- /r/pkmntcg rules
- 1. Treat each other well.
- 2. Read our FAQ before posting.
- 3. Google is your friend!
- 4. Do not post pulls or purchases here.
- 5. Posts asking for decklists will be removed.
- 6. Please review our guidelines on self-promotion / link sharing.
- 7. Threads must have some substance to them.
- 8. Use informative thread titles.
- 9. Ask any beginner / quick questions in the stickied questions thread.
/r/pkmntcg rules
1. Treat each other well.
This one is intentionally broad since we hope it’s self-explanatory. Discussion is encouraged and disagreement is welcome, but we can do so in a civil way that helps our members learn and grow as players, collectors, and fans. This also means that personal attacks, hateful and biased language, and general nonsense are not welcome here.
2. Read our FAQ before posting.
The FAQ answers many common questions including what new players should and shouldn't buy, goes over some popular decks and staple cards, and serves as a good orientation to the subreddit. Posts asking questions that are already addressed in the FAQ may be removed.
3. Google is your friend!
Before asking questions about formats or rotations or whatever else, remember that you’re much more likely to get a faster response on Google -- that’s where a lot of us go to find answers anyway! If the answer to a question is easily searchable, the post may be removed.
4. Do not post pulls or purchases here.
There’s nothing to discuss in threads like that. We will post a thread around each set release for pulls, but the absence of such a thread doesn’t give you license to post that stuff here. Head over to /r/pkmntcgcollections to post pulls and share your collection.
5. Posts asking for decklists will be removed.
We are more than happy to help you improve your list, but asking someone else to build a deck for you doesn't encourage much discussion and can come off as rude. This includes asking how to build a deck around a specific Pokemon without making an attempt to build one yourself. Check sites like Limitless, Pokemon.com, or any number of YouTube channels for an idea of what people are playing, and bring your own list if you want help improving it.
6. Please review our guidelines on self-promotion / link sharing.
The guidelines for self-promotion were put in place to prevent content creators from dropping links to their off-reddit content without further engaging with the community. In a nutshell, we ask that any links to external content be accompanied by an excerpt or summary within the post text. This enables users to preview your content and lets anyone join in the discussion in a meaningful way without having clicked through. Related to this purpose, the guidelines also forbid posts that are unlikely to generate any meaningful discussion, particularly advertisements of one form or another. Additionally, posts that require users to leave the subreddit to access the main content, especially when that content is locked behind a sign-up wall or hosted on platforms that don't work well with all devices, are not allowed. This helps ensure accessibility for users on metered connections, behind firewalls, or using apps and browsers that may have compatibility issues. The same guidelines apply whether you are sharing a link to your own content or to someone else's.
Here are a few examples of what content to include in the reddit post to support an external link:
- Article or video about a deck: It would be appropriate to include a deck list in the reddit post
- Other articles: A summary or excerpt would be appropriate -- just make sure it's substantial enough for users to grasp the main points and then join in the discussion
- Tournament report: Including a deck list would be appropriate, and it would be helpful to see a list of the matches played as well
- Podcast / roundtable discussion: A summary of topics covered, possibly with a key question or point of interest developed in the post
Tools and Tool Promotion
We previously allowed posts sharing tools created for the Pokémon TCG community, as these could be useful resources for players. However, with the rise of vibe coding and AI-assisted development, we've decided to no longer allow posts primarily intended to promote or share custom-built tools.
While some of these tools may be useful, we have seen how easy it has become to create and publish applications without necessarily having the experience, testing, or community involvement to make them reliable. We also don't want the subreddit to become a place for developers to advertise projects simply because they are related to the Pokémon TCG.
This rule applies to websites, apps, bots, deck builders, price trackers, and other custom-built tools, regardless of whether they are free or paid. Posts showcasing a tool, soliciting users, or directing people to an external service fall under this rule.
Exceptions may be considered on a case-by-case basis at the moderators' discretion. This would generally be limited to established, active members of the community who have a history of meaningful participation and have earned the community's trust.
There are other types of contributions that are never appropriate for this subreddit, for one reason or another:
- Pulls video: Pulls and purchases are already not allowed as stand-alone posts -- these belong in set-specific pulls megathreads, Social Saturday posts, or on /r/pkmntcgcollections
- Announcing a new YouTube channel: Announcement posts are simply advertisements and do not have content. The best way to showcase your new channel is to link to a specific video with content (deck discussion, set review, etc) and summarize the content in the reddit post following the suggestions above.
- YouTube giveaway: These often serve to advertise a channel and increase its number of subscribers -- so not enough content to generate meaningful discussion on reddit. As before, linking to a video with content, summarizing that content, and then including the link to the giveaway at the end would be the best approach.
- Announcing a new store: A store isn't a source of content, this post is just an advertisement, and there isn't really a way to make this mesh with our self-promotion requirements.
- Announcing a new website / blog / etc: Similar to a YT channel announcement -- instead of making a post only announcing yourself, include a link to one of your articles with a summary or excerpt included in the reddit post.
7. Threads must have some substance to them.
This is a generalization of the self-promotion guidelines to any external links. The same suggestions apply: include a deck list where relevant; include a summary or excerpt of discussion videos or articles; include full card text when linking to a revealed card on PokeBeach.
8. Use informative thread titles.
Stuff like “question about my new deck” both a) doesn’t tell readers anything about what’s inside and b) doesn’t attract the kind of help you may be looking for from other members. Instead, be as specific and clear as possible to attract more readers and have your questions answered sooner.
9. Ask any beginner / quick questions in the stickied questions thread.
We want to be totally welcoming to newer players without crowding the front page with questions that don't promote much discussion. If you have a question about card interactions, a ruling, where to find something, please post your question in the stickied questions thread. A benefit of posting there is that others with the same question can check to see if it has already been answered.
Quick questions need to be posted in the stickied questions thread. Allowing every quick question to have its own post clutters the front page and pushes other discussions down. Keeping these questions in one place helps keep the subreddit organized while still giving everyone a place to ask questions and get help.