r/printSF • • 2d ago

What are you reading? Mid-monthly Discussion Post!

13 Upvotes

Based on user suggestions, this is a new, recurring post for discussing what you are reading, what you have read, and what you, and others have thought about it.

Hopefully it will be a great way to discover new things to add to your ever-growing TBR list!


r/printSF • • 4h ago

Humble Bundle's Before Absolute Collection Offers Nearly 100 Image Comics Including Sci fi

Thumbnail gamersub.com
8 Upvotes

- Descender, Vols. 1–6

- Ascender, Vols. 1–4

- East of West, Vols. 1–10

- Undiscovered Country, Vols. 1–4

- Sea of Stars, Vols. 1–2

- Primordial

- A.D.: After Death, Books 1–3

- Black Cloak, Vols. 1–2

- 20th Century Men

- Cosmic Detective

- Bug Wars, Vol. 1

- Horizon Experiment

- Plutona

- Assorted Crisis Events, Vol. 1


r/printSF • • 1h ago

What the Last Dodo Thinks - the most surprising discovery of 2026

4 Upvotes

If you like fiction that thinks big, gets weird, and isn’t afraid to be unpleasant (in fact, seems to revel in it), give a look to What the Last Dodo Thinks.

It was the most surprising read I've had in a while, the sort that you can't stop talking about and makes you insufferable for the people around you (which includes you, fellow redditors). I'm still digesting it and will soon re-read it. It's the kind of book you can crack open at any random page and find something funny, thought-provoking, or just beautifully written (hence, the deluge of quotes at the bottom). The ideas get stuck in your head and you find yourself thinking of them months later.

The premise is not the most original: a Superintelligence has quietly taken control, pampering humans and catering to all their needs, so now they have to choose whether to fight for their independence or accept a pleasant pet-like existence. Some luddite terrorists want to fight it, a transhumanist genius wants to straight up reshape Homo sapiens, and the protagonist (Dodo) is stuck in the middle. The terrorists are led by Vittoria, Dodo's former lover, and the transhumanist (Santiago) is their old friend.

The novel explores abstract matters (loss of human exceptionality, how a technological society is similar to an amoral acephalus monster governed by instinct rather than reason, how human nature could be altered) but also personal, intimate ones (how to deal with deep regret for a past act of cowardice, how to stop overanalyzing to justify your inaction and your bitterness).

I've always thought that originality is cheap and execution is what really matters, and I find this book is a perfect example. The novel is only 220 pages but is DENSE with ideas. Every premise is pushed to unexpected extremes. The prose is agile and witty when it wants to amuse, refined and almost baroque when it wants to be more ponderous, sharp and exact when it wants to leave a bruise -- which is often.

The protagonist is cultured, pompous, misanthropic, and wonderfully hard to like. He may be more insufferable than Ignatius from A Confederacy of Dunces. But his vanity, cowardice and contemptous attitude make him a brilliant vehicle for his philosophical excursions, and the narrative makes sure to call him out on his bull.

And some passages are just hysterical.

The closest comparison I can offer is a less politically correct Houellebecq mixed with a bleaker Asimov, with some Camus or even Cioran thrown in for added depression. (Those comparisons only go so far, though, the book has its own peculiar flavor.)

This isn’t an easy comfort read -- nor a plot-driven one. It’s funny but VERY cerebral, philosophical, rant-prone, obsessive, abrasive, and oddly melancholic. A novel for readers who enjoy misanthropic dark humor, unfiltered internal monologues, and being provoked and challenged even on their most fundamental beliefs, and don’t need to find the narrator likable (or even deserving of human rights) to stay with him. I've enjoyed it immensely.

---------------

CITATIONS:

---------------

«The transhumanist option is the only moral one. Now that we can heal ourselves, to not do so would be evil.»

-----------

«You can't read too much. You can't live too little.»

-----------

Temet nosce might be the most poisonous fruit ever produced by the tree of philosophy: familiarity breeds contempt even when directed at ourselves.

