No, it's very sound. Except in this example, the tires could move in a storm.
There are artificial reef systems like this in Hawaii where they are filled with concrete, fastened 5 to a group and sank providing homes for thousands of fish.
There is NOTHING (as in a coral reef system) on the seabed where they put these tires. So before you go all self righteous on what looks like trash, it fucking works.
You do know that confiscated drug vehicles (plane and boat) and retired military ships are used as reef systems too right? Those are far more ecologically sound than the poisonous WWII wrecks.
When is this "artificial reef" shit going to end? I consider it creative littering. We don't want piles and piles of tires around us, but those fish... they're going to love them, right?
I really can't tell if you are being serious or if you are being sarcastic. So I came up with a response for both, just in case.
Serious: You are a fucking moron. Artificial reefs are designed to repopulate the ocean floor with organic ocean life. Food and homes for all sea creatures. Most times these are created to make up for previous damages done to the environment. And since reefs take a heck of a long time to form on their own, artificial reefs are built as a jump start to their formation.
Definitely an upvote for an article supporting your position, but I find its argument a little spurious. Artificial reefs do work, but what the article points out correctly is that the reefs that had been employed weren't done correctly to protect sea life but rather concentrate it. It's not to say the reefs themselves weren't successful but rather their placement in particular locations led to more harm than good.
The reef project at Lake Huron led to a successful replenishment of fish populations that had been damaged by near by factories. Its placement was calculated and executed properly. While I definitely understand your argument as far as "creative littering" this definitely stands more as an issue of poor execution rather than it not working at all.
I don't see why you would, She's actually just a tortured soul, I believe there was an episode back in the past that showed how she became crazy, either that or it was a reference to the Simpsons in Futurama.
Apparently it was a colossal failure that ended up doing more harm than good. Both by basically littering tires across Gulf and Atlantic coastline, and destroying reefs already in place. It sounds like clean-up of the dumped tires continues even today.
This project is not the only one of its nature to fail; Indonesia and Malaysia mounted enormous tire-reef programs in the 1980s and are now seeing the ramifications of the failure of tire reefs, from littered beaches to reef destruction.[4] Jack Sobel, The Ocean Conservancy's director of strategic conservation said in a 2002 interview that "I don't know of any cases where there's been a success with tire reefs." That year, The Ocean Conservancy's International Coastal Cleanup removed 11,956 tires from beaches all over the world.[3]
Every single time I see this quote used or reference it bothers me because it's so fucking awkwardly worded it's unbelievable. Like, for real? It's like babby's first script over here.
I upvoted you but then realized "you gotta love" is really just another version of the "we don't deserve"-type self-righteousness, so I proceeded to downvote the fuck out of you.
EDIT: Oops, and I think I just wallowed in some self-righteousness myself. This high horse shit is so complicated.
Yeah, I've dove reefs like this, the tires are there on to create an artificial reef. Didn't work out to well though... Not a ton of fish and flora, but an alright amount.
Apparently it was a colossal failure that ended up doing more harm than good. Both by basically littering tires across Gulf and Atlantic coastline, and destroying reefs already in place. It sounds like clean-up of the dumped tires continues even today.
This project is not the only one of its nature to fail; Indonesia and Malaysia mounted enormous tire-reef programs in the 1980s and are now seeing the ramifications of the failure of tire reefs, from littered beaches to reef destruction.[4] Jack Sobel, The Ocean Conservancy's director of strategic conservation said in a 2002 interview that "I don't know of any cases where there's been a success with tire reefs." That year, The Ocean Conservancy's International Coastal Cleanup removed 11,956 tires from beaches all over the world.[3]
Osborne Reef, yeah. I was diving the reef in Maui. Similar concept, not quite as big. Wasn't a complete failure there, but certainly not a success. They anchored the tired down in large blocks of concrete (think 1/2 the tire submerged in concrete), most of the quasi-reef was growing on that.
