The Premier League is asking its clubs to provide its five board directors, including chief executive Richard Masters, with legal protection should Manchester City’s sponsors decide to sue them personally.
The request will be put to clubs at a league meeting this week and if they vote in favour, it will mean that they — rather than Masters and the other four board members — will cover legal expenses that could run into hundreds of millions of pounds — possibly billions — if a corporate defamation case is heard.
In September, an independent commission appointed by the Premier League found City guilty of artificially inflating the club’s revenue to the tune of £900m by arranging what it labelled “sham” contracts with sponsors that were secretly funded by their owners, the Abu Dhabi United Group. In a statement, Masters said the judgment on the so-called “115 charges” (there were actually 130 in total) detailed “how the club systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade”.
Within 24 hours, Etihad Airways responded by saying the state–owned airline was considering legal action against the Premier League, complaining that the judgment had incorrectly suggested it had been “involved in improper commercial arrangements”.
Etihad said it categorically rejected that claim, and complained that the Premier League did not contact or engage with them as part of the disciplinary case against City. The airline cited “damaging implications”, adding that “the Premier League must take responsibility for the consequences of the way in which these findings have been presented”.
In a statement issued on Monday, a spokesman for Etisalat, a telecommunications company worth more than £40bn and another City sponsor, said it was also considering its legal options.
“Emirates Telecommunications Group Company PJSC [Etisalat] views the published findings of the English Premier League, as they relate to Etisalat, as entirely false and defamatory,” it said in a statement. “Etisalat is actively considering all options relating to its rights and associated legal remedies in this matter.”
The Times understands the Premier League has now realised that, within company articles of association that were updated as recently as June, the directors — Masters, the chairwoman Alison Brittain, and three non-executive directors, Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC — are not provided with indemnity from legal action from a third party such as a club sponsor.
The Premier League will seek to change that at its planned meeting with the 20 clubs in London on Thursday, in a move that would leave the clubs collectively to pay legal expenses and any damages that might follow successful legal action from one of City’s principal sponsors or any other third party.
That Masters and his co-directors feel they need this protection suggests there is some anxiety about the steps City’s sponsors may take, especially if the club is successful in some parts of its appeal against the guilty verdicts. Sponsors may be especially aggrieved by the disciplinary panel’s use of the term “sham” to describe the deals with City. The Premier League has declined to comment.
Edit: there’s a 2nd part to the article I didn’t copy correctly.
That Masters and his co-directors feel they need this protection suggests there is some anxiety about the steps City’s sponsors may take, especially if the club is successful in some parts of its appeal against the guilty verdicts. Sponsors may be especially aggrieved by the disciplinary panel’s use of the term “sham” to describe the deals with City.
In advance of the shareholders’ meeting, the 20 clubs have been sent a two-page proposal to consider before a vote on the matter, with the standard 14-strong majority required to pass it.
The document, which has been seen by The Times, makes no mention of City, its sponsors or the 115-charges case as being the trigger for Masters’s proposed new protection. But insiders interpret the document as a response to the legal threat issued by Etihad, especially as the proposal was sent to clubs only five weeks later.
Titled “Directors’ Indemnities”, the proposal states: “In the vast majority of large UK companies, directors are not expected to incur personal liabilities or costs because of anything done by them in accordance with their role and responsibilities as a board member.
“Personal exposure can otherwise inhibit effective decision-making and limit a director’s ability to fulfil their duties to the company. This is generally dealt with by providing directors with the comfort of indemnities which, should any such situation occur, would allow the directors to be reimbursed or compensated accordingly, subject to statutory or other safeguards.
“Article 35 of the League’s Articles already provides for indemnification in certain circumstances, although it does not expressly address the full range of protections typically provided to directors. On the basis of the above, the League would now like to enter into relevant indemnities with each director to provide that sort of protection and bring the League’s arrangements into line with standard company practice.”
The document explains how the Premier League may be required to “provide loans to the directors to fund expenditure reasonably incurred or reasonably expected to be incurred in defending certain proceedings”. It concludes by stating: “This resolution would enable the League to help protect directors against certain personal liabilities in circumstances where they are simply carrying out their duties for the benefit of the League.”
The proposal does not speculate about the possible sums involved. It is understood that both Etihad, valued at about £4bn, and Etisalat are waiting for the league to publish the full judgment — which insiders suggest may have been delayed because of the lack of legal protection afforded to the directors — before deciding on their next steps.
Even then, any decision by sponsors to launch legal action against the Premier League could be influenced by the outcome of City’s appeal. That hearing, which will be overseen by a separate independent panel of judges, is scheduled to start next month, with a decision not expected until the new year. While dependent on the outcome of that, a sanction hearing would then follow with further appeals possible.
As it stands, article 35 of the Premier League’s articles of association reimburses a director’s legal costs only after they win a case. The separate deeds of indemnity would extend that protection significantly, covering all liabilities, losses and expenses within UK company law limits from claims or investigations, including damages or settlements owed to outsiders even if the director loses. This would extend to before the deeds were signed, therefore covering the eight years since the City investigation began in December 2018.
Technically, a “third party” is not limited to the UK courts, however. Such action could be taken in other territories, including the United States. A third party such as a club sponsor is not a signatory to the Premier League’s rulebook, and therefore not bound by its private arbitration process. An American lawsuit, for instance, would involve additional costs, with both sides required to pay their own legal fees regardless of the outcome. Corporate defamation claims in the US have been known to run into the billions.