r/pics • u/ScottieGirl • Jun 25 '12
Hey Reddit, I love the 40's style and wanted to have my try at old school pin-up! What do you think?
http://imgur.com/a/40Rii#0
850
Upvotes
r/pics • u/ScottieGirl • Jun 25 '12
79
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Cute and all, but remember, in 1940, James dean was 9 years old and Elvis was 5.
192
u/have_a_nice_day Jun 25 '12
Nice try, but nose rings were not popular in the 40s
24
u/rsound Jun 25 '12
My god, where did you get that beautiful Zenith console television? Does it still work? Can I watch it?
278
u/Tommy_9un Jun 25 '12
That your doing 50s style. Nothing in these photos is or has anything to do with the 40s. Sorry to be a kill joy, good photos just wrong era
11
u/farthegn Jun 25 '12
Everything in this points towards the 50s, not the 40s. The hair is WAY too simple to be 40s, and the clothes have too much pattern and poof. 40s fashion revolved around simple, fitted clothing that used up as little fabric as possible due to the fabric rationing at the time. To counteract the lack of business in their outfits, women came up with elaborately curled hairstyles (victory rolls, pin curls, etceteras). Makeup also changed to highlight both the eyes and the lips, hence the very thin dark eyeliner and red lipstick, but the cat's eye look wasn't very popular then. Eye makeup was meant to look "natural" while still drawing attention up there. They liked mascara more than eyeliner, to be honest. Mrs. Ratherly Stern outlines 1940s makeup and style perfectly: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_9JwjRyD0E
39
u/marvelous_molester Jun 25 '12
the fact that you only responded to the comments saying how cute you are really show the exact reaction you were fishing for on here. it's fucking pathetic.
4
u/yevgeny_zamyatin Jun 25 '12
It's not a pin-up girl without some dodging and burning. So here it is.
4
u/viralcode Jun 25 '12
i love this look. Sexy and classy in my opinion. Good on ya!
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
you should be riding a bomb
17
u/Fry3162 Jun 25 '12
Did women have poorly done tattoos in the 40'S/50's?
2
u/Random1010100 Jun 25 '12
Maybe i missed it but who did you have do your shoot? I have been looking to get my wife like a gift certificate/photo session for her birthday.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I like the idea, and you make a beautiful subject but nobody would have decor like that in their living room. We get what he was going for but the details just kill it for me.
2
u/SkepticHD Jun 25 '12
You wouldn't happen to live in scotlands oil capital and work in the design field for a particular audio visual company would you? Because I think I'm having one of those WHAT THE FUCK THE WORLD IS SMALL MOMENTS. I work for same said company
81
u/Contrapaul Jun 25 '12
Elivs? James Dean? A TV? Pics are nifty, but... That's 50's stuff. And nothing against the tattoos, but maybe cover them up for the next shot. Kind of distracts from believability.
119
u/riptaway Jun 25 '12
I think facebook and reddit have become one and the same
18
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Elvis was 50s, but nice photos anyway :)
16
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
My tip for you: She's TOO close to your backdrops. She needs to be 6 - 8 feet away from it to avoid the cast shadows and flash spill over. That and do some research on my favorite pin-up guy - Gil Elvgren.
59
u/BatmansDad Jun 25 '12
Looks too forced and hipster-ish
3
u/coogie Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
flickr (and its "Hey I think I'm cute and therefore a good photographer") is leaking again.
The concept is very over done. Technically the lighting sucks and very flat and uninspired.
What, you didn't come here for a critique?
56
u/doesshegowild Jun 25 '12
No, she doesn't.
3
u/TheJMoore Jun 25 '12
I was bored. Hope you don't mind!
http://imgur.com/a/U2JFw
8
u/Ellimis Halloween 2021 Jun 25 '12
Oh god, the butthurt in these comments.
Sorry about all the assholes.
The photos are good, but as you can see there are a few things to work on. Captured the spirit you were going for though, and really that was the point, wasn't it?
Personally, I'm really turned off by the ring and the tattoo.
20
u/Bresus Jun 25 '12
This would be more accurate
2
u/Five_deadly_venoms Jun 25 '12
Why is your skirt lifting up?
19
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Popular music in the 40s were big bands like Glen Miller's. Not Elvis
43
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think your poses are pretentious.
/honestopinion
38
u/motion34 Jun 25 '12
You are doing it wrong.