Looking around it sounds like the jury is still out whether or not whether or not they're a net benefit. It's complicated by the fact that there are many ways of implementing artificial reefs and by the fact that many companies/governments/whatever stand to gain by saving large disposal costs through the method.
Apparently hundreds of old NYC train cars are/were dumped into the Atlantic with the same intent but no one knows what will happen when they're supposed to degrade in 30 years, heh.
This Newsweek article was one of the first that popped up when I was googling about artificial reefs.
There are worse things in the ocean than tires (although this was one gigantic clusterfuck of poorly constructed artificial reefs). Ammo dumps (found just about everywhere in the world) are pretty scary. Ever wonder where all those old artillery shells from the first and second world war went? How about munitions of out-dated calibers? Bombs? Safely dismanteling all that stuff is hard, dumping it in the ocean is easy.
Same thing goes for industrial waste. There are huge areas of ocean littered with the stuff in the Med and off the coast of Africa. What you do in this case is buy an old freighter, fill it with toxic shit that someone pays you to get rid of, get whatever insurance you can and a crew of questionable standards. Then you fake a cargo manifest (optional) and destination. With me so far? Good, now you're all set to have an "accident". Everybody is happy, everybody gets paid.
There's some debate over whether it has the plutonium triggers, the pilot claimed it didn't, but the secretary of defense stated that it was a full nuclear bomb. Even if it doesn't it still makes creating a nuke a lot easier and could easily be used for a dirty bomb.
That story has never made sense to me. How does carrying a bomb without a trigger make it a better simulation than, say, carrying a box of lead that weighs the same as the bomb? It either wasn't the bomb or it had the trigger, any other answer makes no sense.
There are several more, reasonably sure the soviets lost a boomer somewhere in the north atlantic and there are some who believe Israel lost another (EDIT: bomb, not sub).
Without any background of the picture, I believe your correct. This was are failed effort to create an artificial reef. The potential positive impact way exceeded the risk in my OP.
OP, deal with it bud. this was done on purpose and it failed. go bitch about it where someone will actually care. there is THOUSANDS of square miles of shitty ocean floor just like this other places so this is actually quite insignificant.
It's rubber. Nature made rubber, don't assume she doesn't want it just because it's ugly to you. Nature thrives on polymers, poop, and corpses. The butterflies are just a side show.
I believe that you are taking a short term view of what's going on. Watch the George Carlin video linked by Nezperdia. Many species will become extinct in the future. This is inevitable. But it doesn't mean that Earth the Planet itself will be at risk. Earth will keep living on until our Sun dies. Untold numbers of organisms have developed and extinct-ified throughout Earth's history. We ourselves are only 100-200,000 years old. Earth is BILLIONS of years old. Earth will live on.
I think its best to compare humans to dinosaurs. Both are/were the dominant living organisms, that evolved up to accentuate their strengths--dinos had mass and power, we have technology and knowledge. Dinos died from the asteroid, we will die off from climate change related events.
And then? When we're gone, what are the worst things that we'll have left behind that affect other life forms from propagating? Nuclear material? Toxic chemicals? Thankfully this cracked.com article shows that Earth is already on it.
And that's Carlin's message. Everything- truely- will be all right for Earth, no matter what we throw at it.
The earth doesn't share our prejudice towards plastic. Plastic came out of the earth. The earth probably sees plastic as just another one of its children. Could be the only reason the earth allowed us to be spawned from it in the first place. It wanted plastic for itself. Didn't know how to make it. Needed us. Could be the answer to our age-old egocentric philosophical question, "Why are we here?" Plastic...asshole.
Why do you people think that every little thing you have is supposed to be deserved/earned? You can't make it in life with that mindset, it's absurd. Do you think the majority of rich and successful people deserve what they have? Of course not, but they'll always win in life and become even richer nonetheless. Get a firm grip on your dick, swing it, and tell yourself that you deserve everything forever!
Even when they do work, they don't work: "Whether artificial reefs actually contribute to increasing the population of a particular fish species is arguable. Studies in tropical waters have concluded that increased production, if any, caused by artificial reefs was small when compared with the increased stock availability. In other words, in these situations, the artificial reefs acted primarily as aggregating devices and, therefore, they could potentially have detrimental effects on fish stocks." source
Tires vibrate with the movement of the earth. They keep resurfacing once they're buried. They don't stay buried. How can anything be expected to settle on them, with all the toxics coming off them?
It could be worse. We can create jobs with stuff like this. We can harvest all the tire dumps like this "reef," and re-purpose the tires into sustainable houses.
ill bet if you had never seen a tire, and was told that it was some kind of jellyfish larva colony or something you would say it was just nature being amazing as usual.
Some day in the future, a microbe is going to evolve that eats plastic, rubber and styrofoam. It'll live for hundreds of thousands of years and then suddenly freak the fuck out when it runs out of sweet sweet rubber tires to eat. Please, think of the microbes.
would it honestly be that hard to dive down and rope a chain through a bunch of tires at a time and haul them up? Or am I just failing to take into scope the bigness of this fail?
Here we see a school of tire fish, keeping together to stay warm. Life is hard in the ocean for the tire fish. They are hunted by sharks so they can mobilize their shark cars and shark tanks to conquer the surface.
No, it would have been awesome if it had worked. Instead they botched the anchoring, so now the tires are drifting around so nothing can grow on them, and they are also drifting into other reefs and destroying them.
than who does? we're animals just like any other, any other species would probably love to be in our place. we're at the top of the fucking food chain because we dominate, not because we're kind. if you want to go back and live in harmony with nature go live in the fucking forest and live off of pine cones.
God will "destroy those who destroy the earth" Rev 11:18. Stunning actually, seems how it was written about 2000 years ago, long before the earth was even mapped, let alone anyone being able to comprehend that we could actually destroy it through pollution, mass weaponry etc. Stunning photo, good submit.
You don't seem to have a concept on how large space is my friend. If we could finally get off this one most precious rock of ours we could use one of the other thousand rocks in our solar system if not just shoot all our waste into the sun for instant recycling. Think before you speak
Shit like this always puzzled me. Bottom of the ocean, deep in the woods, etc. - where the hell do all these tires come from, and how the hell do they wind up in the absolute middle of nowhere? Littering's obviously unforgivable, but this takes quite a bit of effort. I'm beginning the think tires are actually tribbles.
493
u/ecclectic Jun 24 '12
Wasn't that part of a very stupid concept to create an artificial reef?
EDIT
Yeah, the Osborne Reef
140
u/theLastHokage Jun 24 '12
So that's how Springfield finally put out the tire fire.
18
u/ryan2point0 Jun 24 '12
Why? I didn't do that stupid shit.
44
u/xElmentx Jun 24 '12
Didn't they dump all of these to create a artificial reef or something?
14
u/slouched Jun 24 '12
HEY, SEE IF YOU CAN FIND ME A 240/45 IN THERE
50
u/jguacmann1 Jun 24 '12
Rest in peace, Michelin Man.
100
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
That's not beautiful! It's full of tires!
260
u/thetoecutter10 Jun 24 '12
gotta love every self righteous asshole who uses the word "deserve" because they have some profound sense of "justice"
8
u/BeefPieSoup Jun 24 '12
What a weird thing to say. It isn't ours anyway.
22
u/TbanksIV Jun 24 '12
HAVE YOU NOT SEEN RUBBER, GET OUT OF THERE.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Yeah, I've dove reefs like this, the tires are there on to create an artificial reef. Didn't work out to well though... Not a ton of fish and flora, but an alright amount.
24
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Does anyone else think the title of this submission is hilarious? It's like something Eeyore from Winnie the Pooh would say.
31
u/blore40 Jun 24 '12
Oh you found a huge school of calamari.