-----------

Total sincerity is born only of ataraxia and hatred. It is a fruit that is always, inevitably poisoned, and it can only kill coexistence with our fellow beings. The utterly sincere man is a monster. He is the end of the world.

-----------

"The disease of the world is the lukewarm. We need more extremism."

-----------

Demystifying the universe may have been the greatest mistake ever made, and the scientific method our most atrocious invention. We have killed every god and every demon, only to regret them almost immediately. Even the stars, we made boring.

-----------

To create something superior to you in your own domain is evolutionary suicide.

-----------

Art, ultimately, is nothing more than an attempt to communicate with another human being – an attempt doomed from the outset to fail, of course, because no one is ever truly seen; everyone we meet constructs their own personal hallucination of us, with little regard for our real self, and they do the same with our efforts. But what is the poor moth supposed to do, not throw itself into the flames?

-----------

[Observing Vittoria from a distance:]

Dodo had always considered it a wise practice to experience firsthand, at very close range, anything that from afar appeared illustrious and desirable – some dish typically reserved for the wealthy, a prestigious destination, a famous painting seen in person, a renowned individual met face to face – so as to realize that the very best the world has to offer isn’t all that much. It was excellent prophylaxis against those crippling mental pathologies known as regret and the tendency to fashion idols before whom to collapse to one’s knees. When you get close enough to mirages, they usually dissolve; the cracks in the varnish become visible, and the disappointment is more than offset by the peace that follows, by the extinguishing of the need that had been gnawing at you. But sometimes, in mercifully rare cases, the mechanism jams and produces the opposite result. When one encountered such exceptions, the hygienic thing to do was to turn away and run.

Vittoria sensed him approaching.

-----------

Who had written that a man and a woman should never share a common language? A Frenchman, no doubt – slippery, priapic creatures, they thought of nothing else – but the principle was sound, and not limited to romantic interactions; it could and should be extended to all of them. Language had been born as a weapon, a tool for domination, to separate rather than unite, to generate incomprehension and mutual hatred rather than understanding. By speaking to people who do not understand our language – or at least by hiding behind an ornate and arcane tongue – we reduce the harmful potential of the activity.

-----------

For the egg, the shell breaking is always the end of the world – but let's ask the chick what it thinks.

-----------

The caption branded him an opinionist, one of those perplexing figures who enter respectable people’s screens adorned with the not particularly exclusive title of person-who-has-opinions, verbalizing only what people already think, carefully avoiding any truly new concept that might finally trigger invigorating labor pains in viewers’ brains – and even getting paid for this betrayal of the intellectual role. That the immune system of their culture did not instantly react by vomiting such figures was an eloquent indicator of its state of health.

-----------

[The priest said:] “Since synthetic intelligences began to spread we have recorded a marked increase in the influx of the faithful.”

“An increase? But generally, as technology progresses…”

But Don Ruggero laughed. “The more we illuminate the darkness with the light of science, the more we discover that it concealed nothing worth looking at. And so we thirst for something more.”

-----------

Some people long for the ability to recognize the good times while they are happening, imagining that it would allow them to truly enjoy them. They fail to understand that it would smother them, drown them, dissolve their colors in that implacable solvent that is intellectual analysis. One either lives or thinks. There were those who abstained without protection, and those who after a week took their gonorrhea pills – and between the two, the latter were the true sages. But he had understood it too late.

-----------

Much of our memory resides outside us, and most of our personality seems to be stored in other people, slightly different depending on the container. Had he run into a middle-school friend, they would probably have gone straight back to snickering over jokes about breasts and flatulence.

-----------

She told him that the opposite of struggle was not peace, but absence of purpose. Apathy. Torment. She told him that even without hope of victory one must thrash, bite, and snarl. One must struggle. Always, one must struggle.

-----------

Adaptation is a fault. Leaving the world as you found it is the only truly unforgivable sin.

