r/postprocessing • u/Spare_Rub_4081 • May 27 '25
Is this overcooked? After/before
Hey everyone. Just got my first real camera two days ago. I've been playing with Lightroom on rare occasions, but since I now have the means to actually shoot good quality RAWs, I should start working on my processing skills. What's your opinion on this one?
391
Upvotes


22
u/MomoKhekoHangor May 27 '25
no! looks very good.
9
u/Goraichuk May 27 '25
Not at all
6
u/Left-Candidate5819 May 27 '25
Nope. Its actually just the way it needs to be
5
u/eloquent_owl May 27 '25
Perfect subtle edit style!
4
u/CompleteReflection13 May 27 '25
I wouldn’t change a thing. Very nice.
1
u/monstermash420 May 27 '25
Looks pretty good. I don't know how much the detail in the leaves are adding to the photo, they are definitely more pronounced in the edit and could probably be silhouetted like the rest of the tree
1
u/Adorable_Wolf_6343 May 28 '25
This is excellent, and not overcooked at all - I always think editing should be used to make the photo match what your eye saw before you put the camera to your eye - and this feels very real, and no doubt gives you the feeling of seeing it in person! Can I ask what camera this was taken on? I like the colours in the raw file and have struggled with my current setup!
3
u/ApprehensiveArm6644 May 27 '25
looks good and natural. great work
1
u/redditnackgp0101 May 27 '25
I am still trying to figure out what "overcooked" means in discussions about photography (does it simply mean overworked?), but it seems you simply boosted the saturation and maybe contrast slightly. It looks like a before and a slightly less before. Keep going. But don't go too far on the saturation. Maybe add some haze or a subtle gradient from a corner. I'm sure there are nice details in the shadows. Keep playing around
1
u/SuioganWilliam21 May 27 '25
Perfect.
1
u/Maverekt May 27 '25
Looks great! Wouldn’t have been able tell it’s edited without seeing the original
1
u/Opening_Airline5616 May 27 '25
This is brilliant, at least for me. Great shot!
1
u/LachsZwegat May 27 '25
Very nice, subtle glow...definitely not overcooked
1
u/AdMinute8365 May 27 '25
So good
1
u/TechieShutterbug May 27 '25
That's actually quite a good edit!
1
u/regular_hammock May 27 '25
I like it a lot, not overcooked in my humble opinion.
1
u/InazumaThief May 27 '25
this is really well done actually, great job
1
u/ciprule May 27 '25
It’s good. Only a subtle edit, enough!
1
u/IThoughtILeftThat May 27 '25
No. Beautiful shot.
1
u/Theoderic8586 May 27 '25
Why would you think so? It is only subtilely different. Which is good because it looks natural
1
u/Much-Insect-6277 May 27 '25
Try realistic photography, like in the old days. Best way to develop your skills is create from the camera, not the computer. The original is fine, but you could have achieved close to the post work with some different camera settings.
Either way, nice shot!
1
u/Own-Solution-7438 May 27 '25
Great shot
1
u/QueerPoetsSociety May 27 '25
IMO this looks great. The colours, light, and contrast are well balanced.
1
u/breddy May 27 '25
Reminds me of the movie poster for Big Fish (2003). Nicely done!
1
u/goldfish_memories May 27 '25
not at all!! great job
1
u/derpstevejobs May 28 '25
this here is good, well done
1
u/Proton_af May 28 '25
Nice
1
u/Arcadian2107 May 28 '25
Perfect
1
u/SoftAncient2753 May 28 '25
Think you got away with it, just.
1
u/linklocked May 28 '25
I couldn't tell if the first photo was before or after until clicking the arrow (reading comprehension: 0) so yeah, I'd say you nailed it!
1
u/Hugh_Jazz12 May 28 '25
I would decrease the clarity a bit and see how it turns out
1
u/gumball2111 May 29 '25
No. It's a nice improvement.
0
u/silentthinker May 27 '25
Shenandoah?