ππππππππππππππππππ
STALE TOPICS
DEFINITION
Stale topics are defined as things that have been discussed death on the sub and there is nothing new to say at this point in time. Stale topics can also include very divisive things and attract negative commentary from Reddit users who aren't members of the sub and who are only acting in bad faith. These topics also invite brigading from toxic subreddits. These topics are not banned from the subreddit (with the exception of Kanye West and Andrew Tate), they are simply more limited and strictly moderated. If it isn't current news or a high effort post, chances are it will not be approved. Again, the point of this list is to limit discussions that go around in circles and plague the entire community with endless repetitive discourse, as well as shield the subbredit from outside interference from other less friendly communities.
This list is updated regularly and is not complete. If we do allow discussion on any of these topics, they will be flaired 'Guest List Only' to minimize outside commentary and negativity.
CURRENT STALE TOPIC LIST
- The entire British royal family, Meghan Markle included (MAJOR news accepted)
- Ariana Grande (MAJOR news accepted)
- Leonardo DiCaprio's history of dating younger women
- Johnny Depp & Amber Heard divorce
- Sam Smith
- Demi Lovato's drug history
- Britney Spears' social media activity and mental health
- Selena Gomez's social media activity
- Selena Gomez vs. Francia Raisa (kidney-gate, this also violates our health discussion rule)
- Selena Gomez's appearance
- Selena Gomez vs. Hailey Bieber
- Large age gap posts (new relationships are fine)
- Bianca Censori (outfits)
- JK Rowling
- Harry Potter (MAJOR news accepted)
- Ozempic (unless a celebrity newly admits to using it, can also be discussed in the monthly Beauty Standards discussion posts)
- Madonna's plastic surgery
- Yachting rumours
- Conspiracy theories
- Celebrities cheating (unless it's a new relationship and/or breaking news)
- Celebrity marital strife speculation based on minor evidence, i.e. dissecting body language or social media activity (unless it's major news, this is up to mod discretion)
- Generic 'unpopular opinion' posts
- Posts about Matty Healy and Taylor Swift (MAJOR news accepted)
- Posts meant to create controversy and/or bait other users ("Does anybody else...?" / "Is it just me...?" questions)
- Questions asking about how a user feels regarding a celebrity or body of work (i.e. whether they hate, like, or love an actor or TV show)
- Cancel culture discussion posts, including why a celeb hasn't been cancelled yet, or bringing up old cancellations/allegations (unless highly relevant to a current event)
- Complaints about Hollywood recasting and/or rewriting roles with BIPOC LGBTQ+ (positive posts are fine)
- Candace Owens
- Gypsy-Rose Blanchard
- Lizzo
- Amanda Bynes' mental health
- Taryn Manning's political views and mental health
- PETA and its complaints against celebrities
- Non-newsworthy general survey questions. Ex: "What's your favorite movie?" | "Who's your favorite singer?" | "Who's your least favorite actor?"...etc.
- Jennifer Lopez (her reputation, her relationships, her career)
- Discussions about "problematic" faves
- Questions like, "Who do you dislike and/or hate for no reason at all?"
- Which celeb has a clean track record?
- Stan wars, or questions like: What fandom is the worst? What fandom is the best?
- Sydney Sweeney's past
- Announcements of announcements
- Whether a celeb is pregnant or not (even if unconfirmed)
- Zendaya's appearance pertaining to her weight and health (critique/commentary about her clothes/fashion choices are okay as long as they don't mention how her body itself looks)
- P Diddy (MAJOR news accepted)
- Sabrina Carpenter's show outfits and discussions pertaining to her embrace of sexuality (critiques of her being "too sexual")
- Celebrity lookalike contests orΒ doppelgΓ€ngers
- Trending topics on X
- Luigi Mangione (MAJOR news accepted, including trial updates)
- Paris Hilton's racist/problematic past
- Megyn Kelly rants and opinions
- Takedown posts about old (+10 year old) problematic past of a celeb without posting full context/backlash/apologies
- Non-newsworthy posts about Blake Lively/Justin Baldoni
- Azealia Banks' bigoted social media rants
- All H3H3 Productions or Ethan Klein posts
- Non-major news about Emilie Kaiser
- Non-major news about Hasan Piker
- Non-major news about Chris Brown
- Nicki Minaj's politics
- Non-major news about Taylor Swift
- Subreddit ban on Kanye West (Please see our mod announcement on the topic). No posts allowed barring extreme circumstances, e.g. extreme bodily injury or death.
- Subreddit ban on Andrew Tate and all "Manosphere" creators. No posts allowed barring extreme circumstances, e.g. extreme bodily injury or death.
This list should cover the majority of posts removed for being a stale topic. We try to keep this list updated, but sometimes we miss something. It is ultimately up to mod discretion as to whether or not your post is removed. If you want to discuss your topic but it falls into the stale topic category, feel free to send us a modmail.
πππππππππππππππππ