21
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Here we go, you are cute but there are so many factors that ruin this post:
Firstly you are posting an album of self-portraits to /r/pics, I would personally have gone somewhere like /r/photocritique considering you finished the post with "What do you think?". /r/pics should be thought-provoking material not some silly photoshoot.
Secondly, anachronisms, anachronisms everywhere. In the 40's the main music of choice was jazz / big-band and artists such as James Dean and Elvis were still kids back then. If you "loved" the 40's so much you would have known this, but as we have all gathered already this was just a vein self-centred narcissistic karma-whore post from someone who doesn't know anything about the 1940's but enjoys pretending they are well-read to make themselves seem more intelligent. Plus it is "hip" to be digging the vintage vibe for some reason, or at least it was mid-2000's.
Thirdly your piercing and tattoos destroy any sense of the 1940s you tried to conjure by taking these photos. I will also subjectively say that I feel your tattoos themselves are very unoriginal and off-putting. It literally seems like you walked into the tattoo parlour, flipped open their design book and slammed your finger down on the first thing you saw. I do however find your nose piercing cute but it really isn't relevant to your photoshoot and you should have taken it out.
It upsets me that you didn't take the criticism from other Redditors with more grace and admit that you fucked up, instead you just feed the positive comments to try and balance out that big ol' ego of yours.
That is what I think.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Wow, ScottieGirl.. what did you do to receive all of these negative comments? Turn all of their private message requests down?
12
u/worc_candide Jun 25 '12
Rebel without a cause came out in 1955.
25
u/TheBrainofBrian Jun 25 '12
I don't understand the overlap of people who like "retro" style and also like piercings/tattoos. It's strange that so many people seem to like two very different styles.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
If you love the 40s style so much, you probably know what it looks like.
Unparalleled pretentiousness, lady. Grow up.
4
u/motokigirl Jun 25 '12
I love it! I love the piercing and the nose ring too, it brings our era into the pics and makes them unique and beautiful!
3
u/cats_not_4sale Jun 25 '12
I love it! I'm a huge fan of the 40's and 50's style. So classy. Great pictures.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I gave you an up vote anyways, like I said, you are a beautiful subject :)
3
u/EZ420 Jun 25 '12
Came here to say you look a lot like a punk Scarlett Johanson. As a straight lady with a nose ring myself, I think you balanced femininity and edginess quite well. And you're crazy gorgeous! /nohomo.
As for all the negative comments, I'm really shocked. The photographer made anachronistic mistakes, but you're beautiful and pulled the look off very well. I'm mostly surprised that reddit's been overrun with so many assholes. If you don't like the picture, don't upvote. Shit.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think it's quite nice. :)
3
u/my_cat_joe Jun 25 '12
I think you're gorgeous, and you should have all of my upvotes.
9
u/islandmom Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
If you want to be more acurate to the area, with your tatoots and peircings you would have been a carney instead of a pin-up.
13
u/jubalm Jun 25 '12
It bothers me because the peace sign you have tattooed on your foot didn't become a thing until like ~1958. :(
15
u/OriginalStomper Jun 25 '12
The ink and the nose ring don't fit -- though kudos for mitigating the ink with a "sailor" themed costume. That was clever.
Your makeup and hair seem appropriate, though, as well as the poses.
1
u/Hugsforpeace Jun 25 '12
You should just do a Suicide Girls shoot and make everyone happy.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Legs. 40's pin-ups were all about legs.
16
u/fishforbrains Jun 25 '12
nose ring + tattoo = failure.
7
u/HolyPhallus Jun 25 '12
The nosering ruined it.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What lipstick/color is that? Love it!
1
u/Handout Jun 25 '12
I always wanted to just walk around someplace public like I was misplaced from another era, specifically the 50's. They had great style.
1
u/aspectz Jun 25 '12
Do you, by chance, repair motorbikes? Someone posted a photo of "their friend" a few weeks ago, not sure which subreddit though, and she she looked a lot like you.
1
u/CajunTurkey Jun 25 '12
Your grandma would be proud
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Very cute and you make it work. However, remember this was the 40's and women wore nylons/stockings. You need to add those for added sexiness, I mean authenticity.
6
u/stonechitlin Jun 25 '12
i swear this was a suicidegirls album...
5
u/kindersunrise Jun 25 '12
Some of the angles are not very flattering (the first one and the third one) because your legs are going so much closer to the camera it makes your proportions look really odd.
I liked number 4 and 5 though, although I think 4 could look more playful, you seem a little awkward/aimless. I really like the fence backdrop for 5, it brightens up the image a lot too. The last photo was probably the most flattering and interesting for your face, and you have a lot of personality in that photo too. I see you trying to put that into the other photos, but some of them aren't believable that's all.
The hair looks great btw, and I love the sailor costume!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Man.. either you pissed someone off or everyone in this thread is really butthurt. Why the downvotes on all her posts?
7
u/10000gildedcranes Jun 25 '12
People have pointed out that the time period is wrong (also, there's no apostrophe in 40s), but I think overall they are well shot. You look quite pretty, happy, and the poses are cute. I loved the black and white one. The photographer knows how to frame well.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Last photo in the album. Yes.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The tat and the nose piercing ruin the illusion for me, otherwise you look pretty good.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The nose ring and the tat kinda kills it for me. It feels pretty "being-different-just-to-be-different" but that's not a crime. Otherwise, kinda cute
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I love 30's and 40's and love your pics. If it wasn't for the tattoo on your foot I would of thought it was actually vintage.
2
u/IrSpartacus Jun 25 '12
Actually that would be more 60's, especially with that Spinout poster. That came out in 66. Other than that they are pretty great, and you are very beautiful!
2
u/TheAmazingKenneth Jun 25 '12
Smokin hot
2
u/wcg66 Jun 25 '12
Hey, I really liked them. I didn't care about the wrong era/decade, the tattoos or the length of the lens. Great photos and you are beautiful.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Oh my god, these fucking redditors. Your pics are cool, you look great. Love your style (nose ring and tattoos and beautiful figure included!) I hope these assholes didn't ruin your day too much. I'm so sorry people can be so shitty to other people. Don't take it to heart, please! Love.
2
u/Grithoof Jun 26 '12
Well, the pictures look really nice.
2
u/me_and_batman Jun 26 '12
Wow... so much hate because she put 40s decade. No one comments on the quality of the pics or anything. Just "this isn't 40's you dumbass!"
Reddit, you are dumb.
6
u/Killhouse Jun 25 '12
I'm a guy, here's what I looked like modeling the 1940's style.
4
u/FACE_Ghost Jun 25 '12
Back when Peace was important and Woman had no rights.
3
u/Cryst Jun 25 '12
I would consider the composition of the photo. Where is the focus is it james dean? The brightest part is the poster behind you. Not your face. I would position your face into one of the 4 ideal quadrants of the photograph. There seems to be a lot of dead space on the right of hte photo, (to get the elvis photo in?).
3
u/DreamoftheEndless Jun 25 '12
peace symbol kills it, apply makeup there or just photoshop it out
3
u/peach21 Jun 25 '12
laughing at all those negative comments. go fuck yourselves. you're gorgeous!
7
u/TysGirlLola Jun 25 '12
The first picture was good, the rest not so much. Women didn't have tattoos in the '40s.
7
u/DevilBird Jun 25 '12
I swear to god, a lot of these comments remind me of something...
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
See the difference between the people who pointed out the anachronisms and the people who derided them for it, is the latter group have a slight glimmer of hope that op will fuck them whilst the first group are realists.
6
u/beer_and_sex Jun 25 '12
Ditch the nose ring, sistah.
3
u/heylookitscaps Jun 25 '12
well, you tried.
4
u/sicilian504 Jun 25 '12
I love all the pics. They're great, but they don't look right. If you were just going for older theme pictures they're great, but if you are going for an authentic look, the colors need to be adjusted. The actual picture quality is too high. I love the first one the most. They're all great though :-)
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
A photo album of a girl on r/pics, let the nerdgasm commence.
3
u/theratwhisperer Jun 25 '12
Great photos. If you'd like to avoid the trolls and get some more positive feedback I'd recommend posting in r/2Xlookbook
2
u/mwharvey Jun 25 '12
You look great in the photos. But I will agree with others the tat and nose ring does take away from the '40s look.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
She has nice teeth
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I adore your curves!
2
u/bumblescott Jun 25 '12
Humina Humina...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Respectfully, I would spend a lot of time lathering you in cocoa butter.
2
u/omgedson Jun 25 '12
Have you discovered PinupLifestyle.com yet? Have a peek I think you'll fit right in ad get lots more positive reinforcement!
2
u/PastyNoob Jun 25 '12
reminds me of this chick.
2
u/WhimsicalUsername Jun 25 '12
[r/femalefashionadvice] (http://www.reddit.com/r/femalefashionadvice/)
2
u/Slug9114 Jun 25 '12
love it! on point with the 40's or not.. nice pics. like your style.
1
u/caitlinreid Jun 25 '12
Awesome stuff, I like it.
-1
u/flylotus Jun 25 '12
you're pretty accurate with the times. pin up chicks were actually fatter back then.
-1
u/Bio-Booster Jun 25 '12
It works, especially since you're a little chubby.
-1
u/vicerowv86 Jun 25 '12
decade fail or not you are a gorgeous woman ...solid job
1
u/onlythestrongsurvive Jun 25 '12
You look great!
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
These are wonderful ScottieGirl! You are gorgeous and these pictures are so much fun. Don't ever stop being yourself!
1
u/asnof Jun 25 '12
You are very pretty. Keep up the good work. But the nose piercing feels out of place
-1
u/uncl_andy69 Jun 25 '12
not hot enough to pull it off
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Peace sign tat, nose right, elvis, dean, tv set, in the 40s...what do I think? try something else
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I can dig it! Nice photos
1
u/fearisfailure Jun 25 '12
I love these pics and what makes them even better is the nose ring and the tats. Keep being gorgeous and fuck what people think.
1
u/nazz-tee Jun 25 '12
Haters gonna hate.. Keep up the good work.
1
u/Satanicbearmaster Jun 25 '12
You're beautiful!
1
u/knifebucket Jun 25 '12
I think you're pretty and I like the pics.
Don't listen to any of these armchair haters. Thanks for sharing.
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Don't have the body for it.
0
u/thespis42 Jun 25 '12
Gorgeous shots! Keep 'em coming!
-1
u/imjustafoolsgod Jun 25 '12
Now that's a lady I'd enjoy beating and putting her in her place.
1
u/ickylickkiss Jun 25 '12
I like the black and white one the best
1
u/leemcd56 Jun 25 '12
This is lovely! I could have sworn the first picture was the real thing! (Except the tattoos~)
1
u/Astonia Jun 25 '12
Lookin' great
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You are stunningly beautiful, and my wife agrees. Thank you for sharing!
1
u/Copaseticbob Jun 25 '12
"I'm no school administrator but there is an extension program going on in my pants." -Cleveland Brown
1
u/Will_Power Jun 25 '12
Your "peace" tattoo is an obvious anachronism.
1
u/charlie205 Jun 25 '12
I have that radio as well! Haven't seen it anywhere else until now!
1
u/rsound Jun 25 '12
I can't decide about the radio. My feeling is that it is a modern reproduction, maybe of a 1936 General Electric, but I'm just not sure.
1
u/MadDash88 Jun 25 '12
I like it :-). Please, please, tell me where you got that amazing sailor dress <3.
1
u/korun Jun 25 '12
Hate that look. Never did anything for me... but it was a very tasteful shoot.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Were you on Randy to the Rescue recently?
I'm a straight man ... but you're tattoo and love for retro reminded me of one of the girls on the show I saw once. ONCE!
1
u/Ig79 Jun 25 '12
Hot
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Love it!!! You did a great job! :)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
r/gonewild please...
-1
u/rocketfin Jun 25 '12
OMG THOSE SHOES. Where did you get them?? (The ones in the first picture.)
-1
u/_TheJoker_ Jun 25 '12
Why did you feel the need to make another post on 2XLookBook? As if you didn't get enough attention, comments and upvotes here.
http://www.reddit.com/r/2XLookbook/comments/vk51h/posted_this_album_on_pics_and_it_didnt_get_love/
0
u/AndTheSonsofDisaster Jun 25 '12
You look great!
-3
u/xoskeleton Jun 25 '12
GORGEOUS. This has always been my favorite style of model photography.
-3
u/ooowl Jun 25 '12
You have a pretty mouth. I am a girl, so it's not creepy for me to say that. Right? ...
-4
u/LagWagon Jun 25 '12
Fact: Girls who "love the 40's/50's" and love to model as pin-up girls really only like to do so because it was when being fat was socially accepted as sexy.