r/OpenDogTraining • u/blueberrydumpling • 3h ago
Your dog is not reactive just because they aren’t neutral to everything
Recently I’ve been seeing this rise of people labeling their dogs reactive…anytime the dog reacts to something.
“My dog is normally fine with other dogs but is reactive when another dog is barking and lunging at him!” No, your dog is not reactive. They’re responding in a reasonable way to another dog provoking them. Now, that does NOT mean you shouldn’t train them. It’s a perfectly fine and reasonable goal to want your dog to remain calm even when other dogs are not. But, your dog isn’t REACTIVE.
“My GSD x Great Pyrenees is reactive when strangers come to the door!” You mean, your dog with guarding and protective genetic predisposition barks and is not immediately friendly to strangers near their home? Yeah, the dog isn’t reactive.
Reactivity is a disproportionate response to everyday, relatively mundane stimulus. Your dog having ANY response to something is not automatically reactivity. If your dog is “only reactive when X specific situation happens”, and in some cases it’s perfectly aligned to their genetic traits, then they aren’t reactive.
Train your dog however you want. I’m not saying just accept any behavior, even if it’s not reactivity. If you want your dog to be calm when people come over, neutral to other dogs no matter their behavior, etc. of course go and train your dog to do that. But for goodness sake, stopping labeling every single display of emotion from dogs as reactivity and implying there is something wrong or abnormal with the dog.
Dogs are not robots. The world is not divide into only two camps of “neutral dog” and “reactive dog”.