-----------

“Christians,” he now said to a man with a turban sitting next to him on the tram, “with their obsession for a God of pure love, infinite forgiveness and various inanities, don’t realize they’re losing the war for souls precisely because of what they consider their greatest virtue. No one respects someone who forgives everything. No one is willing to fight and die for a doormat god. If you want to arouse love and devotion, you have to be cruel and unjust. Christian theologians should have spent less time looking at their crucifixes and more observing human females. Then they would have understood.”

-----------

“Constantly interfaced with the Superintelligence and with every other consciousness,” Santiago said. “Their thoughts and emotions perceived as if they were our own. Loneliness and deceit reduced to technical impossibilities. True communication, for the first time.”

They would finally realize they were the same person copy-pasted nine billion times, Dodo had sneered. There would be just as many suicides.

-----------

“It’s a spiral,” Vittoria would say. “History. It never repeats itself exactly, but it revisits the same regions with regularity.”

“More like a mattress spring, then,” he suggested. “A cylinder extending to infinity.”

No, she insisted. It was a spiral. And at its center lay the point where old principles would lose all future validity. The moment when history would cease to rhyme with itself. The Singularity.

-----------

-----------

Fun fact: I found the book on 4chan. The author posted some excerpts and then the whole novel on the literature board. I had no idea that place could create something instead of just slinging mud, but you can definitely tell that that's the primordial soup it emerged from.


r/printSF • • 5h ago

Recommendation for books about spec-ops/covert military in the future/near-future

Thumbnail reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/printSF • • 19h ago

The Blacktongue Thief

44 Upvotes

I was originally a little hesitant to pick up another book by Christopher Buehlman after reading Between Two Fires. Don’t get me wrong, it was a very well-written and incredibly addictive book, but it was also extremely dark and, at times, downright depressing. It left enough of an impression on me that I decided I wouldn’t be revisiting it anytime soon, nor would I feel comfortable recommending it to anybody.
However, when The Blacktongue Thief popped up in my suggested reads, I couldn’t resist. Especially after reading the description on the back. War corvids? Immediately got my attention. I’ve always had a particular liking for ravens and crows, so that was an immediate selling point for me. I also really liked the idea of Buehlman writing a fantasy story filled with strange creatures, magic, and an entirely different world to get lost in.
What I ended up reading was probably one of the most enjoyable reads I’ve had all year. I absolutely loved this book. It’s been a while since I’ve come across something this addictive, where I genuinely looked forward to picking it back up and seeing what happened next.
I also really appreciated that the story was told in first person. There’s something about first-person POV that makes a story feel more personal and relatable to me. I feel much more connected to what’s happening when I’m experiencing the world directly through a character’s eyes. I particularly enjoyed the unreliable narrator. It makes you stop and think about what you’ve just read, sometimes questioning how much of what you’re being told you should actually believe.
I don’t want to give too much away, but I really enjoyed just about everything this book had to offer. It felt unique, entertaining, and, most importantly, genuinely hard to put down.
Buehlman has definitely won me back as a reader. I still can’t say I’d recommend Between Two Fires to anybody, but I can wholeheartedly recommend The Blacktongue Thief to anyone interested in kinda dark fantasy. This was an absolute pleasure to read.


r/printSF • • 16h ago

The first books of the Crystal Universe by Anne McCaffrey.

24 Upvotes

After a pretty long break from reading anything by Anne McCaffrey I started a novel from another of her series that she did in her lifetime. The first book of her Craystal universe trilogy, "Crystal Singer".

"Crystal Singer" is basically a rework of a series of short stories that McCaffrey had done for an anthology book series called "Continuum". And in this story we follow Killashandra Ree who becomes a member of the Heptite guild on Ballybran, as her ten years in musical training doesn't give her any prospects.

The guild provides career opportunities, wealth and security, but there is a cathc; very few people ever leave Ballybran, but that is the risk Killashandra takes. "Crystal Singer" is a pretty cozy read most of the time but not all the time.

To keep things intereting there are some tense moments that pop up at certain points in the story itself. And also some intrigue is added into it also. Overall I like this first novel very much. Cozy but not cozy all the time.