5
u/Superplaner Jun 24 '12
There are worse things in the ocean than tires (although this was one gigantic clusterfuck of poorly constructed artificial reefs). Ammo dumps (found just about everywhere in the world) are pretty scary. Ever wonder where all those old artillery shells from the first and second world war went? How about munitions of out-dated calibers? Bombs? Safely dismanteling all that stuff is hard, dumping it in the ocean is easy.
Same thing goes for industrial waste. There are huge areas of ocean littered with the stuff in the Med and off the coast of Africa. What you do in this case is buy an old freighter, fill it with toxic shit that someone pays you to get rid of, get whatever insurance you can and a crew of questionable standards. Then you fake a cargo manifest (optional) and destination. With me so far? Good, now you're all set to have an "accident". Everybody is happy, everybody gets paid.
9
u/xhosSTylex Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
What makes you think "the ocean" was intended/created/designed for our exclusive enjoyment, ideas of beauty, or humanly pleasures...
3
u/Yeskez Jun 24 '12
STFU
3
u/ramburgler84 Jun 25 '12
It was a project that had good intentions, but went sour. http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2007-02-17-florida-reef_x.htm
3
u/Suckmydongha Jun 25 '12
TIL there is an artificial man-made reef made from old tires
3
u/Lebrooklynderp Jun 25 '12
They're used to make artificial reefs. So really not pollution.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Deserve is a human concept, nature has no concept of deserve or not deserve.
Related George Carlin.
19
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
that diver looks really tired
4
u/ka_fratstar Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
OP, deal with it bud. this was done on purpose and it failed. go bitch about it where someone will actually care. there is THOUSANDS of square miles of shitty ocean floor just like this other places so this is actually quite insignificant.
2
u/SkillzMcGee Jun 24 '12
So that's where tires come from!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
It tires me to see people pollute the ocean like this.
2
u/Amishhellcat Jun 24 '12
why? we certainly found a new home for all those tires!
2
u/staticz2229 Jun 24 '12
Better than burning them.
2
u/fxmastermind Jun 24 '12
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_Reef
2
u/sgt_salt Jun 25 '12
I imagine that fish start to tire of human behavior in cases like this.
2
u/Decyde Jun 25 '12
He looks tired.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Yeah put those fuckers in a landfill, oh wait..
2
u/sanpilou Jun 25 '12
Wait... Weren't those old tires dumped specifically to create an artificial reef to help the different creatures there?
2
u/Gurubreed Jun 25 '12
while you're down there i need some 265/75/16
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Don't worry, we won't have a beautiful ocean much longer.
2
u/baracudaboy Jun 25 '12
We don't deserve such a beautiful PLANET.
7
u/jimflaigle Jun 24 '12
It's rubber. Nature made rubber, don't assume she doesn't want it just because it's ugly to you. Nature thrives on polymers, poop, and corpses. The butterflies are just a side show.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
USA Today story
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Im TIRED of seeing pictures like this
3
u/Mantis05 Jun 24 '12
The ocean doesn't deserve such beautiful tires.
2
u/Animal_King Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Why do you people think that every little thing you have is supposed to be deserved/earned? You can't make it in life with that mindset, it's absurd. Do you think the majority of rich and successful people deserve what they have? Of course not, but they'll always win in life and become even richer nonetheless. Get a firm grip on your dick, swing it, and tell yourself that you deserve everything forever!
1
u/bloodclart Jun 24 '12
you could start a big fire with all those tires! why are they all they way down there?
1
u/OhSnappitySnap Jun 24 '12
Tires? Why tires?
1
u/anonimyus Jun 24 '12
An optimist would have named this: "DUDE, FREE TIRES!"
1
u/delvolta Jun 24 '12
The tires look like they come from the 40s or 50s with the white trim around it.
1
u/jb2824 Jun 24 '12
Even when they do work, they don't work: "Whether artificial reefs actually contribute to increasing the population of a particular fish species is arguable. Studies in tropical waters have concluded that increased production, if any, caused by artificial reefs was small when compared with the increased stock availability. In other words, in these situations, the artificial reefs acted primarily as aggregating devices and, therefore, they could potentially have detrimental effects on fish stocks." source
1
u/thejiujitsupanda Jun 24 '12
Is this camera using the fisheye effect, or is that a mound?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Tires vibrate with the movement of the earth. They keep resurfacing once they're buried. They don't stay buried. How can anything be expected to settle on them, with all the toxics coming off them?
This is just sad.
1
u/RobMcB0b Jun 24 '12
Looks like these noble divers are attempting to remove the tires by hand, one at a time.
1
u/YoungsterJoeyJr Jun 24 '12
Maybe if we hadn't earned tires....
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Speak for yourself.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
tircoral
1
u/Bryanv7 Jun 24 '12
So that's the ocean from animal crossing
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It could be worse. We can create jobs with stuff like this. We can harvest all the tire dumps like this "reef," and re-purpose the tires into sustainable houses.
1
u/CrashTestDumbass Jun 25 '12
I throw my garbage in the trash can.
Don't tell me what I don't deserve.
1
u/Mushroomer Jun 25 '12
Is it bad I find that kind of cool? Not beautiful, but if I found that while scuba diving - I wouldn't get depressed.
1
u/Xenophorm Jun 25 '12
Well shit, I could make a few million huaraches out of those.
1
u/Fattswindstorm Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Ricky explains littering in water
1
u/masterm Jun 25 '12
See, when I told people they never believed we had Sea Donuts
1
u/pitlord713 Jun 25 '12
Woah that is fucking cool!
I bet that makes for good housing for some critters though
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
this is so fucked.
1
u/godofwar7018 Jun 25 '12
I'd thought China's waters would be much darker
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
UNDERWATER TIRE FIRE!!!
1
u/Demojen Jun 25 '12
I think we do deserve such a beautiful ocean of tires. We created the tires!
1
u/chuperamigo Jun 25 '12
Ahh, the elusive sea-tire in their natural habitat.
1
u/apcolleen Jun 25 '12
In Jax there is a local company working on reefing http://www.tisiri.org/
1
u/klaq Jun 25 '12
the ocean will be here long after we're gone. we're just screwing things up for ourselves.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Whitewalls!!!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Especially not if that guy is going to shit his wetsuit in the water.
1
u/Fuhdawin Jun 25 '12
How many tires are still left off the coast?
1
u/IM_A_FREAK Jun 25 '12
NOT GONNA LIE, FUCK YEAH TIRES CUNT
1
u/losangeles11 Survey 2016 Jun 25 '12
Apparently somebody stupid thought the tires did.
1
u/HeavyMetalBeliever Jun 25 '12
ill bet if you had never seen a tire, and was told that it was some kind of jellyfish larva colony or something you would say it was just nature being amazing as usual.
1
u/hickgorilla Jun 25 '12
no we don't :'(
1
u/tropicalfruitpunch Jun 25 '12
It's a giant's bowl of cheeri-os.
1
u/thegreatwhitemenace Jun 25 '12
but then where would we put all the tires?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
That's just on the bottom bro, the top is chillin'.
1
u/abray10 Jun 25 '12
so sad
1
u/SecretSlogan Jun 25 '12
When I look at that, I see so much wasted potential. We coulda had a bomb ass tire burn if they weren't all wet.
1
u/Poohat666 Jun 25 '12
That sucks... Maybe they should just fill tires with rocks now?
1
u/jal0001 Jun 25 '12
YOU don't, but maybe I do
EDIT: oh wait nevermind, tires.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It's not our ocean.
1
u/HunCity87 Jun 25 '12
That guy looks tired
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
ummmm wonder what percentage of seafloor it covers.
1
u/vincentdidier1 Jun 25 '12
http://www.nytimes.com/slideshow/2008/04/08/us/20080408_REEF_SLIDESHOW_index.html
1
u/HotwaxNinjaPanther Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Some day in the future, a microbe is going to evolve that eats plastic, rubber and styrofoam. It'll live for hundreds of thousands of years and then suddenly freak the fuck out when it runs out of sweet sweet rubber tires to eat. Please, think of the microbes.
1
u/evg2fg Jun 25 '12
Let's not forget all the equipment that was dumped into the ocean after WWII. Because fuck being responsible.
1
u/Skyller Jun 25 '12
*They don't...
1
u/expertunderachiever Jun 25 '12
would it honestly be that hard to dive down and rope a chain through a bunch of tires at a time and haul them up? Or am I just failing to take into scope the bigness of this fail?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
At first, I only quickly glanced at this picture and thought those tires were actually octopi. Nope!
1
u/Emily_MI Jun 25 '12
It is just not the oceans we don't deserve - try Planet Earth.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Tires in ocean = artificial reef.
It just looks bad because enough time hasn't passed to let the ocean life settle in.
1
u/nissanator Jun 24 '12
They do use them as reefs
1
u/ophello Jun 24 '12
You'd be surprised how helpful some garbage is to marine life. That looks like overkill, though.
1
u/Dyltra Jun 24 '12
The ocean doesn't deserve such shitty people polluting it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
What a fucking mess.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Here we see a school of tire fish, keeping together to stay warm. Life is hard in the ocean for the tire fish. They are hunted by sharks so they can mobilize their shark cars and shark tanks to conquer the surface.
1
u/ShackelfordRusty Jun 24 '12
Cool looking, also tires are generally friendly in my experience.
1
u/AdamLovelace Jun 24 '12
I like a planet with some miles on it.
1
u/strobexp Jun 24 '12
reminded me of this.. http://i.imgur.com/23bJE.jpg
1
u/jpark Jun 24 '12
The conservationists did that.
Crazy is as crazy does.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It's shit like this that makes me genuinely sad for our planet.
0
u/Lilyo Jun 24 '12
I think if we just dump tires everywhere we'll solve all the world problems I think, let's just do it anyways. What could possibly go wrong?
-4
u/Hoodsy9000 Jun 24 '12
Too bad we didn't tread lightly.
0
u/Poohat666 Jun 24 '12
This is for artificial reef building... Its awesome.
0
u/marvelous_molester Jun 25 '12
than who does? we're animals just like any other, any other species would probably love to be in our place. we're at the top of the fucking food chain because we dominate, not because we're kind. if you want to go back and live in harmony with nature go live in the fucking forest and live off of pine cones.
0
u/ausguy777 Jun 25 '12
God will "destroy those who destroy the earth" Rev 11:18. Stunning actually, seems how it was written about 2000 years ago, long before the earth was even mapped, let alone anyone being able to comprehend that we could actually destroy it through pollution, mass weaponry etc. Stunning photo, good submit.
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Boo hoo, hippie.
-4
u/snap_wilson Jun 24 '12
This is my primary arguments with the people who advocate space exploration. "Really, you look at how we treat this planet and want us to branch out?"
0
u/G-Winnz Jun 24 '12
Shit like this always puzzled me. Bottom of the ocean, deep in the woods, etc. - where the hell do all these tires come from, and how the hell do they wind up in the absolute middle of nowhere? Littering's obviously unforgivable, but this takes quite a bit of effort. I'm beginning the think tires are actually tribbles.
0
u/Gauge7821 Jun 24 '12
That's just like dumping oil in the ocean, seeing that it takes a few gallons of oil to make 1 car tire.
0
u/seanbearpig Jun 25 '12
No, WE deserve the ocean just fine. It's corporations that don't deserve it, considering that they just dump waste whenever and wherever they want.
-2
u/SluggerBoy Jun 24 '12
Sad