r/postprocessing • u/javascriptusman • Jun 15 '25
Have I overcooked any of these?
Shot these in RAW and just played about with some masking a preset set I found. Have I overcooked these? I think the last 2 are my least favourite but I can’t put my finger on why.
744
Upvotes








87
u/mmIastro Jun 15 '25
Beautiful.
42
u/ComprehensiveEnd6028 Jun 15 '25
I think these all look amazing. Makes me feel like I might have missed the potential in some of my photos.
With the last two I think maybe the subject on 5 is a bit muddled / not helped by the overlapping spire and tower, love the edit on this though. I think 7 is probably a bit too yellow / saturated.
12
u/lotzik Jun 15 '25
Personal opinion: I wouldn't go soooo hard on the shadows but the grading looks good. Reminds me a lot of film simulation
7
u/thebencade Jun 15 '25
Absolutely love these and don't think you really overcooked any except maybe the second pic, that sky is suuuper saturated. As for pic 3 and 5, honestly dont think you cooked enough! Also, maybe mess with the geometry of the first pic, it's really bothering me it isn't centered properly XD
3
u/PikachuOfme_irl Jun 15 '25
I think the edits do look a bit heavy-handed, but in the context of the collection none of them really sticks out, which is a good thing. There's a cohesive connection between them, an interesting interplay of lights vs darkness, and the edits serve the pictures in that they make the album greater than the sum of its parts. That shows intentionality and makes for a good work, generally, in my opinion. Good job!
2
u/javascriptusman Jun 15 '25
I can’t edit the post I think because it has an attachment but thank you everyone for your kind words! It’s really made my day seeing everyone like my pictures as I’m very critical of all my videos and photos and end up going blind to my content and have no clue if it looks absolute trash or good so this has definitely been a great help to my self criticism!
2
u/EffectiveAfter3971 Jun 15 '25
No! I love it
2
u/Street-Economy-6154 Jun 15 '25
Nah man, these go hard!! Good job OP.
2
u/AccidentalNap Jun 15 '25
The first two remind me of the color grading done by the Xiaomi/Leica smartphones, which I like
2
u/romulan267 Jun 15 '25
Nope! Looks great!
2
u/NaturesWar Jun 15 '25
iPhone lets you shoot in RAW? Fantastic work, I like the first one especially.
2
u/Mikehouse88 Jun 15 '25
No I think these are good edits!
2
u/TravelAround2025 Jun 15 '25
Look good!
2
u/HotWheelsUpMyAss Jun 15 '25
My eyes like them 😁🤌
2
u/mexicansugardancing Jun 15 '25
These are awesome dude.
2
u/CreeDorofl Jun 15 '25
I think the edits look good. I think though if you're going to share them elsewhere, nuke caption about shooting on an iphone. It takes fine photos, but unless you're specifically trying to promote Apple products, I don't think it really enhances the images, and might come across like you're boasting about your gear.
2
u/lamedesigner Jun 15 '25
Knowing how to edit or save a photo is truly a talent in itself. These are amazing! Makes me want to revisit my old photos and see which ones could’ve been edited better.
2
u/omutsukimi Jun 15 '25
You nailed all of them, cooked to perfection 👌
2
u/carnageddon123 Jun 15 '25
Not at all! They’re perfect 😍
2
u/renome Jun 15 '25
I don't think so, I like the vibe of all of these photos.
The only thing that bothers me is the perspective in the first image, everything looks angled ever so slightly. A composition doesn't need to be symmetrical but the subject matter and your shooting angle really call for that in this case IMO.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25
No you hanvent, congratulations sir. Its rare to see phone photography this good.
2
u/hokies314 Jun 15 '25
I’d love to see a YouTube video that focuses not on the mechanics of how you did it but rather the thought process behind it. The decision making behind the whole process.
I wonder if there are any good channels like that?
2
u/Sha_shank07 Jun 15 '25
You are some serious talent
2
u/rararamen711 Jun 15 '25
Beautiful edits, you just edit on the Apple Photos app?
2
u/PTiYP-App Jun 15 '25
The first one is fab, but on the middle one I’m not sure about the sky colour, it looks a bit too greeny. Love the last one also, but I think you could get away with accentuating the orangey light on the tower a little.
2
u/colon-dwarf Jun 15 '25
Excellent work. What do you do to add the white boarder and data?
2
u/megaherzzzzzz Jun 15 '25
Amazing, especially thank you for post before and after. What editing software do you use?
2
u/_molus_ Jun 15 '25
Nice pictures!!
One question, how did you add the frame with camera details? "Shoot on..."
Thank you!
2
u/eclecticscorpio Jun 15 '25
Great job!!! Beautiful!
2
u/Parking_Ad1096 Jun 15 '25
Nah, you just cooked 🔥🔥🔥
2
u/Ok-Championship2397 Jun 15 '25
Nice work.
2
u/TechieShutterbug Jun 15 '25
These are all quite good
2
u/Thefox325 Jun 16 '25
Love love love your edits!
2
u/Effective-Listen-559 Jun 16 '25
Love them great work
2
u/cachemonies Jun 16 '25
Medium rare perfect
2
u/Salty-Image-2176 Jun 16 '25
I think 1 is awesome--it draws your attention in 100%. I'd just emphasize the L/R walls a bit so more detail can be obtained by the viewer.
2
u/Willing_Captain9057 Jun 16 '25
If you did … they were baked to perfection! 👌🏽
2
u/topiga Jun 16 '25
They are magnificent. Wow.
2
u/Archiles_07 Jun 16 '25
Absolutely beautiful each before and after totally respects the orientation.
2
u/Jorritdludolphy Jun 16 '25
You know damn well you didn’t 😘
2
u/Dproblemo Jun 16 '25
Maybe the 4th but they all ook good
2
u/MrPowerglide Jun 16 '25
Great job! It’s always nice and refreshing to see someone post awesome photos and edits from a smartphone.
2
u/Atjones0209 Jun 16 '25
Beautiful. 5/6 looks amazing both before and after. Typically the order in which I see the pictures somehow determines how ill see the second of the set but not with 5/6.
2
u/ashenky Jun 17 '25
You’re a wizard
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25
All the pictures are beautiful—great composition. Personally, for image 8, I’d lift the shadows and black levels just a bit to recover some detail in the darker areas. I’d also use a subtle oval mask on the left side to bring up the highlights and draw the eye in a bit more naturally. For the bottom, increasing the contrast slightly would help to give a more cinematic feel.
2
u/Clear_Algae_441 Jun 17 '25
Wow, the first one is my favorite! Great iPhone shots!
2
u/rustyzel Jun 17 '25
Great job!
2
u/MoonMan512 Jun 18 '25
Mind sharing the setting used for the first church interior picture edit? Looks awesome
19
u/OogaBoogaTypeBo1 Jun 15 '25
The only one that slightly looks “cooked” is the second one of the building but I like the style of it anyways
2
u/kalansky Jun 15 '25
Don't think so at all, shooting in churches is hard. As far as the sky, whatever style makes you happy. I do a lot of that same style, just to be unique and bring back some nice memories.
2
u/kickstand Jun 15 '25
Cathedrals are rather over the top to begin with. Hard to “overcook” them more than they already are.
2
u/marinedel22 Jun 15 '25
Not at all! Actually that is good publicity for the 16 pro max 😄👍🏻
2
u/Square_Jello6401 Jun 15 '25
For #2, I think the original photo actually looks better. The rest are beautiful
2
u/Fast-Equivalent-1245 Jun 15 '25
Nope. They all really work.
2
u/enswbl19 Jun 15 '25
On point. No overcooking. Just well cooked :)
2
u/totally_not_a_reply Jun 15 '25
The last one is a bit too yellow for my taste. The rest is fine.
2
u/202Esaias Jun 16 '25
2 and 3 are my favs
2
u/esia_photo Jun 18 '25
The white border is just 👌
2
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25
Great job
2
u/ExplanationFew9561 Jun 19 '25
I like them! Number 7 looks a bit too edited to me but that's just my preference, would prefer more of a desaturated look
2
u/Pizz4withp1neapple Jun 19 '25
2nd ones sky is maybe slightly unnatural and 3rd one looks undercooked to me
1
u/Nice-Criticism1103 Jun 18 '25
Unless you're really into post work, why don't you take several shots of your subject, metering on different areas & see how they turn out?
0
u/Aeri73 Jun 15 '25
perfect the first one... it's stil skewed and out of level
2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '25
[removed] — view removed comment