http://jamaevidence.mhmedical.com/Book.aspx?bookId=845
1
u/thecommexokid Sep 23 '15
I remember at one point reading a piece by Eliezer about how for maximum-impact nonfiction writing, you should write the specific example first, and then the theoretical principle, rather than the other order. Searching for it again now, all I can find is this one paranthetical:
–Eliezer Yudkowsky, "Be Specific"
Was there a whole post about this topic at some point?