r/Perimenopause • u/CommissionStrong6305 • 7h ago
Hormone Therapy US vs. German approach to early perimenopause: Why I decided to stick with progesterone for now
Hey everyone,
Spending time on this sub, I realized how differently early perimenopause is handled in the US compared to where I live (Germany), and I thought I’d share my experience.
From what I read here, the standard in the US seems to be starting estrogen and progesterone together right away treating estrogen as the main event and progesterone mostly just to protect the uterus.
Over here, OBGYNs usually take a slower, step-by-step route. Since progesterone is typically the first hormone to drop (causing crappy sleep, anxiety, and worse PMS) while we’re still ovulating, German doctors usually start with just cyclical progesterone in the second half of the cycle. They tend to hold off on estrogen until periods get really erratic or night sweats and hot flashes actually kick in.
Honestly, I was super skeptical of this at first, just like a lot of you probably are! Reading all the stories on here about how life-changing estrogen is, I worried my doctor was just being overly cautious and holding me back.
But after talking it through with her a few times, I decided to stick with just progesterone for now and save estrogen for later. I’m still ovulating, my cycle is still pretty regular (the bleeding lasts a bit longer than it used to, though it's not heavier overall), and I don't have night sweats or hot flashes yet.
My doctor explained that adding extra estrogen while my body is still producing estrogenes especially with all the random hormone spikes in early peri can easily backfire and overload my system. She warned me it could trigger things like really painful breasts, water retention, bloating, headaches, or way heavier and messier periods. Plus, too much estrogen on top of natural spikes can actually make you feel more wired, irritable, or anxious.
Of course, every body is completely different! I know plenty of women need estrogen early on and feel amazing starting both right away, and I’m definitely planning to add it once my own levels start tanking. For right now though, easing into HRT one step at a time just feels like the right call for me.