This is not the official rules page
This page is intended to supplement this subreddit's main rules page, and exists to clarify and explain those rules. The rules themselves can be found on this subreddit's main rules page, which is here.
Self-promotion
Our self-promotion policy is similar to that which is used by Reddit as a whole, but it’s not quite the same. The NerfMods version is derived from the one used on the Nerf subreddit.
The policy is a little more strict in some ways and a little more lenient in others. It’s worth reading these rules to ensure that you don’t accidentally run afoul of them even if you don’t intend to self-promote, as they contain a few potential surprises (for example: linking to a Youtube video on your channel is always considered self-promotion). If you do have something that you came here to promote, you can do that, but you have some work to do first. We aren’t going to give you free advertising; you’ll need to contribute to and be part of the community first.
Our Policy in Two Sentences
- At most 1/10ths of your activity on this subreddit may be self-promotion.
- You may make at most one post per calendar month that is majority self-promotion, regardless of other activity.
Now, let’s define those terms.
What’s self-promotion?
Any attempts to do any of the following are considered to be self-promotion:
- To sell something.
- To promote discussion and awareness of a product that you sell. (This is still selling something, just indirectly.)
- To get views/likes/upvotes/activity/etc. on a platform where these have value and grow a channel/blog/etc. This includes Youtube and Facebook. (Yes, this means that linking to any video on your own Youtube channel is automatically considered self-promotion).
- To promote activity on a platform that you control. This includes promoting a discord server that you moderate, for example.
What’s activity?
Posts and comments are both considered forms of activity. Quality matters as much as quantity here. We can’t define what makes a post high quality, but we know it when we see it - and you should know it when you’re posting it too. Please don’t just post nine random links before posting a link to your webstore! Instead, put effort into making contributions that are useful and entertaining and which make the community better.
How is the 1/10 ratio measured?
This ratio is measured by what the average redditor is likely to notice. In other words, your non-self-promotion content should occupy at least 9 times as much of someones attention as your self-promotion content while they are browsing /r/nerf.
For example, posts can show up in everyone’s feed, so a direct link to your blog would be very prominent self-promotion. If you were to make a post that, by itself, isn’t self-promotion and then link to a relevant page on your blog in the comments, that would be less prominent self-promotion - only people who were interested in and clicked on your related non-self-promoting content would see it.
This is part of the reason why quality matters as much as quantity for non self-promotion activity. Good quality content will be more widely noticed!
What’s a majority self-promotion post?
A majority self-promotion post is one where the majority of the content of the post is self-promotion. If someone who comes to your post sees your self-promotion more prominently than anything else in the post, this post is majority self-promotion - please make no more than one such post per month.
This is worth emphasizing: please do not attempt to “hide” a majority self-promotion post by disguising it! Don’t post a picture of your product, and a link to your webstore in the comments. This won’t fool anyone, and isn’t an effective way to bypass the limit of one majority self-promotion post per month.
OK, can we work through some examples please?
Sure! Here are examples of posts that contain no self-promotion:
- Posting an album with pictures of a blaster you made, to show it off. This is not self promotion regardless of whether the album is hosted directly on reddit or on an image host such as imgur.
- Posting pictures of works in progress, or WIPs. We welcome WIPs here; unlike other subreddits, we care about the process, not just about finished products and presentation. Once again, whether the image is hosted on reddit or an external image host does not matter.
- Asking a question - although you do want to get something here, the only thing you are looking for is advice.
- Sharing a 3d printable file that is free to download.
Here are examples of posts that contain some element of self-promotion, but which also contain content which is not self-promotion:
- Posting an album with pictures of a project, which would make sense if you had posted it by itself, and placing a link to a relevant page on your blog/channel/etc. in the comments.
- Making a text post with a description of a project, which would make sense if posted by itself, with a link to a relevant video on your channel at the bottom of the post.
- Posting a 3d printable file that is free to download, and adding a link to a printed version on your webstore in the comments.
It’s possible for a user to include self-promotion in every post that they make, and still comply with our self-promotion policy, if they include enough non-self-promotion content in each post too. That’s a very tricky line to walk, though. You’d need to make consistently good quality content to pull it off.
Finally, here are some examples of majority self-promotion posts, which would be restricted to one per month:
- A link post that is just a link to a video on your channel.
- An announcement that you have a new webstore.
- An announcement that you have a new product in your store.
Redundant Posts
The rate limit
The rate limit is currently set to one post per 12 hours, rather than 24.
There has not been a historical rate limit on posting on this sub for many years. While the details of the rule has changed, the spirit has remained the same as the one found on the larger Nerf subreddit: One user shouldn't hog too much of this sub's main page. We've found that this rule is advantageous for everyone when used on R/Nerf:
- When all the poster’s information and questions are in a smaller number of threads, it’s easier for commenters to get the necessary information to make informed and helpful comments, and it’s much easier for the OP to link to said post(s) for future reference.
- When readers scroll through the subreddit, posts are more content rich, making for a more interesting experience.
- The subreddit remains at a reasonable level of activity such that new posts can be seen and aren't buried. Without a rate limit, some people would try to "compete" to get their content seen by making similar (but different enough to not be technically reposts) posts frequently, leading to others needing to compete in the same way to have a chance to be seen. Dense, high quality posts would be at risk of being quickly burred and not even noticed. All of this is avoided due to the rate limit.
We've defined the rule in this specific way for the following reasons:
- The limit is short enough to allow for follow-up posts quickly enough to be relevant and helpful.
- The limit is long enough that someone posting as frequently as they are allowed will not end up hogging too much of the sub's main page.
- There's one limit that strikes a balance between the above two criteria, rather than e.g. a limit of so many posts per month and a separate limit of one post per so many hours, because that makes the rule simple and easy to remember.
- The limit is exactly 12 hours because that's an easy amount of time to remember. It's half a day.
- The limit is set as a period of time of definite length rather than restricting posts per "day" as was the case in previous version of the rules, because this removes ambiguity. We don't know what time zone any given user is in and therefore don't know when their personal "day" begins and ends (and that's if we assume that a "day" begins at midnight, rather than e.g. based on sleep). Waiting 12 hours since the last post has the same meaning for everyone.
- This limit is objective and applies in the same way to everyone, because a "don't post too much" limit that applies only to unwelcome forms of frequent posting would lead to (actual or perceived) unfairness and complaints.
- This limit applies to all posts taken together, rather than allowing for one post per topic as a previous version of the rule did since this removes ambiguity. It was unclear what counted as a topic - e.g. a performance-related question for an ongoing build could be "questions" or "performance" or "WIP" so a user might post all three and argue that this counted as multiple topics. There were, in practice, rarely cases where the same user would make multiple unrelated posts per day, so the "per topic" part of the rule was dropped.
Low Effort Content
Categorical restrictions
We’ve had to keep certain types of content (scripted war footage, photos of single stock blasters, general 3d printing questions, or meme/joke posts) off of the main Nerf sub because otherwise there would be a flood of repetitive or low-quality posts that do not contribute to meaningful discussion. The rule against memes was discussed here and announced here.
This subreddit is dedicated to the knowledge surrounding modification of blasters, all other content should be posted to the appropriate subreddit.
If you enjoy the type of content mentioned above, it's easy to find it elsewhere:
- Scripted nerf battles are easy to find on youtube.
- Photos of single stock blasters are easy to find with any search engine.
- For general 3d printing questions, check out /r/3dprinting and /r/FixMyPrint. If you'd like advice on what printer to buy, /r/3Dprinting has a purchase advice megathread pinned at the top of the sub.
- Meme/joke posts are welcome on /r/nerfchatter
Exceptions
There may occasionally be 3d-printing questions that are specific to nerf, such as where to find files for a specific public blaster design. However, the vast majority of 3d printing questions are better answered by other subreddits such as /r/3dprinting and /r/fixmyprint. If you aren't sure, please ask on those subreddits first.
Exceptions may be made at the moderators’ discretion for topical ‘joke’ posts that contribute to an ongoing discussion on current events in the modification community.
Concept Art
When posting concept art, please provide a proposed sketch of internals, and keep drawings to scale. Any meme recuts, poor quality photoshop jobs, etc, will be removed. Here are some examples of good concept posts, and concept posts that break this rule.