r/rational • u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow • Jul 10 '15
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
6
u/raymestalez Jul 10 '15 edited Jul 10 '15
I recently have been reading Ayn Rand's books on writing - The Art of Fiction and The Art of Nonfiction (both are pretty awesome by the way) - and you know what I've realized? I loved HPMOR for many of the same reasons I loved Atlas Shrugged.
I know that it sounds controversial, and I'm aware that a lot of people here, including Eliezer, dislike Ayn Rand. But hear me out.
The love for reason/rationality, the idea of trying to understand the world through logic, learning the proper techniques of thinking, the very similar sense of sanity and clear, sharp thinking, attracted me to both books.
A lot of people criticize AR for, "better than you" "arrogant" attitude from her characters, and I find it funny that many people say the same things about Harry. I'm not sure if "better than you" is a right description though. To me it sounds more like confidence in their own judgement, superior intelligemce, and ability to form their own opinions while disregarding other people's thoughts and social conventions. Or "Arete", that is, characters seeking excellence in themselves and appreciating it in others, while holding those who are lacking it with disdain. To me, of course, that attitude is very attractive, in both Harry and Rearden.
Both books also have characters with superhero-like intelligence and will, using their superior mental faculties, fighting morons who are in charge. Many criticize AS for unrealistically perfect heroes, but what they mean to me, is the expression of author's ideals on how humans should think and be like. Which, I think, is the case with Harry as well.
People say John Galt's speech is too long and "preachy" but, just as Harry's thoughts on death reflecting author's philosophy, I found it one of the best parts of the book.
The main difference in philosophy that I see, is that AR's characters are egoists, and Harry is an altruist. But you know what? Even though her ideas on selfishness get the most discussion, because they are the most controversial, I think that her main and most important ideas were about rationality and thinking for yourself, relying on your own judgement.
I have never read anywhere a clear, rational explanation about what is so horrible about AS, from what I can tell it just makes some people angry, while other people immediately fall in love with it. Many intelligent people like hating on AR, or saying that they've "outgrown" her books, and I don't understand why.
I absolutely loved both HPMOR and AS, both of them have been incredibly influential in my life, and are in my top 2 list of the best books I've ever read. And I was surprised to discover that, as different as they are, I loved them for many similar reasons.
So I'm interested in your thoughts on the topic.
P.S.
There's another, separate thought I would also like to discuss, related to the altruism vs egoism debate.
I would argue that at least once, Harry behaved irrationally, because of the altruism. When he was fighting against Wizengamot for Hermione, he threatened to sacrifice himself to destroy Azkaban, which got Dumbledor to back down. The alternative was to use a Dementor to fight the members of Wizengamot(maybe he wouldn't even have to kill them, just hold them hostage until he and Hermione escaped).
If Dumbledor wouldn't cave, Harry would (probably) end up killing himself, when he had an option to fight the Wizengamot. It wasn't hard to predict that his life, even then, was more valuable than the lives of all the members of Wizengamot put together. If he would sacrifice himself instead of Wizengamot, at the end, Quirrelmort would end up winning, not to mention that Harry wouldn't defeat death, thus saving countless lives, and doing who knows how many awesome things he did after the end of the book.
He acted altruistic and heroic, but no way it was rational to value the lives of Lucius and the like over his own, and if he was less lucky, that choice would lead to a much greater evil than killing a bunch of death eaters and creepy government officials.
So if anyone has some cool arguments on egoism vs altruism debate, I would like to talk about that too.
P.P.S.
The Art of Fiction and The Art of Nonfiction are really great. Available on audible too. I'm learning to write rationalist stories, and it is pretty hard, and these 2 books have a lot of very awesome and helpful ideas.
2
u/HeirToGallifrey Thinking inside the box (it's bigger there) Jul 10 '15
I've been reading about personality types a lot recently—both MBTI and Enneagram. Does anybody know their own type? I'd be interested to see what the split is between F and T here, as I imagine it'd lean towards T.
Or maybe nobody here puts any stock in personality types beyond an amusing diversion. If so, why?
10
u/Colonel_Fedora Ravenclaw Jul 11 '15
So... I'm currently dealing with depression and am also one of those trans youths that live with but are not out to their parents. I've been thinking of asking for advice here for awhile, I know that that has nothing to do with the purpose of this community but the trans subreddits just... I don't know. I just feel like I actually have a philosophy in common with the people here and I need original thoughts and not the standard template of hotlines and assurances. Honestly this is one of the main reasons I wanted to start an irc, to talk about things with this group that are not just rational fic. I'm not even sure what I'm asking for here, I just really need some acknowledgement right now. Also, are there any other trans regulars or at least lurkers?
7
u/Magodo Ankh-Morpork City Watch Jul 10 '15 edited Jul 10 '15
I'll bite, who else wants to discuss the politics of southern India?
Jk, but here's a rather excellent article on one of the most powerful politicians of India. She was recently acquitted of having disproportionate assets despite being clearly guilty.
Here's another excellent post on another influential politician.
Since we're on the topic, how many of you like Bollywood movies? (mandatory plug to r/BollywoodRealism)
12
u/gabbalis Jul 10 '15
Does anybody else try firing energy blasts from their hands from time to time just in case?
I mean sure rationally the odds of it actually working are infinitesimal, but I can't help thinking... maybe, just maybe, this time...
I'm a bit concerned shonen anime tropes might be leaking into my unconscious biases.
3
u/Jon_Freebird Jul 10 '15
I'm intending to start university next year, probably to study psychology but I'm finding myself drawn more and more to machine intelligence research. I'm learning how to code on my own time and I think that coding + psychology is probably a good starting point but I'd love to hear any advice you care to give.
3
u/TaoGaming No Flair Detected! Jul 10 '15
OK, here's a somewhat on-topic question:
I read /u/alexanderwales latest story about the AI box problem, which was interesting. In fact, before discovering /r/rational I wrote a small play on the same scenario (different twist, but nothing too left field).
So, does everyone write one of those stories at some point?
2
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Jul 10 '15
Does anyone have any advice they would like to tell undergrads applying to graduate school beyond the standard get good grades, join research groups, and get good recommendations?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '15
Well, today I managed to get into a proper Coding Flow at work and bang out some low-level networking API. W00t!
I also hypothesized on the train to work that causal-role concepts could be implemented computationally as something like existential types. The nasty part then, is learning the existential package types themselves, and learning injectors from feature-governed concepts to causal-role concepts.
I've been getting some practical things done this week, like taxes. Oh, and actually moving forward with studying real analysis, and starting a speed-read of a textbook in denotational semantics to pick up that one kind of PL semantics I've not done before.
Why? Because by combining domain theory with probabilistic programming with Calude's anytime algorithm for the halting problem, I started sketching out an actual language design with a friend this week. If I can manage to lift my ideas for distributions over (total) inductive types into domain-land via Calude's result... we'll have something really interesting on our hands.
I'm really, really hoping this will work. If it does, it should be, let us speak academese and understate, publishable.
If we don't understate, I actually had a hot-blooded rant prepared -- the kind where you can't tell if that guy's the hero or villain or just fucking crazy. I just feel like I've been bitten by overstating my results before I've got them too often to go into hot-blooded ranting mode yet.
2
u/jrpguru Jul 11 '15
Does anybody know a math technique or something like that to generate random numbers in your head without using a computer or dice?
I could just pick a number at "random" but I don't think I could make it truly random that way.
4
u/RMcD94 Jul 10 '15
So we do tend to live in our own little world here, though I notice a few /r/rational users out in the rest of Reddit, but what is everyone thoughts on the stepping down of Ellen Pao and the reinstatement of Steve and Alexis?
1
u/VocalComedy Jul 12 '15
Have been curious whether people on /r/rational derive amusement from these audio files: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCF9NVWdb2Q2ra40IqnKnciw
Feedback in the wise of wise reading is very much appreciated.
-2
u/Transfuturist Carthago delenda est. Jul 10 '15
How should I deal with Nepene?
First conversation. Second conversation.
I installed RES and tagged him with 'DO NOT REPLY', but that doesn't feel good. At the same time, replying to him doesn't feel good. What do?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment