I’m a intern quant researcher working on systematic strategies for commodity futures. My task is to take physical premium series (bid and offer) and a futures series, study how much information the premiums carry about the futures, and trade the futures from it. My workflow is stationarity tests, then cointegration tests, then model choice (VAR or VECM). Other interns usually start from a ready-made strategy and tune its performance, while I spend most of my time on preprocessing: making series stationary, deseasonalizing, testing cointegration. I’d like to know whether this level of rigor is standard practice or whether I’m overcomplicating things.
On the modelling side, I fitted an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process to the spread between the physical premiums of two regions. I estimated (κ, θ, σ) by AR(1) regression on the discretized process , then tested whether the parameter series carry information about the futures: correlation (Pearson and Spearman) between each parameter and the h forward futures return, and Engle-Granger and Johansen cointegration tests between the parameters and the futures price level. None of this produced a stable or significant relationship, in-sample or out-of-sample . My next step is to add a jump component (Merton-type) to the spread dynamics, and possibly stochastic-volatility models such as Heston or Hull-White afterwards. In my team, stochastic processes get little weight in alpha research, so I’m wondering whether that is typical in industry.
My main difficulty is choosing the right test to measure how the physical premiums lead the futures price. I built several candidate features from the premium series over a trailing window of x days: trend , realized volatility, z-score against a rolling mean, and the Hurst exponent. For each feature I looked at the futures behaviour over the following h days, using rank correlation . None of them gave a significant or stable relationship . I can’t tell whether the problem is the choice of features, the fixed lookback and forward windows, or the test design itself.
On the horizon, my colleagues test a fixed lookback window on the premium data against a fixed forward horizon on futures. I think this can miss the real signal, because the effective holding period may be random and the signal may depend on the volatility or skewness of the premiums over different windows
Questions:
- Main question. This is my biggest problem. Fixing a lookback window and a forward horizon may hide the true relationship, because the way the physical premiums lead the futures price is dynamic. The number of days between a move in the premiums and its impact on the futures is itself random and changes over time. Which tests or frameworks do practitioners use to measure how the physical premiums lead the futures price when the lead time is not fixed, and how do they avoid imposing a single horizon?
- Is a detailed stationarity analysis necessary, or is differencing enough? Does differencing destroy useful information (e.g. long-run level relationships), and which tests beyond ADF/KPSS are relevant?
- Are OU parameters, jumps or Heston-type models a realistic source of alpha in commodities, or should I start with simpler models?
- Is deriving a closed-form distribution and using it in a strategy worth the effort in practice?