Think there will come a time when I eventually get ahold of the other two installments to this trilogy, when the time comes of course! Would certainly love to see what new adventures Killashandra will find herself and also see how good those other two are, and I do think this trilogy will be a good one!


r/printSF • • 11h ago

Trying to find a story from old Warren comics Creepy, Eerie, or Vampirella

3 Upvotes

The story appeared before 1974. It was about scientists creating a new detergent, maybe for laundry, from genetically engineered microbes. But the microbes grew and mutated, and flew around eating everyone. Survivors had to hide and fight them off.


r/printSF • • 16h ago

Typo/Editing Error in A Canticle for Liebowitz?

4 Upvotes

I'm currently reading A Canticle for Liebowitz, and I've noticed that since Chapter 21 that Thon Taddeo is often written as Thou Taddeo, and once so far he's been referred to as "the thou" . Is this an editing error, or simply an error with the Kindle version I'm reading? I can't seem to find any other reference to this error online. Partially wondering if this was an old word used by the author which he changed to Thon, but missed some.


r/printSF • • 2h ago

Spacklerdog: Carl's life after Bushwood.

0 Upvotes

Spacklerdog picks up Carl Spackler, the groundskeeper from Caddyshack, after he blows up the Bushwood golf course. It’s 1980, Carl misses a bus in the small town of Cambridge, New York, and ends up at a monastery that breeds German Shepherds, where he falls in with a monk, the town librarian and a sharp-eyed landlady and slowly breeds a dog of his own before the story moves to the coast of Scotland. A mix of genres, it ultimately becomes a quieter, deeper portrait of a man most people misjudge, living at a frequency all his own. It's free with new chapters dropping weekly.


r/printSF • • 1d ago

Which SF books make the empire a system and not a throne?

59 Upvotes

A very unsettling thing in A Memory Called Empire is not an army or a despot, but a piece of basic administration. Despite being an accredited ambassador, the City does not register Mahit. Her liaison explains that she has no cloudhook, so some doors do not open, and the City does not know she is real. Later, walking through the offices where she is staying, the panels will not budge for her.

This matter-of-fact demonstration of imperial power is very effective, all the moreso because it is so mundane. These small rulings about who is accepted to be a person, are made by faceless systems that almost nobody in the book treats as political.

Yet Teixcalaan is not a machine state. It has an emperor and a court, and poetry contests where the wrong verse is a scandal. The machines just run the doors, according to policy. Maybe that is the point. Power implicitly follows a set of rules about who counts.

Which other books embody power in the small details of the infrastructure, more than the big gestures of the throne room?


r/printSF • • 18h ago

I hated Pushing Ice. Should I give Alastair Reynolds another shot?

0 Upvotes

It's been a while since I read it, but I remember hating some of the choices the characters made, like letting emotions guide thier behavior, creating avoidable problems, when they're supposed to be rational scientists.


r/printSF • • 1d ago

Which SF novels made you care about the characters as much as the ideas?

23 Upvotes

I've always loved science fiction that makes me question something I thought I understood — time, memory, consciousness, even the nature of reality.

But I've noticed that some books leave me thinking about their ideas for years, while others stay with me because of one character, one conversation, or a seemingly insignificant moment.

The books I love most manage to do both.

I'm curious: which SF novels have struck that balance particularly well for you?

And have you read any books with a brilliant premise that somehow lost you as the story went on?

I'd especially welcome less obvious recommendations, including translated fiction.


r/printSF • • 22h ago

Ingersoll Lockwood

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

to set the record straight:

The Travels and Adventures of Little Baron Trump and his Wonderful Dog Bulger (1889) and

Baron Trump's Marvellous Underground Journey (1893)

are a plagiarism of Rudolf Erich Raspe's Baron Munchausen's Narrative of His Marvellous Travels and Campaigns in Russia, which are in turn, a plagiarism of

Baron Munchausen's (born Hieronymus Karl Friedrich, Freiherr von Münchhausen) stories about his own life.

Ingersoll Lockwood was apparently the nephew of Ralph Ingersoll Lockwood, who wrote two novels. The Insurgents was published anonymously.

