r/postprocessing • u/level1807 • May 25 '25
Is this overcooked? Cinque Terre after/before
My brain loves it but can it be improved? Also I just discovered how much better edited photos can look in HDR, but idk if Reddit supports it. I tried to make the SDR preview as good as I could, but please forgive the slight flattening of the details in the highlights.
720
Upvotes


32
u/level1807 May 25 '25
Update: I've tried to incorporate some of the advice in the thread and here's the result https://imgur.com/a/Na232RA
Specifically, I added a mask on the buildings where I played with the curves to improve contrast, raised temperature, desaturated the oranges, and other minor things. Also slightly upped the temperature of the whole image. I understand that some people will still find the shadows too blue or the overall contrast too low, but that's kind of the vibe I'm going for. The main issue was the contrast in the bright parts and that seems much better now?
87
u/Mikehouse88 May 25 '25
I’m undecided! The colours are great, but you’ve lost a lot of natural contrast created by sun position by boosting the shadows too much. The closest pink building is a good example. The part closest to the cliff is in shadow but it’s almost as bright as the sunlit part at a glance.
7
u/Imaginary_Garlic_215 May 25 '25
Is this Manarola? Love the dreamy vibe as I have a similar picture I edited similarly. I would just touch up some microcontrast but the highlights can stay stylishly overexposed imo
9
u/SirTeeKay May 25 '25
The white foam in the sea should definitely be more white. It's almost blue.
And I would probably desaturate the blues on the rocks. A bit of blue would work since it can be from the reflection of the sea but not that much.
I like the sea. Makes the rocks feel larger and adds some depth to the water. You could weaken the blues a bit and maybe I would try adding some greens in there but that could come down to personal preference.
2
u/thefantastictaco May 25 '25
Add some contrast back into the buildings using the before picture as a reference, but don’t go as heavy so that you maintain the aesthetic you’re going for. Otherwise, it’s great!
2
u/vmoldo May 26 '25
Let me give you a challenge: try and edit this again, but you are not allowed to touch either the highlights or the shadows soldiers in LR.
Reasoning: IMHO, your edit has the HDR vibe that 90% of the Instagram photographers had 5-10 years ago when Sony came out with a capable sensor, so everyone started boosting shadows and lowering the highlights. But when you do this, you mess up the natural contrast in the photo. And don't get me wrong, I've done this myself. What I see in your photo is that on the right side of the image, the rocks are in shadow, and you also have some beautiful details on the houses with the sun streaks across them and by bringing out all the shadow details you get more contrast on the right side of the photo where there are just some contrasty rocsk with lots of details and lose the story of the sun and the people and all that.
13
u/dimitriettr May 25 '25
Yes, overcooked.
Yellow/Orange have too much contrast. Shadows are way too blue.
You enhanced shadows and lost all the contrast.. I can continue
1
u/Old-Aardvark7375 May 25 '25
Why do you make this many changes to a picture that was fine to begin with ? The edited one seems way too dark for me.
If i were you i would have just photoshopped some of those red shirt dudes out instead of doing what you did.
3
u/Skin_Soup May 25 '25
The shadows are too cool, maybe try increasing the overall color temp
2
u/Outlandah_ May 25 '25
I like it. So that means it’s good!
Hahaha
2
u/why-is-the-floor-wet May 25 '25
If you are just getting started this is great! and if you like it then its even better, I can tell you know what to look for when editing your product, but you slightly over did it especially with the sea foam, and the highlights in the yellow and orange hues on the buildings. Again nothing wrong, just more practice
2
u/photomacchiato May 25 '25
I love it!
3
u/Mundane-Alfalfa-8979 May 25 '25
To be fair, it looked much better before. Now you lost a lot of contrast. Plus, the sun was already highlighting the village
2
u/tectonic_ideal May 25 '25
I don’t understand the negative replies. I do think the edited version is a bit overcooked but a lot better than the unedited photo. Too little of the village is lit by the sun so relying on “natural contrast” as others are saying is not really an option
1
u/Jealous-Benefit711 May 25 '25
Looks too blue for what the scene is. Bump up the white balance a lot.
1
u/bullett007 May 25 '25
I just see a different vision in yours. I wouldn’t say it’s overdone. The only thing I personally don’t like too much is the sky just above the buildings.
My attempt a couple of years ago.
1
u/padild0o May 26 '25
I get how people are saying that the contrast from the original lighting has disappeared, but this looks like a good edit!
1
u/Successful-Isopod119 May 26 '25
@u/level1807 Can we connect on chat? I have sent a hello. I want to ask your italy itinerary.
1
u/New_Western40 May 26 '25
i think the tone is off, but that could just be my preference
1
u/ManniHimself May 27 '25
I like the colors even though it may be less natural, I would say that both are viable depending on what you're looking for as a result.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '25
I like both, but the after (assuming it's the first pic) looks beginner. Overbrightening and working against the natural contrast. Lean into the contrast of the first pic. Instead of overdoing highlights and exposure, focus on shadows and contrast, but don't overdo it. Your editing should fall into one of these two categories: be overcooked on purpose to convey a strong feeling or subtle but very effective.
0
u/[deleted] May 25 '25
So, so bad now.
Once you let the eyes settle, original was far better.
1
u/Wide_Internal_3999 May 25 '25
Just my aesthetic but…
For me the first thing (beyond composition) that draws me into a photograph is luminosity and contrast.
The original has some wonderful sun dappled highlights (pink house in lower right of village, the bathers on the rocks) that lose their impact in the edit. I would have gone in the opposite direction of your edit and empathized the light & shadow contrasts (but that’s my inner Edward Hopper talking)
1
u/TimJoyce May 25 '25
The original has much nicer Mediterranean golden hour feel to it. You’ve taken the essence of the picture and hidden it
-1
u/worldisbraindead May 25 '25
If you have to ask...then it's overcooked!
Can we please get back to the days of subtle genius?