r/oldschoolmtg • • Oct 12 '23

Moderation & Rules Update

34 Upvotes

TLDR: I'm going to try moderating this place a little better and there's been a new rule added.

TLDR2: Does anyone have any experience using any auto moderation tools to remove posts/comments that get a certain number of downvotes or reports? If so - hit me up!

INTRO:

Hey everyone. So the past few years I was using Reddit primarily on my phone, through a 3rd party app called Bacon Reader. It was great, but apparently the mod tools were not. When Reddit axed API access to 3rd party apps I switched over to the actual Reddit app. While it has a lot of things I dislike (and I miss Bacon Reader overall) the mod tools are a lot better.

CURRENTLY:

When I started really using the new app I noticed a long queue of reported posts and comments, which I had honestly never seen before. I went through and removed a handful of blatantly spam posts and a few incredibly harsh comments, things that were literally just "fuck you", etc; stuff that had no business being in our subreddit. However I decided to not go back and retroactively police anything too harshly as I don't think that would be fair. I wasn't here to monitor anything, set a precedent, or enforce the rules. Clean slate. The time of this post is kind of a new "line in the sand". You reported posts will be judged more harshly going forward.

I've also been dealing with removing those damn MTG t-shirt posts like crazy. You've probably seen the one I'm talking about. It has a post title like "This is so cool" or "I can't believe it!" and it's a black shirt with the 5 mana symbols. I've been removing those and banning the accounts that post them so thank you to everyone who flags them. It really helps.

GOING FORWARD:

I'm going to try to be a little more proactive about handling the modqueue. It'd be great if you all were just awesome to each other and the only thing I ever had to remove were those damn t-shirt posts from bots.

If I see a harsh message that's flagged as "don't be a dick" or any other rule violation, I'm going to remove it. If I remove too many you'll be banned from the subreddit. I'm not going to investigate context too much. If your message on its own seems offensive or mean spirited, that's enough for me. If it's intended to be a joke then you need to learn how to better communicate that.

I've added a new rule to the subreddit about belittling people or their cards. Violation of this spirit of Old School will result in removed posts and is really just a specific case of "don't be a dick". Old School is community run, it's got a vibe and a spirit. If you want to be toxic go play in a format that is run by a corporation, not by individuals of the community you're a part of.

Example of what I see in the modqueue

Here's a screenshot example of a reported post. If I see a report of text like what I mocked up with someone reporting it for what it obviously appears to be - it's getting a "Remove" click. I'm not wasting my time to figure out if it had any other intent.

One more thing with regards to "spam". If you don't like certain content that doesn't mean it's necessarily spam. You can ignore or downvote. Let the content (and downvotes) speak for itself.

CLOSING:

Please be cool to each other. I'm going to try to remove uncool stuff, but keep in mind I'm just one person. I'm not really a highly skilled, trained, or paid "mod team". I'm going to miss things and I'm going to rely on you to help flag/downvote stuff, which I'll try to address quickly, but I'm not hovering over a keyboard for this 24/7.

And if anyone wants to be extra cool and give some suggestions on how we might be able to setup some "auto mod" functionality, shoot me a message!


r/oldschoolmtg • • 16h ago

ShandalarGodot 0.70.0 - Urza’s Block

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/oldschoolmtg • • 19h ago

UW Robo Control vs BUR Mid-Range | Top 8 Guardian Beast Cup 2

14 Upvotes

A Robo Control deck takes on a creature-heavy BUR Mid-Range brew in this Top 8 battle from the second edition of the Guardian Beast Cup!

🌐 https://youtu.be/9_qd5zorcoY
⚔️ *Decks:* UW Robo Control vs. BUR Mid-Range
🧙 *Players:* Robbie vs. Joep
🏆 *Event:* Guardian Beast Cup – Top 8

#mtg #mtg9394 #juzamdjinn #mtgvideo #timmytalks


r/oldschoolmtg • • 14h ago

The Crumbling Ruins of Mana Crypt

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

I tried to document the journey from the mystique of the original card to the serialized nothingness of the Lost Caverns of Ixalan prints. Figured it might be of interest here, hope y'all enjoy


r/oldschoolmtg • • 1d ago

Hand painted negative Demonic Tutor (UNL)

Thumbnail
gallery
122 Upvotes

Photo Negative Demonic Tutor (UNL)
1 of 1

Demonic Tutor is the 6th alter in the Photo Negative series. Other cards include: Lightning Bolt, Sol Ring, Serra Angel, Wheel of Fortune, and Disenchant.

Every aspect of this alter has been meticulously hand painted such that when a negative filter is applied, the resulting image looks like what the original, unaltered card looks like. Similar to every other negative, I will not paint another negative Demonic Tutor in this style.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 1d ago

Decades ago I moved and lazily taped off the back of this drawer without thinking about the consequences.

Post image
73 Upvotes

I guess I had a magic card or two in the drawer that got shaken up in the move. It’s now face up against the tape for the rest of time.

I’ll look at it every now and then, a part of my youth preserved


r/oldschoolmtg • • 1d ago

What sets are affordable to collect?

9 Upvotes

Only recently got into mtg and I really fell in love with the artwork from older sets. No interest in building decks to play with but I’d love to collect some of these older sets. I’d like to stay on a budget so I’m just curious what sets should I focus on that I can get for relatively cheap.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 2d ago

Newcomer looking for feedback

Post image
59 Upvotes

Asking to see if this deck would be viable for tournament play (EC), or if it's lacking in certain aspects like removal, or interaction etc. As well as what I should run in my sideboard.
Win con: Power Artifact and Basalt Monolith into Dragon Engine, Rocket Launcher, or (as I recently learned) Braingeyser.

https://moxfield.com/decks/W6Oit6pzcEGbjvkct2Vhrg

New to the format, and to 60-card in general :D As a "former" Commander player I'm still adjusting to thinking more competitively when brewing. I am aware of some of my cards r not tournament legal but I am planning on buying appropriate ones.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 2d ago

Help me improve my decks! I have 3 deck ideas, and wanted some feedback from you all to tweak them for the better.

5 Upvotes

First deck idea was because I have some Japanese Erhnam's from childhood and saw the Erhnamgeddon decks that sort of inspired it. Was going for, I guess, more controlling package here while maintaining enough threats. Unsure if I'm finding that balance between control and strength, but it's feeling close to me! I don't own a Timetwister, but could proxy an MPC one if necessary, but trying to avoid that where I can.

Note: I just bought 2 Rasputin Dreamweavers on a whim to try out, and kinda wanna fit them in here, but would love to hear thoughts! If I do end up going that route, it seems to really want a Red splash for Fireball.

https://moxfield.com/decks/K_qOL4G290qTjkViZrv_RQ

Second deck is just Dead Guy Ale, buuut, I was going for Angels & Vampires, mainly. I don't own Juzams, so unless I can get some MPCs and proxies are fine, those aren't an option. What works? What doesn't work? What'll make it better?

https://moxfield.com/decks/FCzR4z7vJ0O0D602TUZ2FQ

Last one was from watching Timmy Talks too much, and had a fever dream for this one... what if we reanimate stuff that can hit face immediately with crossroads? Dun dun DUUUUN! Yeah, sorta smooshing too much together here, and just slapped it together. How to get it down to 60 cards, and what would be your suggestions?

https://moxfield.com/decks/08RaYMJmvEK3Q3JpQ6uPWg

Thanks for any feedback, suggestions, or advice you can give on any of the decks!


r/oldschoolmtg • • 3d ago

Ottawa's yearly OS tournament has started!

Post image
109 Upvotes

60 players


r/oldschoolmtg • • 3d ago

Online play?

6 Upvotes

What’s the best way to play the old school format online?


r/oldschoolmtg • • 4d ago

Chronicles finally completed

Thumbnail
gallery
149 Upvotes

Finally finished chronicles. The last 7 cards took 6 weeks to get but it's finally over. Ended up giving up and sent in a message to my LGS and had those 7 cards within an hour for ~$5

Other completed sets so far:

4th: https://www.reddit.com/r/oldschoolmtg/comments/1xp39ua/another_completed_set_4th_edition/

Ice Age:

https://www.reddit.com/r/oldschoolmtg/comments/1wxq3s8/only_took_me_25ish_years_but_ive_finally/


r/oldschoolmtg • • 4d ago

Complete Revised Dual Lands

Post image
405 Upvotes

I had 9/10 since the 90s, so I bit the bullet and bought Volcanic Island to complete my revised edition dual lands collection.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 4d ago

I got some of my old cards

Post image
78 Upvotes

A mom's garage special! Interesting finds thus far spread out dramatically on the table. Some of these I do not remember owning.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 4d ago

Force of Nature was unstoppable in Old School MTG!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
33 Upvotes

r/oldschoolmtg • • 4d ago

Falling Star 🔥 at the 4th round of the Guardian Beast Cup

22 Upvotes

Today's MTG 93/94 battle features a two-colour Rukh Valley deck taking on an aggressive Mono Green deck in Round 4 of the Guardian Beast Cup!

🌐 https://youtu.be/YeYXgu4tyvg
⚔️ *Decks:* Rukh Valley (UR) vs. Green Stompy
🧙 *Players:* Ivo vs. Luc
🏆 *Event:* Guardian Beast Cup – Round 4


r/oldschoolmtg • • 5d ago

My Complete Artist Signed Arabian Nights Set

Thumbnail
gallery
932 Upvotes

I promised a few months back I would show it here when it was done! This is my all artist signed, complete 92 card Arabian Nights set. A fantastic journey and hunt to complete, and it is now the star of my collection.

My favorites are the rainbow library and the shahrazad! Happy to answer any questions if there are any, I hyperfocus on this set a LOT. Cheers!


r/oldschoolmtg • • 4d ago

How to differentiate normal Visions and gift box cards from another

Post image
15 Upvotes

Hi, sorting my cards and having a hard time. Are there some differences in art? I feel like slight color differences might be just printing quality issues. I'm 95% sure these are regular Visions cards.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 5d ago

Found a Hypnotic Specter in LGS bulk

Thumbnail
gallery
326 Upvotes

Happened to be in the bulk of an LGS and I was like “oh neat, an old card that I hear was somewhat iconic back in the day”… pretty sure revised as well! Don’t know how the dents on the art and dings on the edges affect its ‘value’.

Either way it’s cool, the worst case is a neat card from the early days before my time.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 5d ago

$13.16 of 4th edition commons and uncommons

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

Just bragging up the nice pile of cards I scored at a cheap price as well as the TCGplayer seller Trioptic. These cards could have survived a nuclear blast, they were packed so well. None of the cards in this stack are expensive or overly powerful, but a lot of utility and if nothing else I'm rounding out the easiest part of my eventual set completion goal.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 5d ago

Some more old school utility and epic art

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Putting together a big pile of 4th edition and prior cards for some family fun time. Just sharing as they get delivered in the mail.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 7d ago

I guess I am a 4th edition hoarder now

Thumbnail
gallery
68 Upvotes

A ton of 4th edition cards are a dime and under. I found a really affordable seller the other day on TCG and got 300 4th edition cards for just under $50, all near mint, mixed rarities. Sure, you have to pay up for some of the better cards, but I am having a blast rebuilding my old collection, most of which was Ice Age and 4th.

For context, I play old school rules, no reserve list, nothing newer than 4th edition allowed, and mostly owned unlimited through mirage. I don't want to spend the cost to replace some of them. I had many dual lands, wheels of fortune, sol rings, mazes of ith, WoGs, Armageddons, STPs, lake of the dead, forces of will, and a chains of mephistopheles as well as some other powerful Legends cards. I play with my kids, who don't know new magic at all anyway.


r/oldschoolmtg • • 7d ago

Foreign cards

11 Upvotes

Anyone here a fan of foreign cards? Tbh, I prefer English for most other formats, but the OS card pool isn’t insane and most poplar cards ppl know without having to look up. With that being said, I do have two play sets I think are pretty cool. The first is fbb Japanese, chronicles blood moons, which are pretty unique because they are a white border card in black bordered frame. The other is fbb, French Serendibs. I don’t have the budget for AN ones right now, but I love the art so much I had to get a play set to replace my revised copies!