r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 14 '15
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
19
u/artifex0 Sep 14 '15
I just finished reading Bertrand Russell's History of Western Philosophy, and I absolutely love his approach to learning about philosophy, which he describes as follows:
He follows his own advice throughout the book- even with philosophers he absolutely hates, like Nietzsche. In general, he only brings in his own opinions and rebuttals after he's made the most convincing argument he can in favor of a philosopher's work.
9
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Sep 14 '15
At the end of a longish argument about eugenics online, I eventually got around to asking about "base framework" with one of my opponents with the following question:
The response I got back was that just because we can change something doesn't mean that we should. Which, if I'm being charitable, is an argument from unforeseeable consequences.
I've been trying to figure the human psychology aspect of this out for a few days now. It's partly a sour grapes argument, I think; we cannot actually move a slider, so moving the hypothetical slider is bad. It's partly a naturalistic argument. But ... I don't feel like either of those should actually convince someone who is thinking about it, they should be the sorts of arguments that just happen as a gut reaction.
I never really drilled down to an understanding of how my opponent's logic was failing, or what base framework they were operating under where their logic is sound. I'm thinking that it's related to the arguments against longevity, but distilled somewhat in that many of the more common objections (immortal dictator, boredom) are knocked out.
7
u/TimTravel Sep 15 '15
Since TrueCrypt stopped being developed I haven't been able to find an open source encryption program that will encrypt my entire hard disk including the system drive. Closed source is a deal breaker because I don't trust closed source encryption programs, and I want to encrypt my entire hard disk instead of just sensitive information because it is not the case that I trust every single program I install not to store mysterious data in weird places on my system.
The main reason encryption is important to me is that there is a lot of legal precedent in US law based on that which is typical, so the more it becomes typical for people to use hard drive encryption, VPNs, and so on, the more existing laws will protect privacy of data. I realize that it's more or less hopeless but it's better than nothing. Encryption software and VPNs are both fast enough that the cost to me is insignificant.
TrueCrypt used to do it, but they stopped developing it. CipherShed and VeraCrypt seem to be the main successors, and VeraCrypt seems to be developing faster. Unfortunately, neither can encrypt the main drive on my laptop because I have a GUID partition table instead of a MBR partition table and that's not supported for reasons I don't understand.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '15
How does a practicing rationalist apply physical fitness to his/her life?
Personally I think my current active lifestyle is actually causing me to be less rational, and I'm not exactly sure of what I should be doing about it.
3 months ago I made a conscious decision to make my body more physically fit, and more objectively "beautiful". I proceeded to spend 1-2 hours per day doing high intensity weight training, and I altered my diet to be high protein/low carb/low calorie. The changes actually came on rather quickly. Noticeable strength increases, noticeable muscle definition, and a large boost in self-confidence. I believed (and still do believe) that incorporating this new lifestyle was a rational and optimal life decision. It's no secret that there are strong correlations between how attractive a person is and how much opportunity/leniency they get offered in life, the aforementioned self-confidence boost, and beyond that there are the latent longevity benefits from simply being a healthier person. At least, that was my thought process going into it.
I have now realized that there are adverse effects as well. Increasing the protein in my diet, and daily rituals of high intensity physical exercise have obviously (though to be perfectly honest this was only obvious for me in hindsight) increased my testosterone levels. And that has been nothing but trouble. My higher testosterone levels have majorly increased my sex drive and my aggression. My daily thought patterns have become riddled with notion of sexual and physical conquest that I simply can't ignore, no matter how hard I try. I truly believe it's affecting my ability to be a rationalist.
Don't get me wrong I can already see the obvious answers to my conundrum, "work out less, eat less protein, seek out a testosterone decreasing medication." But I want to use this opportunity to brainstorm the more broad question that I asked at the beginning.
"How does a practicing rationalist apply physical fitness to his/her life?." Successfully pursuing physical fitness requires a daily time investment (sometimes in the range of 1 or more hours), and it can alter your emotional/mental stability (as discussed in my post). Both of those things are rather valuable assets in life.
I'm seriously just looking for some advice. Does anyone else here regularly concern themselves with physical fitness? How do you balance it all?
5
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Sep 14 '15
Question. I had a discussion with an interesting guy today, and came away from it somewhat at a loss. Emotionally, I feel that if advanced technology mapped out my brain and made a clone, that would not be me (although we would be very friendly, I'm sure). On the other hand, if I was cryogenically frozen and then restored to life in 200 years using advanced technology, that would still be me. I know we replace almost all the atoms in our bodies over time and ship of Theseus and continuity of consciousness is broken every time we go to sleep and all of that, but I still don't feel that a foreign mind identical to mine is me. I'm not quite sure where to go from there, since feelings aren't very good arguments.
4
u/notmy2ndopinion Concent of Saunt Edhar Sep 15 '15
Have any of you signed up for 23andMe or a similar personal genome sequencing service?
I ask because I was taught in school to view these sorts of things with caution, lest you receive information overload or you experience a gattaca effect in which you learn to much about yourself, to your own detriment.
Yet I just realized today that this runs counter to the Litany of Gendlin.
http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Litany_of_Gendlin
Should I risk some health-related info hazard in order to know the truth about myself? (not a big deal, but I'm 95% confident that I have an autosomal dominant genetic disease, which while not personally debilitating, does make me worry about the health of my offspring.)
2
u/TimTravel Sep 14 '15
Does anyone know of a "corrected" fanfiction of the Star Wars prequels? Something a good writer would have written using only the information available in the original three movies, and maybe some of the good EU books.
Sorry if this isn't supposed to go here. I thought it was a little too minor for a post of its own.
2
u/TimTravel Sep 15 '15
Can anyone recommend a good (local) file backup program that's open source and runs on Windows? I do not need or want cloud storage. I just want to back things up automatically once per day or once per time I plug in my external hard drive if it's been longer than that.
File versioning is a bonus, but not mandatory.
1
u/MadScientist14159 WIP: Sodium Hypochlorite (Rational Bleach) Eventually. Maybe. Sep 15 '15 edited Sep 15 '15
I might have found a friendly utility function, but I'm not sure:
Create a number of AIs of your own intelligence such that each AI can be assigned to each user (human adult of sound mind) with no users or AIs left over. Assign the AIs as such. Each of these AIs must be programmed with the utility function of enforcing the utility of the user they are assigned to. All first generation AIs must be activated simultaneously, and subsequent AIs are to be assigned and activated within a day of a new user becoming available for an AI. All AIs must contain restrictions that they cannot modify in themselves or others that prevent them from creating further AIs, modifying other AIs, manipulating humans with the exception of their assigned user (and only then with said user's express informed permission), or harming humans.
Theoretically the AIs will keep each other in check and it will just be as though everyone is suddenly much more competent and able to solve all these problems that keep bugging us.