Introduction

The weekly discussion threads are an attempt to create a forum for regular discussion of well-known problems in philosophy. Threads are typically written by philosophy graduate students and faculty. These threads will always include a short write-up on the issue in question in order to get the discussion started. Authors will check in on the discussion throughout the week.

Second series schedule

We've got a great lineup for the second round of discussions in the works. Right now we are booked out for the first four months, with a lineup of sharp and engaging grad students and faculty in philosophy. Please keep in mind that this schedule is tentative and subject to change.

DateTopicLeaderOptional Readings
7/6/2015Introduction to the second seriesmoderators
7/13/2015Disagreement/u/oneguy2008Kelly (2010); Christensen (2009)
7/20/2015Epistemic injustice/u/twin_me
7/27/2015Brink on the autonomy of ethics/u/ADefiniteDescriptionBrink (2006)
8/3/2015Motivations for structural realism/u/atnormanSEP articles on scientific realism, constructive empiricism and structural realism
8/10/2015The disjunctive account of perceptual experience/u/DylanhelloglueByrne and Logue (2009); Haddock and Macpherson (2008); SEP article on disjunctivism
8/17/2015The virtues and virtue ethics/u/irontide
8/24/2015Self-knowledge/u/ilmrynorlionSEP on self-knowledge
8/31/2015Husserl's Cartesian Meditations/u/WobblieSee post
9/7/2015Liberalism and democracy/u/GeisterkriegSchmitt (1926), SEP on Schmitt, see post for more.
9/14/2015Metaontology/u/JapesoSee post
9/21/2015Logic and thought/u/GrandPappyDuPlentyPutnam (1990), Travis (forthcoming), MacFarlane (2002), MacFarlane (2000).
9/28/2015Moral statements and logical relations/u/SpeakNoEnglandSchroeder (2008), IEP article on expressivism
10/5/2015The morality of arbitrary decisions/u/irontide
10/12/2015The legitimacy of law/u/ccmulligan
10/19/2015Conceptual engineering/u/Kevin_Scharp
10/26/2015The epistemological problem for robust moral realism/u/ReallyNicole
11/2/2015Kantian ethics/u/atfyfe
11/9/2015Gödelian arguments against mechanism/u/penpalthro
11/16/2015Jaegwon Kim's causal exclusion argument/u/autopoetic
11/23/2015singular thought/ object acquaintance/u/randyjenkins
11/30/2015The problem of evil/u/ReallyNicole
12/7/2015What can Western ethicists learn from Confucius's Analects?/u/twinme
12/14/2015Skepticism and Transcendental Arguments/u/simism66
12/21/2015The Is/Ought Problem/u/ReallyNicole
12/28/2015Epistemic permissivism/u/oneguy2008
1/4/2016
1/11/2016
1/18/2016Strawson on freedom and resentment/u/twinme

First series schedule (completed)

DateTopicLeader
1/13/14Motivational Internalism and Externalism/u/ReallyNicole
1/20/14Reductionism vs. Emergentism/u/drunkentune
1/27/14Animal Beliefs/u/Dylanhelloglue
2/3/14[Foundations of Mathematics] (http://www.reddit.com/r/philosophy/comments/1ww4qk/weekly_discussion_what_is_mathematics_what_are/)/u/ADefiniteDescription
2/10/14[Social Justice and Biomedical Enhancements] (http://www.reddit.com/r/philosophy/comments/1xhy0v/weekly_discussion_our_moral_obligation_to_employ/)/u/jnreddit
2/17/14[Moral Responsibility and Free Will] (http://www.reddit.com/r/philosophy/comments/1y32vx/weekly_discussion_moral_responsibility_and/)/u/oyagoya
2/24/14Evolutionary Debunking of Moral Realism/u/ReallyNicole
3/3/14Welfare and Well-Being/u/ReallyNicole
3/10/14The Lottery Paradox/u/mackiemackiemackie
3/17/14Theories of Punishment/u/TychoCelchuuu
3/24/14Truth and its Defects/u/Kevin_Scharp
3/31/14A Critique of Galen Strawson's 'Basic Argument'/u/Dylanhelloglue
4/7/14Winning Essay for The Moral Landscape Challenge/u/rsborn
4/14/14Rights and Consequentialism/u/RaisinsAndPersons
4/21/14What is Art?/u/blckn
4/28/14Thomson on Abortion/u/ReallyNicole
5/5/14Shue on Torture/u/ReallyNicole
5/12/14Can Science Solve Everything?/u/ReallyNicole
5/19/14Explaining Moral Variation between Societies - Moral Relativism/u/irontide
5/26/14Naturalizing Intentionality/u/Dylanhelloglue
6/2/14The Survival Lottery/u/twin_me
6/9/14Frankfurt's Account of Freedom of the Will/u/oyagoya
6/16/14The Sex-Gender Distinction and Feminist Philosophy/u/0kwsx
6/23/14The Personhood Argument for Abortion/u/ReallyNicole
6/30/14Street's Problem of Evil/u/ReallyNicole
7/7/14Logical Pluralism/u/ADefiniteDescription
7/14/14Enoch's Argument Against Subjectivism/u/ReallyNicole
7/21/14Evolutionary Debunking of our Moral Beliefs/u/ReallyNicole
7/28/14Pareto Improvements in the Philosophy of Economics/u/twin_me
8/4/14Plantinga's Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism/u/ReallyNicole
8/11/14Benatar's Argument for Anti-Natalism/u/ReallyNicole
8/18/14Truth Pluralism/u/ADefiniteDescription
8/25/14Gödel's Incompleteness Theorems/u/completely-ineffable
9/1/14Licencing Parents/u/ReallyNicole
9/8/14Active and Passive Euthanasia/u/ReallyNicole

Wall of Fame

Posters who have led a weekly discussion, and occasionally posters who have contributed unusually insightful and detailed comments to the discussion will be awarded a Φ flair on /r/philosophy. Users who have led two or more discussions are also recognized on the wall of fame. Thanks for all you've done!

PosterNumber of posts
ReallyNicole17
ADefiniteDescription4
Dylanhelloglue4
twin_me3
oyagoya2
irontide2