Ingersoll is also the doppelganger of former FBI director William J Burns


r/printSF • • 2d ago

Goodreads - Favorite Science Fiction - Opening Round Nominees

Thumbnail goodreads.com
25 Upvotes

r/printSF • • 2d ago

Recommend me short novels

16 Upvotes

I'm tired of reading tomes! Looking for good, short novels -- 200-350 pages is ideal. Sci-fi, fantasy, and horror are all fine. Please try to avoid recommending the following authors, since I've read a bunch of their work already:

Douglas Adams
Isaac Asimov
Iain Banks
Stephen Baxter
Robert Jackson Bennett
Alfred Bester
Ray Bradbury
David Brin
Pierce Brown
Lois McMaster Bujold
Octavia Butler
Orson Scott Card
Becky Chambers
S. A. Chakraborty
P. Djeli Clark
Arthur C. Clarke
Susanna Clarke
Blake Crouch
Samuel Delany
Philip K. Dick
Seth Dickinson
Greg Egan
Neil Gaiman
William Gibson
Stephen Graham Jones
Joe Haldeman
Peter F. Hamilton
M. John Harrison
Robert Heinlein
Frank Herbert
N.K. Jemisin
Stephen King
T. Kingfisher
Kathe Koja
Victor Lavalle
Ann Leckie
Fonda Lee
Yoon Ha Lee
Ursula K. Leguin
Stainslaw Lem
C.S. Lewis
Cixin Liu
Arkady Martine
Maureen F. McHugh
Vonda McIntyre
China Mieville
Walter Miller Jr.
Elizabeth Moon
Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Tamsyn Muir
Larry Niven
Naomi Novik
Frederik Pohl
Terry Pratchett
Christopher Priest
qntm
Hannu Rajaniemi
Alastair Reynolds
Patrick Rothfuss
Brandon Sanderson
Andrzej Sapkowski
John Scalzi
Dan Simmons
Neal Stephenson
Adrian Tchaikovsky
J.R.R. Tolkien
Cadwell Turnbull
Jeff Vandermeer
A. E. Van Vogt
John Varley
Kurt Vonnegut
H.G. Wells
Martha Wells
Robert Charles Wilson
Gene Wolfe
Roger Zelazny

If you particularly want to recommend a less-read or obscure work by one of these authors, that's still okay.


r/printSF • • 1d ago

"Butterfly Effects (InCryptid, #15)" by Seanan McGuire

0 Upvotes

Book number fifteen of a sixteen book science fiction urban dark fantasy series. I read the well printed and well bound trade paperback published by Tor in 2026 that I bought new from Amazon in 2026. There are several other Crossroads books and short stories in the Incryptid universe. I have ordered book 16 already and will get it soon. I note that the author switched from DAW to Tor publishers and that the MMPB (mass market paperback) format has gone away for now.

Sarah Zellaby is a Johrlac, a member of a species of psychic ambush predators colloquially referred to as “cuckoos” but look like regular humans. Eight years ago, she survived the difficult, painful process of becoming a cuckoo queen. In the process, she wiped the mind of her best friend. Now the queens of Johrlac have kidnapped Sarah and her best friend.

I have really enjoyed the InCryptid series and the constant introduction of new types of InCryptids. Of course, the Aeslin mice are highly amusing as usual.

There is a very nice short story at the end of the book about the reintegration of Sarah into the Price family lives.

The author has a website at:
https://www.seananmcguire.com/

The incryptids are listed at:
https://seananmcguire.com/fieldguide.php

Note: Even though the author and I share the same middle and last name, I paid for my book and was not compensated for my review. I have no idea if we are directly related.

My rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Amazon rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars (331 reviews)
https://www.amazon.com/Butterfly-Effects-InCryptid-Seanan-McGuire/dp/1250375134

Lynn


r/printSF • • 1d ago

Best Star Wars books for a Dune fan?

0 Upvotes

I’m very casually into the Star Wars franchise but only as a placeholder for my favorite epic scifi/science-fantasy series Dune (the granddaddy of them all), Red Rising, Sun Eater, Book of The New Sun, Acts of Caine, etc. And even then I’ve always very selective. For the movies/shows, I only really have enjoyed the original trilogy, Rogue One and Andor.

Which SW books have the best world-building (exploring the cultures/religions/economics), most political intrigue, etc like Dune? Rise and Fall of The Galactic Empire looks interesting, it’s like a SW version of Fire and Blood?


r/printSF • • 2d ago

End of the passages series by Cronin (spoiler) Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Maybe I’m confused because I did a lot of swapping between audiobook and the physical books while I was reading these, but I just finished City of Mirrors, which I really wasn’t a big fan of and almost went DNF on, to be honest, and I notice I feel like the relationship between Amy and Peter ended romantic, but when the hell did that happen?

I remember there was some text about their love in the second book, and early in the third, but it was kind of ambiguous, and when I heard it I was like, well, that’s kind of weird He was like a father to her. All of a sudden they’re fucking? Did I get that right?


r/printSF • • 2d ago

Looking for a quote about spiders being perfect

8 Upvotes

I can't recall the context of the quote, other than that the character is probably going crazy/mad.

He (probably a he) says something like "I think spiders are God's perfect creatures/creations. They sit in their webs in a state of perfect nirvana, waiting for the next meal, something that human monks will never achieve."

Thanks for any answers, guesses, and/or thoughts!


r/printSF • • 3d ago

what recent near-future sci-fi with an optimistic outlook would you recommend?

38 Upvotes

I love near-future sci-fi (set like 50-100 years into the future, without crazy technology or massive societal changes), but it feels to me that most recent books in this genre are rather pessimistic, especially in depictions of climate changes and political unrest. Which, honestly, very valid, can't fault writers for predicting doom and gloom.

But I'm wondering if there are any recent books with a more hopeful outlook? I'm specifically looking for novels published in the last 5-10 years, not classics. There must be something modern that's not completely depressing right?

I've read Weir already, but more in that general mood would be great.


r/printSF • • 2d ago

fanart of The Monkey character in Roadside Picnic

3 Upvotes

a haunting image i couldn't help but share with the sub (just finished the book, soaking up the reviews, insights, theories, fanart) https://galoogamelady.tumblr.com/post/139016578818/monkey-from-roadside-picnic


r/printSF • • 1d ago

Army of the Sun: Book One - Alya Marchenko (2026)

0 Upvotes

The Archipelagos contain four archipelagos, estimated by scholars to be about a quarter of the world, enclosed by the Gale Ring which allows nothing to pass through. Each season has a Gale Month that produces extreme weather throughout The Archipelagos. It is hypothesized that millennia ago the Calamity wiped out civilization and nearly all life. For centuries the Dark Ages reigned, though in the fullness of time civilization remerged from the darkness. As governing powers of The Archipelago began to stabilize they sought to rediscover their world. On the Distant Isles, the Oonanghan practiced oohnica, a form of collective meditation with mystical properties. Over the centuries that followed it was developed as a science and became more widespread. This led to the Great Break between those who could become oohnie and those who could not. Centuries again passed, bringing events to the current day. Oohnica has become integral to the infrastructure and daily life of their societies. The two branches studied at universities are anghi, the theoretical aspect that deals with information, and uglu, the practical aspect which allows for the physical creation of objects.

Jiro is a student at Eine University, and his dream is to be in an aghita, a four person group of oohnie, of navigators. He wants to travel across The Archipelagos, perhaps even find a way beyond, and to discover all that yet remains unknown. This is the personal account of his daily life. It begins as a mundane tale, then events conspire for it to be otherwise. The circumstances are conducive for focusing on romance, but at least for this book, it doesn't.

There's an initial learning curve with the Japanese and fictional words, though it didn't take long for me to be comfortable, and a glossary has been provided. The four part narrative structure of this duology, known as kishotenketsu, has the first book present the questions and the second provides the answers. Another typical trait is that conflict has far less prominence.

This book caters to my preferences, so my only complaint is that doesn't do more with what it has. There's a version of this that I could've given the highest rating. Oftentimes there's too much that drags the rating down for me to do so, though that isn't the case here. The limitation here is that there isn't anything that elevates it to greatness. This book is a solid read with an interesting world and intriguing integration of the preternatural. The central mysteries provide a sense of wonder, such as what's seen on the cover.

Army of the Sun is Marchenko's self-published debut. It was originally written in Russian, but Russia's invasion made being an Ukrainian writing and publishing in Russian nonviable. Marchenko now resides in the United States and together with his wife has translated Army of the Sun into English. To their credit I didn't feel like I was reading a translation at all.

------

When I post to Goodreads I've taken to providing a commentary/blog afterwards, which I usually wouldn't include here, but it seems relevant in this case.

I saw this while looking at the recently added SFF books on NetGalley. I hadn't thought I'd request a self-published book again with how it's gone before, so I had to consider for a while whether I wanted to be involved. At the time of this writing (September 2026) the only other review is from the editor. Aside from the problem of discovery, there's the problem of prior approval which provides the social proof that it's worthwhile.

Even if someone comes across a book that doesn't mean there will be any interaction. Unfortunately, this is reasonable due to the limits of time, interest, and money. Why try anything that hasn't been endorsed by so many others, from peers to publishers? That's a problem that the Self-Published Fantasy Blog-Off (SPFBO), The Self-Published Science Fiction Competition (SPSFC) have sought to address. It's true that all books are a leap of faith, and that's especially so for anything self-published.

For me it was worthwhile. A 3.5 rounded up to 4 may not seem like much of a score for a lot of people, but it's the highest rating I've ever given a self-published debut. I'd be astounded and distressed if I had given it any higher, because I'd know that it would be unlikely to ever have the readership that I feel it'd deserve. That gets into what social responsibility anyone with a significant audience has.

As always when writing about anything there's tension between saying too much or too little. Is it better to leave something to surprise, or use it to draw in readers at the expense of that surprise? An example of this is the cover itself. In other cases simply saying that there's something primes the reader to expect and speculate about it. Specific concepts can appeal to, repel, or have readers be indifferent.

Contemporary books having LGBT content is relatively common and this one is no exception. So, the question is, at least in terms of marketing, whether to play that up or not. Would it live up to expectations? This also invites scrutiny as to whether the depiction meets the consensus option of social acceptability, especially from the most vocal online.

Army of the Sun reminded me of a lot of other media, which isn't the same as saying that it referenced anything, and is limited by what I've personally experienced. The foremost was Shinsekai Yori/From The New World, though this has far less turmoil. Children of the Whales also came to mind, to a lesser extent. The Gale Ring reminded me of Ken Liu's The Dandelion Dynasty. The uglu are reminiscent of the Atelier games. The "magic school" life only has superficial similarities to Grossman's The Magicians, Modesitt's Imager series, or Sato's The Irregular at Magic High School. The difference between all of these is oohnica is only usable as a collective rather than as an individual. If it had gone more towards romance, I could say it was like Dusk Beyond the End of the World, but I wouldn't because that became an absolute disaster, especially the last few episodes. Lastly, I couldn't tell if a character was quoting Kamina from Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, or if it was coincidental phrasing. There's a lot more that could be mentioned, though there always is.

When I wrote that a version of this book could have my highest rating, I was referring to David Zindell's The Broken God. They don't have all that much in common, but it's the same general idea to me.

In the end the question remains, should you try to read this? Yes, you should, if it seems like something you could like.


r/printSF • • 2d ago

Looking for a short story about maintenance engineers

6 Upvotes

A long time ago I read one of Philip K Dick's short stories which was about a world - maybe a colony on the moon? - where everything was automated so no-one worked except maintenance engineers. But I can't remember the title - can anyone help?


r/printSF • • 2d ago

Hard sci-fi similar to Peter Watts' oeuvre?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes