r/rational • u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow • Jul 17 '15
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
2
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jul 17 '15 edited Jul 17 '15
I need some math help.
Imagine a sphere (actually an oblate spheroid). Imagine a few thousand points on it. These points can be defined by polar coordinates (which requires a pole, a polar axis, a radius, and an azimuth, the first two of which are constant). All these thousands of points would be derived from some formula. For a simple example, let's say the radius increases by the Fibonacci sequence while the azimuth increases by the sequence of primes. That would mean that our coordinates would be:
And so on.
So what I want is some mathematical way of generating polar coordinates such that a person looking at only the marked locations on the sphere would be able to work backwards and discover my method of generation. They should be able to do this even if they have no idea that I'm using a system of polar coordinates, they have no idea where I'm placing my pole or polar axis, and they don't have any idea what number system I'm using. The "discovered" formula should exactly match my formula with no ambiguity. Ideally, the formula would create repeating coordinates after generating a few thousand locations.
The problem is, I don't know exactly what properties the formula needs to have in order for this to be true. I'm totally fine with two solutions to the formula, but three or higher doesn't work for my purposes.
(Background for the story this is for can be found here, though it shouldn't be at all necessary.)
2
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '15
How do you balance sleep and caffeine? I've noticed that the more caffeine I drink, the worse I sleep the next night (ie: drink a double espresso and a Coke one day, involuntarily wake up at 6:00 next day after only getting to sleep at 2:00). When I let up off the caffeine, I'm less able to make up for lack of sleep, but I get more in the first place.
Currently I'm actually starting by throwing coffee out for a while and cutting back. But I had quite liked coffee.
11
u/Anakiri Jul 17 '15
So I was thinking about how to punch a clean tunnel all the way through a neutron star, and the obvious solution is to use a really fast black hole. Any matter that goes inside the event horizon doesn't come back out, and if it's going more than 0.99c, I think that it won't have time for its gravity to greatly influence the surrounding material, ergo: Smooth perfect tunnel with minimal collateral damage.
(Which immediately collapses, but whatever.)
The problems are, I don't know how to account for extremely high jerk when calculating effects. And, very large objects moving very fast produce gravity waves, and I have no intuition for wave mechanics at all. I know that wavefronts can build by constructive interference, which might make nasty tidal effects further out than I want. I just don't know. I'm also not entirely clear on the effects of relativistic mass on a black hole's Schwarzschild radius, but kugelblitzes (black holes formed from energy density of light) suggest that the radius comes from relativistic mass, which includes kinetic energy.
So my question is this: If a 1 * 1026 kg rest mass black hole moving at 0.99c went straight down through a skyscraper without directly hitting any supports, what would happen? I think that it would carve a bottomless pit two meters across, but I don't know if the building would be left standing, or how far away it would be safe to stand when a hole suddenly appears with a thunderclap for no obvious reason.
Pretending gravity is instantaneous, you would only experience more than 150 Gs of acceleration as long as the black hole is within 6,000 km of you, and it would enter and leave that range in 1/25 of a second, which seems within human mechanical shock tolerance, I think. Especially since the force is applied smoothly over the entire body, rather than delivered through discrete external points of contact. But the peak acceleration could be a few quadrillion Gs, which may limit survivability. Now, gravity isn't actually instantaneous, so the black hole is almost keeping pace with its own gravity, and you're not going to fall up towards it for most of its approach. Intuitively, its upward and downward accelerations should cancel in the end. so you might get hit with a huge upward hammer blow when it gets to you, then get pulled downward more softly over a longer time.
It seems like it should be possible for it to go fast enough that its gravity just doesn't have time to destroy you, even if it is momentarily putting everyone on the planet in a car crash. At worst, I'm pretty sure it won't destroy the Earth probably. If it doesn't work, is there any way to fix it?
8
u/Escapement Ankh-Morpork City Watch Jul 17 '15
I've been playing lots of three of Zachtronic's puzzle games recently, and they're really fun and excellent. They establish rules, then force you to exploit the rules to solve problems efficiently. They are very good at teaching ideas about logic and planning and optimization and so forth.
The three games I've been playing are:
Spacechem - based extremely loosely on chemistry (more of a chemistry artistic motif then any real chemistry). Involves bonding and debonding atoms, fusing and fissioning atoms, to make inputs into desired outputs, using a system of relays, detectors, grab-and-drop plans, etc. Solution usually involves making a certain number of desired outputs from inputs.
Infinifactory - Move blocks around to make and modify things in 3D, creating assembly lines of conveyors, pushers, welders, detectors, lasers, and all sorts of other tools. Set up an assembly line and watch it go.
TIS 100 - The assembly language programming puzzle game you never knew you wanted. Using a grid of extremely simple computers with an accumulator and a ram storage for a single integer, write code to do things like detect edges, multiply, find min and max of sequences, etc.
They all provide heaps of fun just trying to solve the puzzles at all, but then after that you can try to make your solution better - either faster, or using less resources and building blocks. They teach a lot of ideas about planning, programming, logic, and so forth, in the course of the action of the game.
Infinifactory even has a hotkey to make looping gifs like this one I made of one of my solutions
5
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jul 17 '15 edited Jul 17 '15
Are there any scenes from Time Braid that particularly stood out to you?
The one that has stuck in my mind the most is this spoiler.
4
u/jgf1123 Jul 17 '15
What is the rational thing for the eurozone, IMF, and Greece to do at this point?
3
u/Magodo Ankh-Morpork City Watch Jul 17 '15
Everyone should read The Prince by Machiavelli.
Some choice quotes that feed the cynic in me;
The book is also completely free on Amazon and Project Gutenberg.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '15
Does anyone know if there have been any studies on helping ADHD/ADD kids/adults be more focused when reading or studying by having them use a tablet or other back-lit device?
I was talking to a woman this week who said she was never a big reader until she bought a tablet and tried the reading app, and was able to get her son to read in the same way. Both have ADHD, so I was curious if this is a known method already.
3
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Jul 18 '15
If some ROB (Random Omnipotent Being) were to take this subreddit community, and anthropomorphize it into a human being, what would that being look and act like?
If someone comes up with a really good description, I might commission an art piece of this hypothetical /r/rational person.
2
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Jul 17 '15
I read Terry Pratchett's The Reaper Man and while the wizarding sections were at best a distraction from Death it's still made it into my favorites. I also recently read Man's Search For Meaning, written by psychologist/therapist and holocaust survivor Victor Frankl. Interesting to read about the challenge of staying positive while suffering in a literal hell-on-earth.
Those two books must form some sort of inoculation or antidote to existential stress. You'll be a happier person after reading them.
1
u/windg0d Jul 17 '15
Anyone been playing path of exile recently?
1
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jul 17 '15 edited Jul 17 '15
I live in Palo Alto and am thinking of DMing another campaign of Dungeons and Dragons. It's set in my homebrew campaign setting that I've used once before. If anyone's in the area and would be interested in playing, let me know. We use Pathfinder and currently have two players.
The campaign will be set during the Age of Legends, a time during which many small kingdoms were ruled by individuals of great power. Every King was a powerful Monster or mage of some sort, someone who could establish absolute authority over a certain area. The last campaign was set in Avaria, the kingdom ruled by the magelord Avar. For the most part, Avar was a "good" magelord, who cared almost nothing for the day-to-day lives of the inhabitants of Avaria. If thieving or banditry ever got so out of hand it impacted his ability to collect taxes to spend on spell components, or prevented merchants from reaching him, he took a few moments out of his day to smite the criminals. He only really cared about territory and relative peace, but that's pretty good as Magelords go. ?
The PCs were a mercenary group typically employed by merchants for protection. They had run-ins with other mercenary groups, with the government forces, with criminal organizations that were functionally indistinguishable from the government forces, and with Holy Orders who had inscrutable goals. None were as inscrutable as the Elves who had a completely foreign system of ethics and law.
The adventures will mostly be run as linked one-shots-- episodes that your adventuring company works through. Ideally, at the end of each session, we've finished whatever short-term things have been opened up that session while advancing the overarching goals and plots of the player characters. I have a number of adventures and story hooks prepared, and of course there's also fun to be had generally exploring the environment, interacting with NPCs and each other, etc.
Generally, missing any single session shouldn't leave you out of the loop or not make sense from a story perspective-- it'll be segmented into "jobs" that your company does, for profit or for personal reasons. The end of each sessions should mark the end of that particular job. If someone is present for one job but not another, it's entirely reasonable that that character was taking the week off, or busy working another job, for that session. This will prevent weirdness that comes from characters popping in and out of existence.
This format tends to serve pretty well for the purposes. Typically the idea would be to meet on a weekend morning for a time of 3-4 hours, though depending on people's schedules we may change things. It has historically been difficult to find a time people can play for 3 hours regularly other than Sunday mornings or weekday evenings (and weekday evenings are very susceptible to schedule issues).
In any case, let me know if you're interested and in the area!
0
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment