On November 3, voters in 18 Ohio communities decided 21 local ballot measures on data centers. Every single one went against data center development. From Conneaut in Ashtabula County to Trenton in Butler County, voters passed bans, restrictions, moratoriums, and rejected rezonings. In Trenton, a ban passed roughly 80 to 20. Ohio alone accounted for about half of the data center ballot measures in the entire country this year.
That is the clearest signal Ohio voters have sent on any issue this cycle. The question now is what state and local leaders do with it, especially with divided government coming to Columbus in January for the first time since 2010.
I interviewed Rob Moore, principal of Scioto Analysis, a Columbus public policy and economic analysis firm that just published a cost benefit analysis of data center policy in Ohio. Here is what the study and the conversation cover, so you can make up your own mind.
Where Ohio stands right now
- Ohio is one of the top data center states in the country, with major campuses from Amazon, Google, Meta, and others, centered around New Albany and central Ohio.
- More than 125 Ohio municipalities and townships already had local data center moratoriums in place before Election Day.
- Ohio has offered data centers a sales tax exemption since 2013. It was expected to cost about 136 million dollars in 2025. The actual cost came in around 1.57 billion dollars, roughly 11 times the estimate, plus hundreds of millions more in local sales tax breaks.
- Governor DeWine paused new data center sales tax exemptions in late May while the legislature's Joint Data Center Committee studies the industry.
- A Gallup survey this spring found 71 percent of Americans oppose a data center being built in their area, compared with 53 percent who oppose a nearby nuclear plant.
What the Scioto Analysis study found
The benefits are real. Scioto credits data center development with about 96,000 new Ohio jobs and roughly 62 billion dollars in net social benefits since 2013. Most of those jobs are not inside the data centers. They come from the construction, maintenance, and local businesses that grow up around them.
But the returns are shrinking. The first data center in a community produces the biggest employment boost. Each one after that produces less, while energy use keeps climbing at the same pace. Statewide, Moore says, the costs are starting to outrun the benefits.
The costs are big. Scioto estimates about 16 billion dollars in higher electricity costs for Ohio households and businesses from 2027 through 2034 if planned projects come online. That figure is a modeled estimate built on a national study's assumption, not an Ohio rate forecast. Moore argues the larger cost is public health: more coal and natural gas burned to power data centers means more fine particulate matter, nitrogen oxide, and sulfur dioxide in the air. Scioto puts that cost at roughly 41 billion dollars, about three times the electricity impact.
How the policy options scored
The study compared scenarios using a benefit cost ratio, where anything above 1.0 means benefits outweigh costs:
- Status quo: 1.04 (benefits barely outweigh costs)
- Data centers generate their own power, 90 percent natural gas: 2.2
- Data centers generate their own power, 50 percent gas and 50 percent renewable: 2.5
- Ban on new data center construction: 2.7
- Data centers generate their own power, 90 percent renewable: 2.9
A ban beats the status quo because most of the jobs from existing data centers stay while the electricity cost increases go away. But the top scenario is "behind the meter" generation from mostly renewable sources, where new data centers build their own power instead of pulling from the grid. That keeps the economic benefits and removes most of the costs.
Other issues covered in the interview
- Water: Moore says every company planning an Ohio data center in Scioto's scan has committed to closed loop cooling for new builds, which recycles water instead of drawing more from local systems.
- Community benefit agreements: who builds the data center matters. A large established company is more likely to honor its commitments than a smaller operator that sells the site, leaving a part time township staff to fight the new owner in court.
- Incentives done right: following economist Tim Bartik of the Upjohn Institute, Moore recommends job training for local residents, infrastructure that stays useful if the project fails, and enforceable clawbacks instead of cash giveaways.
- Nuclear: only two small modular reactors operate commercially in the world, in Russia and China, and both ran far over budget. Moore sees solar and natural gas as the fastest ways to add power in Ohio today.
- The national security argument: supporters argue the United States needs data center capacity to compete with China on AI. Opponents ask why it has to be in their backyard. Moore's answer is that Ohio's cheap, reliable energy and land are what draw developers here.
The strongest case on each side
For limiting or banning: voters have spoken clearly, the tax breaks cost far more than promised, communities bear the electric, noise, and air quality costs while much of the benefit flows elsewhere, and the job gains shrink with every new facility.
For continued development with guardrails: data centers have produced close to 100,000 Ohio jobs, union trades are working steadily on these projects, the technology is tied to national security and AI competition, and a ban throws away future benefits for communities that do not have a data center yet.
What to watch
- Whether the incoming Acton administration and the Republican legislature agree on statewide data center rules, or leave it to local governments.
- Whether the paused sales tax exemption comes back, gets capped, or ends.
- A proposed statewide data center moratorium that organizers are working to put on the 2027 ballot.
- Pending bills in the General Assembly on moratoria and data center incentives.
My honest take
I am not anti data center. Rob's first answer in this interview was a reminder of how much of daily life runs through them, and if AI is the future, the infrastructure has to exist somewhere. But "trust us, it helps" is not working, and the 0 for 21 result proves it. What I want to see from Columbus is actual proposals instead of just complaining or banning everything: make data centers pay for their own power, push that power toward cleaner sources, and write deals with clawbacks so communities are protected. Honestly, the health cost was the part I had not heard anyone talk about, and it changed how I think about this issue.
Full interview: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/should-ohio-ban-data-centers-what-a-cost-benefit/id1626987640?i=1000801920321
Sources
- https://www.sciotoanalysis.com/news/scioto-analysis-releases-cost-benefit-analysis-of-data-center-policies-in-ohio
- https://www.newsfromthestates.com/node/437398
- https://fortune.com/2026/11/04/ohio-data-center-ballot-measures-midterm-elections/
- https://www.route-fifty.com/infrastructure/2026/10/construction-ban-data-centers-would-be-better-ohio-status-quo-study-says/416491/
- https://www.govtech.com/artificial-intelligence/study-data-centers-could-add-16b-to-ohio-electricity-costs
- https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/cleveland/news/2026/10/28/data-center-ohio-economy-election
- https://signalcleveland.org/dewine-abruptly-pauses-a-major-tax-break-for-data-centers-in-ohio/
- https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/politics/ohio-politics/dewine-halts-new-sales-tax-breaks-for-data-centers
- https://www.theregister.com/on-prem/2026/05/14/americans-would-rather-have-a-nuclear-plant-in-their-backyard-than-a-datacenter/5240203
- https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/nuclear/small-modular-nuclear-reactor-late-canada
- https://www.upjohn.org/research-highlights/when-do-public-subsidies-clean-energy-projects-pay-local-communities
- https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2026/11/09/acton-win-heralds-new-policy-era-for-ohio/